Table 1.
Literature search on periodontal application of three-dimensional printing
| Author | Journal | Type of study | Method | Material | Application | 3D printer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kim et al., 2010[9] | Journal of Dental Research | In vivo animal | 3D-printed tooth scaffold | Poly-epsilon caprolactone and hydroxyapatite | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Park et al., 2010[10] | Biomaterials | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | PCL-PGA | Guided tissue regeneration | 3D wax-printing system (ModelMaker II, Solidscape, Inc., Merrimack, NH USA) |
| Carlo Reis et al., 2011[11] | Biomaterials | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | PLGA/CaP bilayered biomaterial | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Park et al., 2012[12] | Biomaterials | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | Poly-ε caprolactone solution (PCL) | Guided tissue regeneration | 3-D rapid prototyping wax printer (ModelMaker II; Solidscape Inc., Merrimack, NH) |
| Rasperini et al., 2015[13] | Journal of Dental Research | Case report | 3D-printed Bioresorbable Scaffold | PCL | Periodontal Repair | Selective laser sintering (Formiga P100 System; EOS e-Manufacturing Solutions) |
| Sumida et al., 2015[14] | Journal of Craniomaxillofacial Surgery | RCT | 3D-printed scaffold | Titanium | Guided bone regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Obregon and Vaquette, 2012[15] | Biomaterials | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | Bilayered biomaterial | Guided bone regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Adel-Khattab et al., 2018[16] | Journal of Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine | In vitro | 3D-printed synthetic scaffold | Bioceramic | Guided bone regeneration | R1Series ExOne (PROMETAL, USA) |
| Park et al., 2014[17] | Journal of dental research | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | Gelatin, chitosan | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Costa et al., 2014[18] | Journal of Clinical Periodontology | In vivo | 3D-printed scaffold | Bilayered biomaterial | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Pilipchuk et al., 2016[19] | Advance Healthcare Material | Preclinical study | 3D-printed scaffold | PCL | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Lei et al. 2019[20] | Journal of Oral Implantology | Case report | 3D-printed bone model | Not mentioned | Guided tissue regeneration | Not mentioned |
| Park et al., 2018[21] | Materials (Basel) | In vivo animal study | 3D-printed bioresorbable scaffold | PCL | Socket preservation | 3D bioprinting system (laboratory -made system in Korea Institute of Machinery and Materials, Daejeon, Korea) |
| Goh et al., 2015[22] | Clinical oral implants research | pilot randomized controlled clinical trial | 3D-printed Bioresorbable Scaffold | PCL | Socket preservation | Fused Deposition Modeling techniques (FDM 3000; Stratasys, Eden Prairie, MN, USA) |
| Kijartorn et al., 2017[23] | Key engineering materials | Prospective study | 3D-printed scaffold | Hydroxyapatite granules | Socket preservation | Projet 160, 3D systems |
| Tamimi et al., 2009[24] | Biomaterials | Case report | 3D-printed monolithic monetite blocks | Synthetic calcium phosphates | Vertical bone augmentation | 3D-powder Printing system (Z-Corporation, USA) |
| Torres et al., 2011[25] | Journal of Clinical Periodontology | In vivo | 3D-printed monolithic monetite blocks | A/b-tricalcium phosphate | Vertical bone augmentation | 3D-powder printing system (Z-Corporation, USA) |
| Mangano et al.[26] | Journal of Oral Implantology | In vivo | 3D synthetic bone substitute | Ceramic | Sinus augmentation | Not mentioned |
| Xu et al., 2016[27] | Journal of Prosthodontics | In vitro | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Conne×350; Objet, Rehovot, Israel |
| Sarment et al., 2003[28] | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants | In vitro | Stereolithographic templates | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Mimics; Materialise Technical, Ann Arbor, MI |
| Ozan et al., 2009[29] | Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery | Retrospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Stereolithography apparatus models and guides (Ay-Tasarim, Kos-gep, ODTU, Ankara, Turkey) |
| Valente et al., 2009[30] | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants | Retrospective study | Stereolithographic templates | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Simplant |
