Table 5. Risks associated with controlled human infection with Schistosoma mansoni.
Risk | Inherent risk score | Total
inherent risk |
Controls | Residual risk score | Total
risk post control |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Likelihood | Impact | Likelihood | Impact | ||||
Symptoms related
to infection |
Common | Major | 20 | 1) Slow dose escalation in modest
increments 2) Frequent follow up visits and collection of adverse events. 3) Clinical assessment and routine safety lab. 4) Symptomatic treatment with corticosteroids or abrogating infection with praziquantel (which kills adult worms) if needed. 5) Abrogate infection with artesunate (which kills immature forms) |
Common | Moderate | 15 |
Symptoms related
to treatment with praziquantel |
Common | Moderate | 15 | 1) Take praziquantel with food
2) Clinical assessment, reassurance, symptomatic relief if needed |
Common | Minor | 10 |
Misunderstanding
of the nature of CHI-S studies |
Likely | Critical | 20 | 1) Education of community leaders, opinion
makers and regulators 2) Work with community advisory board 3) Education of potential volunteers using tested materials 4) Informed consent verified with tests of comprehension |
Possible | Major | 12 |
Inappropriate
remuneration leading to coerced participation |
Possible | Moderate | 9 | 1) Formative research to determine
appropriate remuneration |
Unlikely | Moderate | 6 |
Likelihood was scored as almost certain/common, 5; likely, 4; possible, 3; unlikely, 2; rare, 1. Impact was scored as critical, 5; major, 4; moderate, 3; minor, 2; insignificant 1.