Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 12;2019(12):CD001088. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001088.pub4
Mental state: 4. Average score (various scales, high = poor)) (skewed data)
Study Intervention Mean SD N
Depressive symptoms ‐ 3 months (BDI‐11)
Baker 2006 Treatment 16.93 12.51 58
Baker 2006 Control 10.93 10.43 61
Depressive symptoms ‐ 6 months (BDI‐11)
Baker 2006 Treatment 14.10 11.38 58
Baker 2006 Control 9.92 9.29 61
Depressive symptoms ‐ 12 months (BDI‐11)
Baker 2006 Treatment 17.14 13.20 44
Baker 2006 Control 9.68 10.30 53
Depressive symptoms ‐ 3 months Calgary Depression Scale
Madigan 2013 Treatment 4.4 4.3 40
Madigan 2013 Control 4.6 4.8 20
Depressive symptoms ‐ 12 months Calgary Depression Scale
Madigan 2013 Treatment 4.3 4.4 33
Madigan 2013 Control 4.3 4.2 11
General symptoms total score ‐ 6 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 35.47 9.34 58
Baker 2006 Control 34.52 8.53 61
General symptoms total score ‐ 12 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 35.43 8.59 44
Baker 2006 Control 32.58 8.19 53
General symptoms total score ‐ 3 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 35.31 9.04 58
Baker 2006 Control 34.46 11.24 61
General symptoms ‐ 18 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 21.13 6.39 15
Barrowclough 2001 Control 30.07 8.17 14
Barrowclough 2014 Treatment (long) 35.1 9.0 23
Barrowclough 2014 Control 31.6 8.5 21
Total score ‐ 3 months (PANSS)
Gouzoulis‐Mayfrank 2015 Treatment 65.36 28.26 50
Gouzoulis‐Mayfrank 2015 Control 77.42 31.55 50
Total score ‐ 6 months (PANSS)
Gouzoulis‐Mayfrank 2015 Treatment 61.92 26.823 50
Gouzoulis‐Mayfrank 2015 Control 77.9 33.254 50
Total score ‐ 12 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 56.88 14.23 17
Barrowclough 2001 Control 63.40 17.96 15
Total score ‐ 18 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 52.20 11.12 15
Barrowclough 2001 Control 58.50 15.04 14
Manic symptoms ‐ 3 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.43 2.46 58
Baker 2006 Control 7.39 3.51 61
Manic symptoms ‐ 6 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.38 2.23 58
Baker 2006 Control 6.57 3.56 61
Manic symptoms ‐ 12 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.07 1.63 44
Baker 2006 Control 6.18 2.32 53
Negative symptoms ‐ 3 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.24 2.10 58
Baker 2006 Control 6.48 2.47 61
Negative symptoms ‐ 6 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.00 1.52 58
Baker 2006 Control 6.08 1.54 61
Negative symptoms ‐ 12 months (BPRS)
Baker 2006 Treatment 6.86 1.36 44
Baker 2006 Control 6.58 2.35 53
Negative symptoms ‐ 6 months (PANSS)
Hjorthoj 2013 Treatment 16.3 5.92 34
Hjorthoj 2013 Control 15.3 5.35 28
Negative symptoms ‐ 9‐10 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 12.47 4.12 17
Barrowclough 2001 Control 16.20 4.87 15
Hjorthoj 2013 Treatment 14.9 5.2 34
Hjorthoj 2013 Control 15.2 6.15 26
Negative symptoms ‐ 12 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 12.65 4.97 17
Barrowclough 2001 Control 14.67 6.02 15
Negative symptoms ‐ 18 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 10.27 2.25 15
Barrowclough 2001 Control 15.50 5.71 14
Barrowclough 2014 Treatment 13.7 3.9 23
Barrowclough 2014 Control 15.2 6.5 21
Negative symptoms ‐ 3 months (SANS)
Madigan 2013 Treatment 3.8 2.4 40
Madigan 2013 Control 3.2 2.3 20
Negative symptoms ‐ 12 months (SANS)
Madigan 2013 Treatment 4.6 3 32
Madigan 2013 Control 4.8 3.2 19
Positive symptoms ‐ 6 months (PANSS)
Hjorthoj 2013 Treatment 15.6 5.09 34
Hjorthoj 2013 Control 17 5.01 28
Positive symptoms ‐ 9‐10 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 15.29 4.69 17
Barrowclough 2001 Control 16.40 4.29 15
Hjorthoj 2013 Treatment 14.4 5.22 34
Hjorthoj 2013 Control 16.2 4.99 26
Positive symptoms ‐ 12 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 13.35 4.57 17
Barrowclough 2001 Control 16.07 5.54 15
Positive symptoms ‐ 18 months (PANSS)
Barrowclough 2001 Treatment 13.87 4.27 15
Barrowclough 2001 Control 12.93 4.23 14
Barrowclough 2014 Treatment (Long) 13.0 4.6 24
Barrowclough 2014 Control 12.7 5.1 21
Positive symptoms ‐ 3 months (SAPS)
Madigan 2013 Treatment 4.8 3.7 42
Madigan 2013 Control 5.1 4.1 22
Positive symptoms ‐ 12 months (SAPS)
Madigan 2013 Treatment 4.9 4 32
Madigan 2013 Control 5.1 4.2 17