Table 1.
Study | Induction factor | Medium | Duration of muscle commitment and differentiation (days) | Cell composition | Purification | In vitro | In vivo |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chal et al., 2015 | days 0–6 CHIR99021 and LDN193189, insulin-transferrin-selenium; days 3–6 addition of FGF-2; days 6–8 IGF-1, HGF, FGF2 and LDN193189; days 8–12 IGF-1; days 12–50 IGF-1 and HGF |
DMEM based medium; days 0–6 serum free, thereafter + knock-out serum replacement (KSR) |
20–30 | ~22% of nuclei were MYOG+, and 23% of nuclei were PAX7+ | No purification | MyHC+, MYOG+ fibers, PAX7+ cells, organized sarcomeres, with the periodic distribution of the sarcomeric proteins Titin and fast MyHC |
No |
Chal et al., 2016 | days 0–6 CHIR99021 and LDN193189, insulin-transferrin-selenium; days 3–6 addition of FGF-2; days 6–8 IGF-1, HGF, FGF2 and LDN193189; days 8–12 IGF-1; days 12–50 IGF-1 and HGF |
DMEM based medium; days 0–6 serum free, thereafter + KSR |
30 | Most MYOG+ cells, MyHC+ myofibers. PAX7+ satellite-like cells. | No purification | Sub-culturing of human myo-progenitors by day 28. MyHC+, MYOG+ fibers, PAX7+ cells, organized sarcomeres. Fast MyHC+ and h-Dystrophin+ fibers in muscle construct. |
No |
Choi et al., 2016 | days 0–4 CHIR99021; days 4–12 DAPT |
Serum-free N2 medium | 30 | ~15% NCAM+ HNK1-myoblasts, 61.5% MYOG+ and 63.6% MyHC+ cells |
NCAM+ HNK1- |
MyHC, TITIN, DES, DYSTROPHIN, α-ACTININ | PAX7+ cells, h-Dystrophin+ fibers |
Hicks et al., 2018 | days 0–2 CHIR99021; days 12–20 FGF2, TGF-β inhibitor when in differentiation condition |
days 0–12, days 20–35 E6 medium, days 12–20 StemPro-34 medium, days 35–50 DMEM/F12 + 1% ITS medium |
30–50 | PAX7, MYF5, MYOD, MYOGENIN and spontaneously contracting myotubes | ERBB3+NGFR+ | Enriched for PAX7 and MYF5 | h-LaminA/C+, h-Dystrophin+ fibers. In vivo engraftment of ERBB3+ hiPSC-SMPCs restored dystrophin to levels approaching uncultured fetal muscle |
Sakai-Takemura et al., 2018 | days 0–12 Chal et al. 2016 method; days 12–42 floating culture; days 42–70 adhesion culture |
days 0–12 DMEM, days 12–70 10% FBS/DMEM |
70 | MYOGENIN+ myotubes | CD57(−) CD108(−) CD271(+) ERBB3(+) cells |
MYOGENIN, MyHC |
h-LaminA/C+ (nuclear membrane) and h-Spectrin+ (sarcolemma) myofibers |
Wu et al., 2018 | days 1–4 CHIR99021, BMP inhibitor, TGF-β inhibitor; days 5–15 BMP inhibitor, TGF-β inhibitor |
MDM-I medium days1–4, MDM-II medium day 5–15, MDM-III medium for terminal differentiation |
15 | at day 4 99.4% PAX7+, at day 15, 50–55% MYF5+ |
CD10+CD24- | MyHC+ myotubes | myofibers expressing human markers (maximum of 50–60 fibers positive for h-Dystrophin and h-Lamin A/C) |