1. Characteristics of dietary interventions, outcomes, and length of follow‐up.
Author and date | Personnel providing dietary intervention | Description of intervention | Method of dietary assessment | Frequency of contact | Outcomes recorded | Follow‐up length | Nutritional status at recruitment | Behavioural change therapy | Control or comparison group |
Befort 2016 | Registered dietitian or psychologist | Phase 1: 25‐week 60‐minute conference call sessions delivered to groups of 12 to 15 women. Phase 2: 26 biweekly conference calls | Not reported | Weekly | Anthropometry changes, participant costs, incremental cost‐effectiveness | 18 months | Not reported | Not reported | Provided 9 newsletters with the same content as intervention calls |
Bloom 2008 | Trained healthcare professional |
Three 6‐hour group workshops | Fruit and vegetable and fat screener questionnaires | Monthly | QoL, knowledge, dietary changes |
6 months | Not reported | Not reported | Usual care |
Bourke 2011 | Exercise physiologist | Nutrition advice pack and healthy eating seminars with supervised home‐based exercise sessions | 3‐Day food diary | Weekly | QoL, dietary and anthropometry changes | 12 weeks | Not reported | Not reported | Usual care |
Demark‐Wahnefried 2006 | Dietitian/ counsellors |
Personalised workbook of diet and physical activity targets given on the basis of individual intake. Supported by telephone counselling | 3‐Day diet recall | 12 bimonthly 20‐ to 30‐minute sessions over 6 months | Anthropometry, physical function, diet quality | 6 months and 12 months | Nil | Transtheoretical model, social‐cognitive theory |
General written material |
Demark‐Wahnefried 2007 | Mail‐based | Tailored mailed dietary material on increasing fruits and vegetables, reducing total fat, increasing exercise, providing lifestyle advice | Telephone interviews using diet history questionnaire | 7 newsletters at 6‐weekly intervals | Anthropometry, behaviour and dietary change, QoL |
1 year & 2 years |
Not reported | Transtheoretical model, social‐cognitive theory |
General written material |
Demark‐Wahnefried 2014 | Not reported | Personalized workbook with goal‐setting. Advice on specific dietary intake and physical activity | 24‐Hour recall | Telephone interviews at 3 time points | Dietary intake, anthropometry, QoL |
12 months |
BMI ≥ 25 to 39.9 |
Social‐cognitive theory | Written material |
Djuric 2002 | Dietitian | Individualised counselling via telephone contact provided |
3‐Day food diary | Counselling: weekly for first 3 months, biweekly for months 3 to 6, then monthly up to 30 months | Dietary intake, anthropometry | 12 months | Not reported | Social‐cognitive theory | Written materials |
Djuric 2002 | Weight watchers groups | Weight watchers meetings only | 3‐Day food diary | Weekly | Anthropometry and dietary changes | 12 months | Not reported | Not reported | Written materials |
Ghavami 2017 | Researcher but not specified | Individualised intervention promoting prescribed exercise (moderate exercise 3 to 5 days per week) and a balanced diet through stage‐matched telephone counselling and a workbook | Not reported | Weekly | QoL | 24 weeks | BMI > 25 | Not reported | Usual care |
Greenlee 2013 | Staff trained under the CURVE programme | Group weight loss programme | Food frequency questionnaire 110‐item | 3‐ to 5‐day/week exercise 1‐hour nutrition course/week |
Anthropometry, metabolic and dietary changes | 12 months | BMI ≥ 25 | Not reported | Waiting list |
Greenlee 2015 | Registered dietitian, nutritionist, chef | 9 group sessions (24 hours over 12 weeks) of nutrition intervention with culturally tailored curriculum | 24‐Hour dietary recall | Weekly/ monthly |
Anthropometry, dietary changes | 12 months | BMI 30.6 | Social‐cognitive theory, transtheoretical model | Booklets on healthy eating |
Gruenigen 2012 | Dietitian | Individualised goal‐setting enabling self‐efficacy. Group sessions for nutrition and physical activity advice plus face‐to‐face counselling sessions |
24‐Hour recall | 10 weekly sessions followed by 6 biweekly sessions plus face‐to‐face counselling | Anthropometry and dietary changes | 12 months | BMI 25.0 to 39.9 vs > 40 in control | Social‐cognitive theory | Written material |
Harrigan 2016 | Registered dietitian | In‐person counselling about nutrition, expertise, behaviour strategies | Food frequency questionnaire | Once per week (for month), then every second week (for months 2 and 3), then once per month (for months 4 to 6) | Anthropometry, dietary changes, biochemical changes, physical activity | 6 months | BMI 33.5 vs 34 in control | Social‐cognitive theory | |
