Table 3.
Number | Hospitalisation outcome to avoid | Process of suboptimal clinical care prior to hospitalisation | Source |
Haemorrhagic event | |||
1 | Haemorrhagic event | Use of warfarin; | Original |
Concurrent use of an interacting antibiotic; | |||
No INR test in the 5 days prior to admission. | |||
2 | Haemorrhagic event | Use of warfarin; | Original† |
No INR test in the 6 weeks prior to admission. | |||
3 | Haemorrhagic event | Use of one or more antithrombotics (warfarin, DOAC, aspirin, NSAID, clopidogrel, LMWH); AND | Original† |
No haemoglobin test within the past year; OR | |||
No monitoring of renal function in the previous 6 months; OR | |||
Use of triple therapy (dual antiplatelet plus oral anticoagulant) for more than 1 month prior to admission. | |||
Gastrointestinal | |||
4 | Gastritis, GI bleed, GI ulcer or GI perforation | History of or prior hospitalisation for GI ulcers or GI bleed; | Original† |
Use of NSAID (including aspirin) for a period of at least 1 month prior to admission. | |||
5 | Gastritis, GI bleed, GI ulcer or GI perforation | History of prior hospitalisation for GI ulcers or GI bleed; AND | Original† |
Use of gastric toxin (eg, oral corticosteroids, NSAIDs, antiplatelet agents, bisphosphonates, anticoagulants, cholinesterase inhibitor) for a period of at least 3 months prior to admission; AND | |||
No cytoprotection (eg, proton pump inhibitor). | |||
6 | Bowel impaction | Use of two or more medications known to retard gastrointestinal motility (including anticholinergic agents, calcium channel blockers, antacids and iron preparations) at the time of admission; OR | Original† |
Use of a highly anticholinergic agent at the time of admission; OR | |||
Use of an opioid analgesic without concurrent use of a laxative at the time of admission. | |||
Cardiovascular | |||
7 | Congestive heart failure or fluid overload | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of high blood pressure or CHF; | Original† |
Use of an agent known to exacerbate CHF including NSAIDs, COX-2 inhibitors, anti-arrhythmics (apart from beta-blockers or amiodarone), non-dihyropyridine calcium-channel blockers in systolic CHF (verapamil, diltiazem), corticosteroids, clozapine, tricyclic anti-depressants, tyrosine kinase inhibitors, thiazolidinediones or tumour necrosis factor antagonists at time of admission. | |||
8 | Congestive heart failure or fluid overload | Prior hospitalisation for/ or diagnosis of heart failure; | Original |
No use of ACEI, ARB or ARNi (angiotensin receptor neprilysin inhibitor) at time of admission. | |||
9 | Myocardial Infarction | History of acute coronary syndrome / previous MI; | Original† |
No use of anti-platelet(s) OR beta-blocker (reduced left-ventricular systolic function only) OR HMG-CoA reductase inhibitor in the 3 months prior to hospitalisation. | |||
10 | Myocardial infarction | Insertion of stent within the previous 12 months; | New |
No use of dual anti-platelet in 2 months prior to admission. | |||
11 | Thromboembolic cerebrovascular event | Prior diagnosis of atrial fibrillation; | Original† |
No use of anticoagulant in the 3 months prior to admission in a patient with high risk according to CHA2Ds2Vasc score. | |||
12 | Acute coronary syndrome | CVD risk known to be >15% prior to admission; | New |
Not on lipid lowering therapy AND/OR antihypertensive therapy. | |||
13 | Transient ischaemic attack/ischaemic stroke | Pulse quality/blood pressure not tested within past 24 months; | New |
No use of any of antiplatelet, antihypertensive, anticoagulant, lipid lowering therapy. | |||
14 | Ischaemic coronary event | History of angina or acute coronary syndrome; | New |
No use of beta-blocker, calcium channel blocker or nitrates. | |||
15 | Ischaemic event | History of diabetes; | New |
History of ischaemic event; | |||
No antiplatelet or lipid lowering therapy. | |||
Electrolytes and laboratory abnormalities | |||
16 | Blood dyscrasia | Use of an agent known to cause blood dyscrasias (including carbimazole, sulphonylureas, propylthiouracil, methotrexate, sulphasalazine); | Original† |
No complete blood count or platelet test in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
