Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 5;3(12):1900013. doi: 10.1002/gch2.201900013

Table 4.

Cost involved in the coating of boron, sulfur, and zinc onto prilled urea and economic evaluation for one hectare aromatic rice crop. Means in a column with at least one letter common are not statistically significant using Fisher's least significant difference

Treatment Cost involved Economic evaluation
Quantity [kg ha−1] of B/S/Zn required a) Amount of borax/sulfur/Zn product [kg ha−1] required a) Cost of borax/sulfur/Zn [US $ ha−1] Cost of coating of urea with B/S/Zn b) Total cost of coating urea of [US $ ha−1] Cultivation cost [US $ ha−1] Gross returns [US $ ha−1] Net returns [US $ ha−1] Benefit:cost ratio
Absolute control 983.5 1443.8E 460.3E 0.47D
Prilled urea 1058.6 2057.9D 999.4D 0.94C
0.1% BCU 0.28 2.33 4.67 2.08 6.75 1065.2 2128.2CD 1063.0CD 1.00BC
0.2% BCU 0.56 4.66 9.32 2.40 11.72 1070.2 2170.3BCD 1100.1BCD 1.03ABC
0.3% BCU 0.84 7.00 14.0 2.73 16.73 1075.1 2230.7ABC 1155.6ABC 1.07AB
0.4% BCU 1.12 9.32 18.63 3.05 21.68 1080.0 2291.3AB 1211.3AB 1.12AB
0.5% BCU 1.40 11.65 23.30 3.38 26.68 1085.0 2323.8A 1238.8A 1.14A
Absolute control 983.5 1443.8D 460.3D 0.47D
Prilled urea 1058.6 2057.9C 999.4C 0.94C
1.0% SCU 2.83 3.14 1.57 1.85 3.42 1061.9 2144.9BC 1082.9BC 1.02BC
2.0% SCU 5.65 6.28 3.13 1.97 5.10 1063.6 2288.9B 1225.2B 1.15B
3.0% SCU 8.48 9.42 4.72 2.08 6.80 1065.3 2449.0A 1383.7A 1.30A
4.0% SCU 11.30 12.56 6.28 2.18 8.47 1066.9 2486.1A 1419.2A 1.33A
5.0% SCU 14.13 15.70 7.85 2.30 10.15 1068.6 2572.5A 1503.9A 1.41A
Absolute control 983.5 1533.7E 550.2E 0.56F
Prilled urea 1058.6 2169.4D 1110.8D 1.05E
0.5% ZnCU (ZnSHH) 1.41 7.07 3.50 1.98 30.20 1064.0 2263.9CD 1199.9CD 1.13DE
0.5% ZnCU (ZnO) 1.41 1.76 2.61 1.91 29.24 1063.1 2254.5CD 1191.4CD 1.12DE
1.0% ZnCU (ZnSHH) 2.82 14.1 6.98 2.23 33.91 1067.8 2378.6BC 1310.9BC 1.23BCD
1.0% ZnCU (ZnO) 2.82 3.52 5.23 2.10 32.05 1065.9 2371.9BC 1303.3BC 1.22CD
1.5% ZnCU (ZnSHH) 4.23 21.15 10.48 2.46 37.66 1071.5 2460.8AB 1389.3AB 1.30ABC
1.5% ZnCU (ZnO) 4.23 5.28 7.84 2.28 34.83 1068.7 2447.2AB 1378.5AB 1.29ABC
2.0% ZnCU (ZnSHH) 5.64 28.2 13.96 2.71 41.39 1075.2 2528.1A 1452.9A 1.35AB
2.0% ZnCU (ZnO) 5.64 7.04 10.46 2.46 37.64 1071.5 2509.9A 1438.4A 1.34ABC
2.5% ZnCU (ZnSHH) 7.05 35.25 17.46 2.95 45.13 1079.0 2551.7A 1472.8A 1.36A
2.5% ZnCU (ZnO) 7.05 8.81 13.09 2.64 40.45 1074.3 2537.4A 1463.1A 1.36A
a)

For coating of 282.6 kg urea (kg ha−1)

b)

At the rate of 7% of fertilizer prices (US $ ha−1)

Prevailing prices of fertilizer materials during 2013&14: (i) Borax (12% boron) at the rate of US $ 2.0 kg−1, (ii) sulfur dust (90% S) at the rate of US $ 0.50 kg−1, (iii) ZnSO4·7H2O (20% Zn) at the rate of US $ 0.50 kg−1; (iv) ZnO (80% Zn) at the rate of US $1.49 kg−1, (v) prilled urea at the rate of US $ 0.087 kg−1, (vi) price of one US $ = 60.6 INR [Note: Prilled urea at the rate of US $ 883 tonne−1; US $ 24.97 for an application of 130 kg ha−1].