Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 22;2019(11):CD011287. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011287.pub2

1. Characteristics of dietary interventions, outcomes, and length of follow‐up.

Author and date Personnel providing dietary intervention Description of intervention Method of dietary assessment Frequency of contact Outcomes recorded Follow‐up length Nutritional status at recruitment Behavioural change therapy Control or comparison group
Befort 2016 Registered dietitian or psychologist Phase 1: 25‐week 60‐minute conference call sessions delivered to groups of 12 to 15 women. Phase 2: 26 biweekly conference calls Not reported Weekly Anthropometry changes, participant costs, incremental cost‐effectiveness 18 months Not reported Not reported Provided 
 9 newsletters with the same content as intervention calls
Bloom 2008 Trained healthcare
professional
Three 6‐hour group workshops Fruit and vegetable and fat screener questionnaires Monthly QoL,
knowledge,
dietary changes
6 months Not reported Not reported Usual care
Bourke 2011 Exercise physiologist Nutrition advice pack and healthy eating seminars with supervised home‐based exercise sessions 3‐Day food diary Weekly QoL, dietary and anthropometry changes 12 weeks Not reported Not reported Usual care
Demark‐Wahnefried 2006 Dietitian/
counsellors
Personalised workbook of diet and physical activity targets given on the basis of individual intake. Supported by telephone counselling 3‐Day diet recall 12 bimonthly 20‐ to 30‐minute sessions over
 6 months Anthropometry, physical function, diet quality 6 months and
 12 months Nil Transtheoretical
model, social‐cognitive theory
General written material
Demark‐Wahnefried 2007 Mail‐based Tailored mailed dietary material on increasing fruits and vegetables, reducing total fat, increasing exercise, providing lifestyle advice Telephone interviews using diet history questionnaire 7 newsletters at 6‐weekly intervals Anthropometry, behaviour and dietary change,
QoL
1 year &
2 years
Not reported Transtheoretical
model, social‐cognitive theory
General written material
Demark‐Wahnefried 2014 Not reported Personalized workbook with goal‐setting. Advice on specific dietary intake and physical activity 24‐Hour recall Telephone interviews at
 3 time points Dietary intake,
anthropometry,
QoL
12
months
BMI ≥ 25 to
39.9
Social‐cognitive theory Written material
Djuric 2002 Dietitian Individualised counselling via
telephone contact provided
3‐Day food diary Counselling: weekly for first
 3 months, biweekly for months 3 to 6, then monthly up to 30 months Dietary intake, anthropometry 12 months Not reported Social‐cognitive theory Written materials
Djuric 2002 Weight watchers groups Weight watchers meetings only 3‐Day food diary Weekly Anthropometry and dietary changes 12 months Not reported Not reported Written materials
Ghavami 2017 Researcher but not specified Individualised intervention promoting prescribed exercise (moderate exercise 3 to 5 days per week) and a balanced diet through stage‐matched telephone counselling and a workbook Not reported Weekly QoL 24 weeks BMI > 25 Not reported Usual care
Greenlee 2013 Staff trained under the CURVE programme Group weight loss programme Food frequency questionnaire 110‐item 3‐ to 5‐day/week exercise
1‐hour nutrition course/week
Anthropometry, metabolic and dietary changes 12 months BMI ≥ 25 Not reported Waiting list
Greenlee 2015 Registered dietitian, nutritionist, chef 9 group sessions (24 hours over 12 weeks) of nutrition intervention with culturally tailored curriculum 24‐Hour dietary recall Weekly/
monthly
Anthropometry, dietary changes 12 months BMI 30.6 Social‐cognitive theory, transtheoretical model Booklets on healthy eating
Gruenigen 2012 Dietitian Individualised goal‐setting enabling self‐efficacy.
