Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 27;9:17692. doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-53544-0

Table 3.

Ranking of six candidate reference genes for Frieseomelitta varia based on their expression stability according to analyses by geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and delta-Ct during development, between sexes, in tissues, and after bacterial injection and pesticide exposure.

Condition Reference Gene geNorm NormFinder BestKeeper delta-Ct
Stability Rank Stability Rank Stability Rank Stability Rank
Development ef1-α 0.506 5 0.851 5 1.489 6 0.98 5
gapdh 0.775 6 1.256 6 0.843 2 1.31 6
rpl32 0.132 1 0.066 1 0.892 4 0.54 1
rps5 0.290 4 0.387 4 0.673 1 0.67 4
rps18 0.132 1 0.146 3 0.891 3 0.56 2
tbp-af 0.221 3 0.121 2 0.903 5 0.59 3
Sex ef1-α 0.745 6 1.398 6 1.471 6 1.42 6
gapdh 0.309 4 0.447 4 0.491 2 0.71 4
rpl32 0.120 3 0.065 3 0.548 4 0.53 3
rps5 0.085 1 0.043 1 0.563 5 0.50 1
rps18 0.409 5 0.715 5 0.375 1 0.81 5
tbp-af 0.085 1 0.043 2 0.545 3 0.50 2
Tissues, organs and body parts ef1-α 1.153 6 1.389 6 2.892 5 1.56 6
gapdh 0.948 5 1.347 5 2.947 6 1.53 5
rpl32 0.200 3 0.852 4 1.390 1 1.02 4
rps5 0.078 1 0.556 3 1.552 3 0.89 2
rps18 0.078 1 0.539 2 1.543 2 0.89 1
tbp-af 0.436 4 0.460 1 1.720 4 1.02 3
Bacterial injection ef1-α 0.880 6 1.222 6 2.013 6 1.26 6
gapdh 0.688 5 0.945 5 1.910 5 1.09 5
rpl32 0.084 1 0.542 2 0.843 3 0.72 2
rps5 0.117 3 0.649 4 0.789 1 0.77 4
rps18 0.084 1 0.555 3 0.887 2 0.72 1
tbp-af 0.279 4 0.213 1 1.148 4 0.72 3
Pesticide exposure ef1-α 0.184 5 0.200 5 0.262 5 0.25 5
gapdh 0.217 6 0.260 6 0.334 6 0.28 6
rpl32 0.102 3 0.168 4 0.105 2 0.21 4
rps5 0.065 1 0.141 3 0.078 1 0.19 2
rps18 0.120 4 0.108 2 0.186 4 0.20 3
tbp-af 0.065 1 0.043 1 0.115 3 0.17 1