Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: Soc Psychol Personal Sci. 2018 Jul 17;10(6):711–721. doi: 10.1177/1948550618784890

Table 5.

Results of Multivariate genetic analyses

Panel 1: Additive genetic effects matrix

E A C N O Parenting
Variable

E 0(.11)
.06(.06)
.17(.05)** .14(.04)*** −.09(.04)* −.001(.04) .06(.03)
A .15(.04)*** .008(.13)
.04(.10)
.30(.04)*** −.16(.06)** .09(.05) .14(.05)**
C .14(.04)*** .29(.04)*** .001(.001)
0(0)
.02(.10) −.14(.13) −.12(.11)
N −.09(.04)* −.16(.05)** 0(.08) .002(.001)
0(0)***
−.02(.11) .07(.10)
O .002(.04) .08(.05) −.09(.11) −.04(.09) .03(.19)
.21(.18)
−.01(.12)
Parenting Variable −.01(.05) −.18(.06)** .19(.12) −.09(.11) .03(.14) .41(.25)
.46(.32)

Panel 2: Dominant genetic/shared environmental effects matrix
E A C N O Parenting
Variable

d11 .61(.04)***
.61(.04)***
.50(.07)***
.52(.06)***
.28(.10)**
.31(.07)***
.45(.07)***
.46(.06)***
.53(.18)**
.51(.17)**
----
----
c22 ----
----
-----
----
----
----
----
----
----
----
.74(.04)***
.46(.11)***

Panel 3: Nonshared environmental effects matrix

E A C N O Parenting
Variable

E .77(.03)***
.77(.03)***
.21(.04)*** .15(.03)*** .04(.03) .25(.03)*** −.02(.02)
A .21(.04)*** .79(.02)***
.79(.02)***
.28(.03)*** −.05(.04) .09(.03)** .04(.02)
C .15(.03)*** .28(.03)*** .75(.02)***
.75(.02)***
.07(.04)* .12(.03)*** .03(.02)
N .04(.03) −.04(.04) .07(.04)* .83(.03)***
.83(.03)***
.07(.03)* −.008(.02)
O .25(.03)*** .09(.03)** .11(.03)*** .07(.03)* .74(.02)***
.74(.02)***
−.03(.02)
Parenting
Variable
.03(.03) −.07(.03)* −.09(.03)** .15(.03)*** −.004(.03) .41(.03)***
.62(.04)***

Note. Results for parental warmth displayed on the upper diagonal. Results for parental stress displayed on the lower diagonal.

E= extraversion, A=agreeableness, C=conscientiousness, N= neuroticism, O= openness to experience

*

p < .05,

**

p <.01,

***

p <.001.

All p-values are from two-tailed tests

Models are residualized for age, sex, age2, and age × sex

All reported parameter estimates were standardized