Group sessions for nutrition and physical activity advice plus face‐to‐face counselling sessions
24‐Hour recall 10 weekly sessions followed by 6 biweekly sessions plus face‐to‐face counselling Anthropometry and dietary changes 12 months BMI 25.0 to 39.9 vs > 40 in control Social‐cognitive theory Written material
Harrigan 2016 Registered dietitian In‐person counselling about nutrition, expertise, behaviour strategies Food frequency questionnaire Once per week (for month), then every second week (for months 2 and 3), then once per month (for months
 4 to 6) Anthropometry, dietary changes, biochemical changes, physical activity 6 months BMI 33.5 vs 34 in control Social‐cognitive theory  
Harrigan 2016 Registered dietitian Telephone counselling about nutrition, expertise, behaviour strategies Food frequency questionnaire Once per week (for month), then every second week (for months 2 and 3), then once per month (for months
 4 to 6) Anthropometry, dietary changes, biochemical changes, physical activity 6 months BMI 31.8 Social‐cognitive theory  
Hawkes 2013 Health coach Telephone health coaching focused on physical activity, weight management, dietary habits, smoking Food frequency questionnaire 11 phone sessions over
 6 months Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL 6 months BMI ≥ 25 Acceptance commitment therapy, mindfulness Usual care
Kanera 2017 Web‐based Web‐based self‐management program with modules on diet, physical activity, depression, others Dutch standard questionnaire on food consumption 4 weeks after diet Dietary changes, physical activity 12 months BMI 26.0 Theory of planned behaviour, self‐regulated theory. integrated model of change Usual care (waiting list)
Kim 2011 Trained nurses Workbook and individualised prescription for regular exercise and diet
30‐minute telephone calls
3‐Day dietary recall, diet quality tool Weekly Dietary changes, Diet Quality Index, QoL, behavioural changes 12 weeks Not reported Transtheoretical model Usual care
Mefferd 2007 Trained research assistant Group exercise and diet modification sessions using behavioural treatment, weekly phone calls Food diaries self‐monitored Weekly sessions followed by once‐monthly sessions, then monthly sessions for
 6 months Anthropometry changes 16 weeks BMI ≥ 25 Cognitive‐behavioural therapy Waiting list
Morey 2009 Health counsellor PersonaIised tailored workbook and series of quarterly newsletters, along with a programme of telephone counselling and automated prompts 24‐Hour dietary recall Weekly and monthly telephone and counselling sessions over 12 months Anthropometry changes, functionality 12 months BMI ≥ 25 and ≤ 40 Transtheoretical
model, social‐cognitive theory
Usual care
Park 2016 Mail‐based Mail‐based lifestyle intervention Paffenbarger activity questionnaire Biweekly for 4 months Dietary changes, feasibility, and adherence 7 months Not reported Addressed behavioural skills but no specific therapy reported Usual care
Pierce 2007 Trained counsellors Telephone counselling. Phase 1: build self‐efficacy to implement dietary targets. Phase 2: focus on self‐monitoring and barriers to adherence. Phase 3: focus on motivation
12 cooking classes were offered plus newsletters
24‐Hour dietary recall Average 18 counselling calls, 12 cooking classes, and 12 study newsletters. By 4 years, average
 31 calls and 48 newsletters received Overall survival, incidence of secondary cancer, comorbidities, anthropometry, dietary changes 4 years Not reported Social‐cognitive theory Writen materials
Reeves 2017 Dietitian Posted materials and telephone calls 24‐Hour diet recall Posted materials and up to 16 calls over 6 months Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL 6 months BMI ≥ 25 to 45 Not reported Usual care
Scott 2013 Trained technician Individual hypocaloric eating and supervised exercise sessions 3‐Day diet diary Weekly Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL 24 weeks BMI ≥ 25 Not reported Written material
Sheppard 2016 Exercise physiologist, nutritionist, survivor coach Group and individualised phone sessions 4‐Day food diary Every 2 weeks group session, phone calls on the weeks in between Anthropometry changes, physiological function, QoL, biochemical changes 12 weeks BMI ≥ 25 and ≤ 40 Motivational
interviewing technique
General health information
Swisher 2015 Dietitian, exercise physiologist Supervised and unsupervised exercise sessions, 2 individual dietary sessions 3‐Day food diary 3 times/week supervised
2 times unsupervised
Anthropometry changes, physical function, QoL, biochemical changes 12 weeks BMI ≥ 25 Not reported Written materials
Yun 2017 Trained health professional 1‐hour health education session, 3‐hour leadership workshop, individual coaching by phone for 24 weeks Validated questionnaire based on the Rules for National Cancer Prevention: dietary practice guideline Weekly/monthly for different sessions Physical activity, dietary changes, QoL, cancer survivors leadership 12 months BMI 22.05 Transtheoretical model Usual care
Zick 2017 Registered dietitian Individualised phone counselling 24‐Hour dietary recall Weekly for 4 weeks, then biweekly Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL, biochemical changes 3 months BMI 27.2 vs 29.2 Brandura's social‐cognitive theory General health curriculum sessions