Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 27;19:519. doi: 10.1186/s12870-019-2135-x

Table 3.

SNP identification (SNP ID), additive effect and allelic variants for the SNP, proportion of total variance explained by the SNPs significantly associated with cell wall traits (PCA, FA, DFAT, DFA 8–O–4, DFA 8–5 l, DFA 8–5, DFA 5–5), and significance values for the association between the SNP and the phenotype (P-value and RMIP)

Traita QTLb Markerc Chrd Bine Allelesf (No)g Add Effecth P-value RMIPi R2j
PCA qPCA_1_1 S1_174637686 1 1.05 C/T 108/147 568.75 4.3E-08 0.69 0.08
PCA qPCA_1_2 S1_288696782 1 1.11 T/G 190/68 813.84 1.9E-07 0.85 0.09
PCA qPCA_1_3 S1_108071292 1 1.05 T/G 147/100 851.22 6.5E-08 0.92 0.11
PCA qPCA_1_3 S1_108071293 1 1.05 A/T 147/101 851.22 6.5E-08 0.92 0.11
PCA qPCA_3_1 S3_20426421 3 3.04 C/G 79/170 697.11 6.9E-07 0.57 0.08
FA qFA_1_1 S1_187590405 1 1.06 T/C 125/133 177.91 1.9E-06 0.52 0.08
FA qFA_1_2 S1_220067811 1 1.07 C/T 23/239 304.04 1.6E-06 0.61 0.07
FA qFA_1_2 S1_220067812 1 1.07 C/T 20/237 320.80 1.2E-06 0.54 0.08
FA qFA_1_3 S1_295476338 1 1.11 T/C 35/222 269.14 1.5E-08 0.81 0.08
FA qFA_1_3 S1_295476576 1 1.11 C/T 37/223 243.99 6.4E-08 0.66 0.09
FA qFA_4_1 ss4_10220935 4 4.01 C/A 170/83 181.03 1.9E-07 0.66 0.08
FA qFA_5_1 ss5_169927760 5 5.04 A/G 81/182 185.18 1.1E-06 0.51 0.08
FA qFA_8_1 S8_138322127 8 8.05 T/C 22/240 280.72 3.2E-07 0.57 0.08
DFAT qDFAT_10_1 S10_22521088 10 10.03 A/G 15/240 55.93 7.9E-07 0.51 0.07
DFAT qDFAT_3_1 S3_184608458 3 3.06 C/T 15/245 55.34 8.4E-08 0.5 0.08
DFA 8–O–4 qDFA8o4_1_1 S1_220067811 1 1.07 C/T 23/239 15.07 8.1E-07 0.69 0.08
DFA 8–O–4 qDFA8o4_1_1 S1_220067812 1 1.07 C/T 20/237 15.49 4.7E-07 0.54 0.08
DFA 8–O–4 qDFA8o4_10_1 S10_22521088 10 10.03 A/G 15/240 16.70 3.2E-07 0.51 0.07
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_1_1 S1_297490295 1 1.11 A/G 99/161 5.81 2.0E-06 0.57 0.07
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_1_2 S1_220067811 1 1.07 C/T 23/239 10.78 3.1E-07 0.62 0.08
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_1_2 S1_220067812 1 1.07 C/T 20/237 11.94 9.1E-08 0.7 0.08
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_3_1 ss3_60941077 3 3.04 G/A 38/229 8.39 9.8E-07 0.52 0.07
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_3_2 S3_184608458 3 3.06 C/T 15/245 14.73 6.49E-08 0.77 0.10
DFA 5–5 qDFA55_10_1 S10_22521088 10 10.03 A/G 15/240 13.24 3.9E-07 0.75 0.08
DFA 8–5 qDFA85_1_1 S1_297490295 1 1.11 A/G 99/161 12.04 9.7E-07 0.51 0.07
DFA 8–5 l qDFA85l_1_2 S1_297490295 1 1.11 A/G 99/161 4.69 3.9E-07 0.64 0.08
DFA 8–5 l qDFA85l_1_1 S1_220067811 1 1.07 C/T 23/239 8.30 4.1E-07 0.56 0.08

a: PCA: p-coumaric acid; FA: ferulic acid; DFA 8–5 l: 8–5 linear diferulic acid; DFA 5–5: 5–5 diferulic acid; DFA 8–O–4: 8–O–4 diferulic acid; DFA 8–5b: 8–5 benzofuran diferulic acid; DFA 8–5: sum (DFA 8–5 l + DFA 8–5b); DFAT: total diferulates sum (DFA 5–5 + DFA 8–O–4 + DFA 8–5b + DFA 8–5 l)

b: The number before the underscores indicates the chromosome and the number after the underscores indicates the QTL within the chromosome

c: The number before the underscores indicates the chromosome number and the number after the underscore indicates the physical position in bp within the chromosome

d: Chromosome

e: A bin is the interval that includes all loci from the leftmost or top Core Marker to the next Core Marker. The genetic maps are divided into 100 segments of approximately 20 centiMorgans designated with the chromosome number followed by a two-digit decimal [25]

f: The letter before the diagonal is the nucleotide with the larger value; and the letter after the diagonal is the nucleotide with the smaller value

g: No = Number of inbred lines homozygous for a determined allelic variant, The number before the diagonal represents the number of homozygous with the largest mean value; and the number after the diagonal the number of homozygous with the smaller mean value

h: Additive effect (μg/g DW): the additive effect was calculated as half the difference between the mean of the homozygous for the allele with the largest value and the mean of the homozygous for the allele with the smallest value

i: RMIP: resample model inclusion probability

j: Phenotypic variance explained by each marker