Skip to main content
. 2019 May 5;10(5):e1502. doi: 10.1002/wcs.1502

Table 1.

Sample reasons for and against the adaptiveness of delusions found in the literature

Wellbeing and good functioning Survival, good health, and reproduction
Delusional beliefs in schizophrenia
  • Their adoption brings short‐term anxiety relief by ending the uncertainty caused by perplexing experience.

  • Depending on their content, their maintenance may cause distress. They are also likely to compromise socialization due to the lack of a shared reality.

  • According to some predictive processing accounts, their adoption helps resume automated learning after disrupted prediction‐error signals. Habitual processes enable engagement with the physical and social environment.

  • Given that flexible learning relative to the delusional content is disabled, delusions are fixed beliefs.

Delusional beliefs in dementia
  • Their adoption and maintenance may lead to the construction of a better self and a better reality or fill explanatory gaps created by memory impairments.

  • Their maintenance may cause inconsistencies in the self‐narrative and compromise socialization due to the lack of a shared reality.

  • They may contribute to self‐esteem and reduce the risk of depression. They may also support the pursuit of one's goals by sustaining motivation.

  • By distorting reality, they may prevent one from finding the best means to achieve one's goals.

“Motivated” delusions
  • Their adoption and maintenance allow one to construct a better self and a better reality in response to negative emotions that could otherwise become overwhelming.

  • Clashes between delusional content and reality may cause confusion and disappointment and compromise social relationships due to lack of a shared reality.

  • By making one feel better, they enhance mood and reduce the risk of depression. They may also support the pursuit of one's goals by sustaining motivation.

  • Due their distorting reality, they may prevent one from finding the best means to achieve one's goals.

Delusional beliefs in MDD or OCD
  • They restore coherence between low mood and belief (MDD); and between obsessive and compulsive behavior and belief (OCD). Thus, they reduce fragmentation in the self‐narrative and tension in the sense of self.

  • They can contribute to symptoms of MDD or OCD worsening.

  • By making one feel worse, more guilty and inadequate, and less competent, delusions in MDD adversely affect mood which may negatively impact on goal pursuit via motivation.

  • People with OCD who have delusions show poorer functioning and higher levels of depression than people with OCD who do not have delusions.