Tracy 2007.
Methods | Allocation: randomised.
Design: single‐centre.
Duration: 1 month.
Setting: community. Location: New Haven Connecticut, USA. |
|
Participants | Diagnosis: Met current or lifetime DSM‐IV Axis 1 psychiatric disorder* and had a co‐occurring current diagnosis of cocaine or alcohol abuse or dependence. N = 30. Age: not stated. Sex: gender not stated. Inclusion criteria: homeless or seeking shelter at least 18 years of age in addition to current SUD and psychiatric diagnosis. | |
Interventions |
1. Psychosocial intervention: Contingency management: Low‐cost contingency management with variable ratio reinforcement where patients received reinforcers** contingent upon demonstrating abstinence from both alcohol and cocaine, as verified by breathalyser and cocaine‐free urine specimens. N = 15. 2. Standard care: TAU, assessment only. N = 15. |
|
Outcomes | Leaving the study early: lost to treatment (4 weeks). Unable to use Substance use: mean and SDs not provided for alcohol and substance use; percentages (and Chi2 statistics) are provided for some outcomes but not subject number (N) for each group. |
|
Notes | * Specific diagnoses are not reported, unknown seriousness or duration of psychiatric illness. ** Reinforcers were redeemable prizes ranging in value from no prize, $1, $20 and $100. All participants received $30 for the screening, baseline and termination interviews and $5 for each weekly assessment. |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Randomised using a table. No further details. |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | No details provided. |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | High risk | Clinician‐/participant‐mediated and participants and personnel not blinded. It is not possible to blind a psychosocial intervention. |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | Not stated if raters were blind to allocation. |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | Lost to follow‐up: 13% (4/30) 1 month. Four patients in the TAU (assessment only) group did not complete the study, no further details are provided. Analyses adjusted for greater cocaine use using covariate. |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | High risk | Gender, specific diagnoses and age not reported for participants. Mean and SDs not provided for alcohol and substance use; percentages (and Chi2 statistics) are provided for some outcomes but not participant number (N) for each group. |
Other bias | Low risk | No evidence other biases are occurring. |
F = Female, M = Male, N = Number ITT ‐ Intention‐to‐treat analysis
LOCF ‐ Last observation carried forward
RDC ‐ Research diagnostic criteria SCID ‐ Structured Clinical Interview for Diagnosis
Type of care AA ‐ Alcoholics Anonymous ACT ‐ Assertive Community Treatment CBT ‐ Cognitive Behaviour Therapy NA ‐ Narcotics Anonymous
For full list of diagnostic scales and abbreviations see Table 10.