Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 14;7:1900708. doi: 10.1109/JTEHM.2019.2946147

TABLE 2. Respiratory and Heart Rate Estimation Error.

Respiratory Rate Estimation mean (± std) E < 1 br/min (%) E < 0.5 br/min (%) RMSE (br/min) MAE
Awake, N = 50 83.32 (± 13.85) 75.36 (± 16.34) 2.85 (± 1.82) 1.24 (± 1.13)
NREM, N = 50 94.63 (± 9.16) 90.03 (± 12.30) 1.29 (± 1.26) 0.49 (± 0.66)
REM, N = 46 92.72 (± 11.61) 86.79 (± 14.33) 1.34 (± 1.44) 0.55 (± 0.63)
Apnea and Hypopnea, N = 50 83.04 (± 13.46) 73.40 (± 17.28) 2.74 (± 1.89) 1.23 (± 1.07)
All, N =50 89.89 (± 10.95) 83.65 (± 13.91) 2.10 9 (± 1.64) 0.82 (± 0.89)
Heart Rate Estimation mean (± std) E < 5 bpm (%) E < 2.5 bpm (%) RMSE (bpm) MAE
Awake, N = 45 75.42 (± 19.20) 64.60 (± 21.00) 8.57 (± 5.51) 5.13 (± 4.34)
NREM, N = 45 80.18 (± 20.81) 71.06 (± 22.68) 6.81 (± 5.34) 4.05 (± 4.41)
REM, N = 42 78.66 (± 22.79) 68.69 (± 23.95) 6.93 (± 5.16) 4.26 (± 4.05)
Apnea and Hypopnea, N = 45 75.34 (± 20.78) 60.05 (± 22.92) 7.47 (± 5.41) 4.90 (± 4.31)
All, N = 45 77.97 (± 18.91) 67.60 (± 20.73) 7.47 (± 4.79) 4.36 (± 3.69)

Error values were calculated by averaging over all subjects. std = standard deviation, br/min = breaths per minute, bpm = beats per minute, E = percent of estimation for which the absolute error is less than specified threshold, RMSE = root mean squared error, MAE = mean absolute error, N = number of subjects, NREM = non-rapid eye movement sleep, REM = rapid eye movement sleep.