17 | Syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion | Use of TCAs, carbamazepine, ACEIs, other antidepressants; | Original† |
No electrolyte test in the 12 months prior to admission. | |||
18 | Electrolyte imbalance | Use of diuretics, ACEI/ARB, spironolactone, potassium supplements or calcium supplements; | Original† |
No electrolyte test in the 12 months prior to admission; AND | |||
No renal function test in the 12 months prior to admission. | |||
19 | Anticonvulsant drug toxicity | Use of anticonvulsant requiring therapeutic drug monitoring; | Original |
No drug level test in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
20 | Digoxin toxicity | Use of digoxin; | Original† |
No renal function test in the 12 months prior to admission; AND | |||
No potassium serum level in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
21 | Lithium toxicity | Use of lithium; | Original |
No lithium drug level test in the 3 months prior to admission. | |||
22 | Clozapine-related blood dyscrasias | Use of clozapine; | New |
No full blood count/white blood count/neutrophils/ eosinophils in >1 month prior to admission or within the previous week in the first 18 weeks of therapy. | |||
23 | Clozapine-induced myocarditis/cardiomyopathy | Use of clozapine; | New |
No baseline echocardiogram; OR | |||
ECG in the previous 12 months; OR | |||
troponin in the previous 12 months; OR | |||
CRP in previous 12 months before admission. | |||
24 | Clozapine toxicity/failure | Use of clozapine; | New |
Altered smoking status while on clozapine (may vary levels and result in toxicity or relapse). | |||
25 | Clozapine toxicity | Use of clozapine; | New |
Concurrent illness; | |||
No full blood count/ white blood count/ neutrophils/ eosinophils in >1 month prior to admission. | |||
Endocrine | |||
26 | Hypoglycaemia | Use of insulin; OR | Original† |
Use of long-acting sulfonylurea in the 3 months prior to admission; AND | |||
Inadequate blood glucose monitoring OR reduced adherence to diabetes treatment plan. | |||
27 | Diabetic complications (including hyperglycaemia) | Previously diagnosed with diabetes; | Original† |
Use of a hypoglycaemic in the 6 months prior to admission; AND | |||
No HbA1c in previous 6 months. | |||
28 | Hypothyroidism or thyrotoxicosis | Use of amiodarone or lithium; | Original† |
No thyroid function test in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
Fracture or falls | |||
29 | Hip fracture or other fracture/break | Aged 65 years or older; AND | Original† |
Use of long-term corticosteroids (>1 month); AND/OR | |||
Use of sedating psychotropic medication (including TCAs, benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, opioids); AND/OR | |||
Use of cardiovascular drugs with high potential to cause postural hypotension (including nitrates, centrally acting adrenergic blockers and alpha-receptor blockers). | |||
30 | Hip fracture | Female gender; | Original |
Prior fall from the standing level resulting in fracture; | |||
No use of HRT, bisphosphonate or other osteoporosis medicine in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
31 | Hip fracture | Male gender; | Original |
Prior fall from the standing level resulting in fracture; | |||
No use of bisphosphonate or other osteoporosis medicine in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
32 | Low-trauma fracture | Previous low-trauma fracture; | New |
Not taking osteoporosis prevention therapy at time of admission. | |||
Neurological | |||
33 | Acute confusion | Urinary tract infection un/inadequately treated | New |
34 | Acute confusion | Use of two or more anticholinergic agents at the time of admission; OR | Original† |
Use of a highly anticholinergic agent at the time of admission; OR | |||
Use of two or more of sedating prescription drugs and/or sedating antihistamines; OR | |||
Use of multiple psychotropic medicines (≥3 unique medicines from ATC groups, N05 or N06) at the time of admission. | |||
35 | Seizure | Use of an anticonvulsant; | Original† |
Concurrent use of a medication which lowers the seizure threshold (as specified in the Australian Medicines Handbook); AND/OR | |||
Reduced compliance with anticonvulsant medication. | |||
36 | Bipolar disorder | Prior hospitalisation for bipolar disorder; | Original |
