Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 25;2019(11):CD011284. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011284.pub2

2. Descriptive summary of included studies.

Study variables All included studies
(n = 60)
Synthesis studies
(n = 52)
n % n %
Year published Older (before 2013) 44 73.3% 37 71.2%
Recent (2013 ‐ 2018) 16 26.7% 16 30.8%
Sample size (median, IQR) 257 132 ‐ 592 312 166 ‐ 627
Population source Healthcare 37 61.7% 33 63.5%
Occupational 16 26.2% 14 26.4%
General 3 4.9% 3 5.7%
Mixed 3 4.9% 1 1.9%
Not specified 1 1.6% 1 1.9%
Duration of LBP Acute 5 8.2% 4 7.5%
Subacute 5 8.2% 5 9.4%
Chronic 22 36.7% 20 38.5%
Mixed 19 31.1% 14 26.4%
Not specified 9 14.8% 9 17.0%
Type of expectations measure General expectations 42 68.9% 36 67.9%
Self‐efficacy expectations 12 19.7% 12 22.6%
Treatment expectations 17 28.3% 14 26.9%
Number of expectations measures 1 44 73.3% 39 75.0%
2 13 21.3% 11 20.8%
3 2 3.3% 2 3.8%
4 1 1.6% 0 0.0%
Prognostic factor study phase Exploratory/TEM 3 5.0% 3 5.8%
Exploratory 44 73.3% 37 71.2%
Confirmatory 13 21.3% 12 22.6%
Outcomes assessed Pain 31 51.7% 24 46.2%
Functional limitations 36 60.0% 30 57.7%
Work participation 35 58.3% 31 59.6%
Satisfaction 5 8.3% 2 3.8%
Global improvement 9 15.0% 8 15.4%
Health‐related quality of life 6 10.0% 4 7.7%
Cost 7 11.5% 6 11.3%
Mood 3 4.9% 3 5.7%
Follow‐up times available Short (3 ‐ 4 months) 29 48.3% 24 46.2%
Moderate (5 ‐ 8 closest to 6 months) 16 26.2% 13 24.5%
Long (8 ‐ 16 closest to 12 months) 40 65.6% 35 66.0%
Very long (> 16 months) 7 11.5% 7 13.2%
Low risk of bias by QUIPS domain Study Participation 18 30.0% 17 32.7%
Study Attrition 36 60.0% 33 63.5%
Prognostic Factor Measurement 27 45.0% 24 46.2%
Outcome Measurement 54 90.0% 46 88.5%
Study Confounding 28 46.7% 27 51.9%
Statistical Analyses & Reporting 41 68.3% 38 73.1%
All QUIPS ROB domains rated low or moderate 36 60.0% 34 65.4%
All QUIPS ROB domains rated low 2 3.3% 2 3.8%

LBP = low back pain; ROB = risk of bias; TEM = treatment effect modification; QUIPS = Quality in Prognosis Studies Tool