Harrigan 2016 | Registered dietitian | Telephone counselling about nutrition, expertise, behaviour strategies | Food frequency questionnaire | Once per week (for month), then every second week (for months 2 and 3), then once per month (for months 4 to 6) | Anthropometry, dietary changes, biochemical changes, physical activity | 6 months | BMI 31.8 | Social‐cognitive theory | |
Hawkes 2013 | Health coach | Telephone health coaching focused on physical activity, weight management, dietary habits, smoking | Food frequency questionnaire | 11 phone sessions over 6 months | Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL | 6 months | BMI ≥ 25 | Acceptance commitment therapy, mindfulness | Usual care |
Kanera 2017 | Web‐based | Web‐based self‐management program with modules on diet, physical activity, depression, others | Dutch standard questionnaire on food consumption | 4 weeks after diet | Dietary changes, physical activity | 12 months | BMI 26.0 | Theory of planned behaviour, self‐regulated theory. integrated model of change | Usual care (waiting list) |
Kim 2011 | Trained nurses | Workbook and individualised prescription for regular exercise and diet 30‐minute telephone calls |
3‐Day dietary recall, diet quality tool | Weekly | Dietary changes, Diet Quality Index, QoL, behavioural changes | 12 weeks | Not reported | Transtheoretical model | Usual care |
Mefferd 2007 | Trained research assistant | Group exercise and diet modification sessions using behavioural treatment, weekly phone calls | Food diaries self‐monitored | Weekly sessions followed by once‐monthly sessions, then monthly sessions for 6 months | Anthropometry changes | 16 weeks | BMI ≥ 25 | Cognitive‐behavioural therapy | Waiting list |
Morey 2009 | Health counsellor | PersonaIised tailored workbook and series of quarterly newsletters, along with a programme of telephone counselling and automated prompts | 24‐Hour dietary recall | Weekly and monthly telephone and counselling sessions over 12 months | Anthropometry changes, functionality | 12 months | BMI ≥ 25 and ≤ 40 | Transtheoretical model, social‐cognitive theory |
Usual care |
Park 2016 | Mail‐based | Mail‐based lifestyle intervention | Paffenbarger activity questionnaire | Biweekly for 4 months | Dietary changes, feasibility, and adherence | 7 months | Not reported | Addressed behavioural skills but no specific therapy reported | Usual care |
Pierce 2007 | Trained counsellors | Telephone counselling. Phase 1: build self‐efficacy to implement dietary targets. Phase 2: focus on self‐monitoring and barriers to adherence. Phase 3: focus on motivation 12 cooking classes were offered plus newsletters |
24‐Hour dietary recall | Average 18 counselling calls, 12 cooking classes, and 12 study newsletters. By 4 years, average 31 calls and 48 newsletters received | Overall survival, incidence of secondary cancer, comorbidities, anthropometry, dietary changes | 4 years | Not reported | Social‐cognitive theory | Writen materials |
Reeves 2017 | Dietitian | Posted materials and telephone calls | 24‐Hour diet recall | Posted materials and up to 16 calls over 6 months | Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL | 6 months | BMI ≥ 25 to 45 | Not reported | Usual care |
Scott 2013 | Trained technician | Individual hypocaloric eating and supervised exercise sessions | 3‐Day diet diary | Weekly | Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL | 24 weeks | BMI ≥ 25 | Not reported | Written material |
Sheppard 2016 | Exercise physiologist, nutritionist, survivor coach | Group and individualised phone sessions | 4‐Day food diary | Every 2 weeks group session, phone calls on the weeks in between | Anthropometry changes, physiological function, QoL, biochemical changes | 12 weeks | BMI ≥ 25 and ≤ 40 | Motivational interviewing technique |
General health information |
Swisher 2015 | Dietitian, exercise physiologist | Supervised and unsupervised exercise sessions, 2 individual dietary sessions | 3‐Day food diary | 3 times/week supervised 2 times unsupervised |
Anthropometry changes, physical function, QoL, biochemical changes | 12 weeks | BMI ≥ 25 | Not reported | Written materials |
Yun 2017 | Trained health professional | 1‐hour health education session, 3‐hour leadership workshop, individual coaching by phone for 24 weeks | Validated questionnaire based on the Rules for National Cancer Prevention: dietary practice guideline | Weekly/monthly for different sessions | Physical activity, dietary changes, QoL, cancer survivors leadership | 12 months | BMI 22.05 | Transtheoretical model | Usual care |
Zick 2017 | Registered dietitian | Individualised phone counselling | 24‐Hour dietary recall | Weekly for 4 weeks, then biweekly | Anthropometry, dietary changes, QoL, biochemical changes | 3 months | BMI 27.2 vs 29.2 | Brandura's social‐cognitive theory | General health curriculum sessions |