Use of lithium; | |||
No lithium drug level in the 3 months prior to admission. | |||
37 | Bipolar affective disorder/psychotic disorder | Prior hospitalisation for bipolar disorder; | New |
No use of/ poor compliance with a mood stabiliser; OR | |||
Reduced compliance with long acting injection and/or oral medication. | |||
38 | Depression | Prior diagnosis of depression; | Original |
Concurrent use of a moderately highly lipophilic beta blocker. | |||
39 | Depression (readmission) | Reduced compliance with antidepressant or augmenting medications (mood stabiliser or antipsychotic); AND/OR | New |
No review (including medication adherence) undertaken post previous admission. | |||
40 | Mania/hypomania | Use of antidepressants in the 2 months prior to admission; | New |
No use of mood stabiliser in the 2 months prior to admission. | |||
41 | Attempted suicide | Use of SSRI in adolescents (up to 20 years old); | New |
No psychiatric review in 12 months prior to admission. | |||
42 | Psychotic episode | History of psychosis/ mental illness; | New |
Reduced compliance with prescribed antipsychotic/ anxiolytic medication. | |||
43 | Antidepressant withdrawal symptoms | Abrupt cessation of antidepressant (especially short-acting such as paroxetine and venlafaxine). | New |
44 | Acute anxiety | Cessation of psychotropic medications (such as antidepressant and/or benzodiazepines) without monitoring. | New |
45 | Eating disorder/electrolyte imbalance | Excessive laxative use; OR | New |
Use/abuse of medications altering electrolyte levels (for example, loop diuretics). | |||
46 | Serotonin toxicity | Use of multiple serotonergic agents that may contribute to serotonin toxicity (desvenlafaxine, duloxetine, MAOIs including moclobemide, SSRIs, TCAs, venlafaxine, fentanyl, tramadol, selegiline, lithium, tryptophan, St. John’s Wort). | New |
Renal | |||
47 | Renal failure | Use of ACEI or ARB; | Original† |
No BUN or serum creatinine test in the 12 months prior to admission. | |||
48 | Renal failure | Use of allopurinol; | Original |
No BUN or serum creatinine test in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
49 | Renal failure | Use of lithium; | Original |
No BUN or serum creatinine test in the 3 months prior to admission. | |||
50 | Renal failure | NSAID use for>3 months; | New |
BUN or serum creatinine not monitored in the previous 12 months. | |||
51 | Renal failure | Use of methotrexate; | New |
No BUN or serum creatinine test in the 6 months prior to admission. | |||
Respiratory | |||
52 | Asthma AND/OR COPD | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of asthma/COPD; AND | Original† |
No / inadequate maintenance therapy (LAMA, LABA, ICS); OR | |||
Poor inhaler technique; AND/OR | |||
No action plan in place; AND/OR | |||
No smoking cessation advice given. | |||
53 | Asthma/COPD | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of asthma and/or COPD; | Original |
Use of beta-blocker eye drops for glaucoma at the time of admission. | |||
54 | Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of COPD; | Original |
Use of a betablocker at the time of admission. | |||
55 | Acute respiratory failure | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of COPD; | Original |
Use of a medium to long-acting benzodiazepine at the time of admission. | |||
56 | Asthma | Prior hospitalisation for/or diagnosis of asthma/COPD; | New |
High use (>2X per week) of a short-acting bronchodilator (SABA, SAMA); | |||
No use of maintenance therapy (LAMA, LABA, ICS). | |||
57 | Bronchiectasis | Two or more admissions with bronchiectasis exacerbations in last 12 months; No prophylactic azithromycin trialled in the 12 months prior to admission. |
New |
Genitourinary | |||
58 | Urinary retention | Prior diagnosis of benign prostatic hyperplasia OR bladder atony due to diabetes mellitus; | Original† |
Current use of a drug with anticholinergic effects or an opioid at the time of admission. | |||
59 | Recurrent urinary tract infection | No test for organism identification and sensitivity undertaken. | New |
Sexually transmitted diseases | |||
60 | Chlamydia or gonorrhoea | Untreated with antibiotics for more than 1 week after results received. | New |