| Cassetta et al., 2011[31] | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery | Retrospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Stereolithographic surgical guide (External Hex Safe1, Materialise Dental, Leuven, Belgium) |
| Cassetta et al., 2013[32] | International Journal of Oral Maxillofacial Surgery | Retrospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Stereolithographic surgical guide (External Hex Safe1, Materialise Dental, Leuven, Belgium) |
| Vieira et al., 2013[33] | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants | Retrospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Dental slice, bioparts |
| Lee et al., 2013[34] | Journal of Advance Prosthodontics | Retrospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Conne×350® 3D printing system; Object Geometries Inc., Billerica, MA, USA |
| Arisan et al., 2013[35] | Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Acrylic resin | Guided implant placement | Simplant Pro, Materialise Dental, Leuven, Belgium |
| Ersoy et al., 2008[36] | Journal of Periodontology | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Acrylic resin | Guided implant placement | Ay-Design, Kos-gep, ODTU, Ankara, Turkey |
| Verhamme et al., 2015[37] | Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | NobelGuide (Nobel Biocare, Gothenburg, Sweden |
| Vasak et al., 2011[38] | Clinicl Oral Implants Research | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | NobelGuide (Nobel Biocare, Gothenburg, Sweden |
| Stübinger et al., 2014[39] | Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Polymer | Guided implant placement | Astra Tech AB, Mölndal, Sweden |
| Di Giacomo et al., 2012[40] | Journal of Periodontology | Prospective | 3D-printed surgical guide | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Sinterstation HiQ, 3D Systems, Rock Hill, SC |
| D’haese et al., 2012[41] | Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research | Clinical trial | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Materialise N.V., Leuven, Belgium |
| Van Assche et al., 2010[42] | Journal of Clinical periodontology | Clinical trial | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Procera® software (Nobel Biocare AB, Göteburg, Sweden) |
| Van de Wiele et al., 2015[43] | Clinical Oral Implants Research | Clinical trial | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Not mentioned | Guided implant placement | Implant Safe Guide, Dentsply Implants |
| Pozzi et al., 2014[44] | European Journal of Oral Implantology | Clinical trial | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic resin | Guided implant placement | Nobel Procera, Nobel Biocare |
| Arisan et al., 2010[45] | Clinical Oral Implants Research | Clinical trial | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic resin | Guided implant placement | Aytasarim (Classic and Otede systems), Kos-gep, ODTU, Ankara, Turkey SimPlant (SurgiGuide and SAFE systems), Materialise Dental. |
| Abboud et al., 2012[46] | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants | NRCT | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Materialise SimPlant system or the Nobel Biocare system |
| Di Giacomo et al., 2005[47] | Journal of Periodontology. | NRCT | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Polymer | Guided implant placement | Sim plant CSI Materialise, Ann Arbor, MI |
| Mangano et.al., 2018[48] | International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health | NRCT | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Polymer | Guided implant placement | 3D printer (XFAB2000®, DWS). |
| Lindeboom et al., 2010[49] | Clinical Oral Implants Research | RCT | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Procera® Software 3D Planning Program (Nobel Biocare AB, Göteborg, Sweden) |
| Bernard et al. 2019[50] | Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry | RCT | Stereolithographic surgical guides | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Simplant; Materialise Dental |
| Younes et al.[51] | Clinical Oral Implants Research | RCT | Stereolithographic templates | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Not mentioned |
| Vercruyssen et al., 2014[52] | Journal of Clinical Periodontology | RCT | Stereolithographic templates | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Materialise Dental |
| Shen et al., 2015[53] | Journal of Craniomaxillofacial Surgery | RCT | Stereolithographic templates | Acrylic | Guided implant placement | Geomagic, version 10.0, Geomagic, Research triangle Park, NC |
3D – Three dimensional; PCL – Polycaprolactone; PGA – Polyglycolic acid; PLGA – Polylactide-co-glycolide acid; CaP – Calcium phosphate; RCT – Randomized controlled trial