Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 19;10:2686. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2019.02686

TABLE 1.

Mutation and recombination frequencies detected within each of the 11 PCR treatments.

Treatment Total Identical sequences Recombined sequences without mutated sites Recombined sequences with mutated sites Novel sequences without recombination Total novel sequences Accuracy rate (% ± SD)1


A B C 1 2 3 >3
A (PCR) 110 110 (100%) 100 ± 0 a
B (PCR) 109 109 (100%) 100 ± 0 a
C (PCR) 110 110 (100%) 100 ± 0 a
A (Clone) 653 633 (96.94%) 20 (3.06%) 20 (3.06%) 96.94 ± 1.06 b
B (Clone) 641 618 (96.41%) 23 (3.59%) 23 (3.59%) 96.41 ± 1.47 b
C (Clone) 648 624 (96.30%) 24 (3.70%) 24 (3.70%) 96.30 ± 1.12 b
A+B 621 243 (39.13%) 190 (30.60%) 101 (16.27%) 43 (6.92%) 20 (3.22%) 3 (0.48%) 8 (1.29%) 13 (2.09%) 188 (30.27%) 69.51 ± 2.52 c
B+C 630 204 (32.38%) 221 (35.08%) 108 (17.14%) 50 (7.94%) 23 (3.65%) 3 (0.48%) 5 (0.79%) 16 (2.54%) 205 (32.54%) 67.33 ± 3.36 c
A+C 635 218 (34.33%) 231 (36.38%) 105 (16.54%) 44 (6.93%) 16 (2.52%) 1 (0.16%) 7 (1.10%) 13 (2.05%) 186 (29.29%) 69.91 ± 2.20 c
A+B+C 636 150 (23.58%) 122 (19.21%) 136 (21.38%) 112 (17.61%) 56 (8.80%) 28 (4.40%) 4 (0.63%) 11 (1.73%) 17 (2.67%) 228 (35.85%) 64.65 ± 3.38 c
Original DNA 636 169 (26.57%) 131 (20.60%) 138 (21.70%) 103 (16.20%) 47 (7.39%) 15 (2.36%) 2 (0.31%) 11 (1.73%) 20 (3.14%) 198 (31.13%) 68.07 ± 3.55 c
Total 5429 1523 (28.05%) 1374 (25.31%) 1460 (26.89%) 529 (16.75%)2 240 (7.60%)2 102 (3.23%)2 13 (0.41%)2 42 (1.33%)2 146 (3.69%)3 1072 (21.02%)3

1Treatments with different letters a, b, and c indicate that the accuracy rates are statistically significantly different from each other. 2The results were calculated using the equation R = a/b, where a is the total recombined sequence of each item and b is the total sequence number of the treatments A+B, A+C, B+C, A+B+C and original DNA, i.e., 42/3158. 3The results were calculated using the equation R = x/y, where x is the sequence number of each item and y is the total sequence numbers of the treatments A (Clone), B (Clone), C (Clone), A+B, A+C, B+C, A+B+C and original DNA, i.e., 1072/5100.