Vaccine preventable diseases | |||
61 | Pneumonia | No pneumococcal vaccine if 'at risk' (chronic illness or>50 years); | New |
No revaccination after 5 years. | |||
62 | Influenza | No influenza vaccination in the past 12 months. | New |
63 | Tetanus | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
64 | Diphtheria | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
65 | Whooping cough | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
66 | Acute poliomyelitis | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
67 | Varicella | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
68 | Measles | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
69 | Rubella | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
70 | Mumps | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
71 | Hepatitis A | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
72 | Hepatitis B | No/incomplete vaccination. | New |
Other | |||
73 | Cellulitis | No treatment / inadequate treatment with antibiotics to treat staphylococcus aureus or streptococcus pyogenes with an appropriate antibiotic at time of admission. | New |
74 | Rheumatic fever (<21 years of age) | Prior diagnosis of rheumatic fever or rheumatic heart disease; | New |
No benzathine penicillin (or erythromycin if allergic) in the last 28 days. | |||
75 | Gout attack | Previous history of gout; | New |
Use of loop diuretics or thiazide diuretics. | |||
76 | Hepatitis C | No treatment with direct acting antivirals. | New |
77 | Methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus skin infection | Recurrent skin infection (>2 weeks); | New |
Continuing use of β-lactam antibiotic; | |||
No skin swab taken. | |||
78 | Jaw osteonecrosis | Use of a bisphosphonate or denosumab; | New |
No dental assessment within 6 months prior to admission. | |||
79 | Trachoma | Untreated with appropriate antibiotics. | New |
80 | Iron deficiency anaemia | Confirmed pregnancy; | New |
No FBE test during pregnancy. | |||
81 | Eclampsia | Prior diagnosis of hypertension (a systolic blood pressure of greater than or equal to 160 mm Hg or a diastolic blood pressure greater than or equal to 110 mm Hg) during the current pregnancy; |
New |
No treatment with antihypertensive agent (suitable for use in pregnancy) at time of admission. |
*The final list of clinical indicators has not been considered as part of any independent Health Technology Assessment (HTA) for effectiveness/cost-effectiveness.
†The original indicator (from Kalisch et al14) forms the basis of this indicator but it has been modified either to (i) update the indicator to reflect current guidelines or new medicines in the class; (ii) combine with another indictor/s for simplification or (iii) has been split into more indicators for clarity.
ACEI, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors; ARB, angiotensin II blockers; ARNi, angiotensin receptor-neprilysin inhibitors; ATC, anatomical therapeutic chemical; BUN, blood urea nitrogen; CHA2Ds2Vasc, congestive heart failure, hypertension, age, diabetes and stroke/TIA vascular disease (peripheral arterial disease, previous MI, aortic atheroma) (female gender is also included in this scoring system); CHF, congestive heart failure; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; COX-2, cyclooxygenase-2; CRP, C-reactive protein; CVD, cardiovascular disease;DOAC, Direct oral anticoagulant; FBE, full blood examination; GI, gastrointestinal; HbA1c, glycolated haemoglobin; Hg, mercury; HMG-CoA, 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-CoA; HRT, hormone replacement therapy; ICS, inhaled corticosteroids;INR, international normalised ratio; LABA, long-acting beta agonists; LAMA, long-acting muscarinic antagonists; LMWH, low molecular weight heparin; MAOI, monoamine oxidase inhibitor; MI, myocardial infarction; MRSA, methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus; NSAID, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug; SABA, short-acting beta-2 agonists; SAMA, short-acting muscarinic antagonist; SIADH, syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion; SSRI, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor; TCA, tricyclic antidepressants; TIA, transient ischaemic attack.