Table 2.
Country | Authors and Year | Group | Type of Ratio | Increase | Magnitude | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Country/ Region | Sex (M,F) | Generation (1st, 2nd) | |||||
Australia | McCredie, Williams, & Coates, 1999 78 | Eastern Europe | Both | 1st | Relative Risk of Death from Cancer | Yes | 2.0–3.1 |
Belgium | Hemelrijck, Valk, & Vandenheede, 2017 79 | Turkey | Female | 1st | Indirectly Standardized Mortality Rate | Yes | 27.6 (18.6–39.4)a |
Brazil | Iwasaki et al., 200832 | Japan | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 49–88b |
Iwasaki et al., 200433 | Japan | Both | 1st, 2nd for male only | StandardizedMortality Ratio and Standardized Proportional Mortality Ratio | Yes | 91–118b | |
Canada | Newman & Spengler, 1984 26 | Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 161–256c |
Germany | Kaucher, Kajüter, Becher, & Winkler, 2018 27 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.52–1.62 |
Cho, Jaehn, Holleczek, Becher, & Winkler, 2018 28 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.91–2.15 | |
Winkler, Ott, Holleczek, Stegmaier, & Becher, 2009 29 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.44–2.81 | |
Kyobutungi, Ronellenfitsch, Razum, & Becher, 2006 25 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | No | 1.44–1.45 | |
Israel | Jördis Jennifer Ott, Paltiel, & Becher, 2009 80 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.85–1.86 |
Netherlands | Siemerink, van der Aa, Siesling, Hospers, & Mulder, 2011 46 | Non-western | Both | 1st | Relative Excess Risk of Dying | No | 0.55 (0.43–0.70)d |
Stirbu et al., 200642 | All migrants | Both | 1st | Relative Risk of Cancer Mortality | No | 1.05–1.35 | |
Sweden | Nilsson et al., 199748 | Estonia | Both | 1st | Excess Mortality Rate | No | 12.3–42.2%e |
United States | Singh & Miller, 2004 81 | All immigrant s, China, Japan | Both | 1st | Average Annual Age Adjusted Death Rates | Yes | 1.61–2.19 |
Fang, Madhavan, & Alderman, 1996 34 | China | Both | 1st | Relative Risk of Age Adjusted Annual Death Rate | Yes | 1.4–1.5 | |
Stellman & Wang, 1994 35 | China | Both | 1st | Standardized Proportional Cancer Mortality Ratio | Yes | .44-.60f | |
Multiple: Denmark, England & Wales, France, Netherlands, Scotland, Spain | Ikram et al., 2016 36 | Eastern Europe, Turkey | Both | 1st | Mortality Rate Ratio | Yes | 1.88–1.97 |
Multiple: Belgium, Denmark, France, Netherlands | Spallek et al., 201237 | Turkey | Both | 1st | Mortality Rate Ratio | Yes | 1.35–1.69 |
Multiple: Israel and Germany | Ronellenfitsch et al., 2009 30 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.44–1.83 |
Multiple: Israel and Germany | Jördis J Ott, Paltiel, Winkler, & Becher, 2008 31 | Former Soviet Union | Both | 1st | Standardized Mortality Ratio | Yes | 1.42–1.83 |
Notes:
• Belgium female ISMR was 8.9 with 95% CI of 8.5–9.4
• Japanese mortality rate in Japan used as baseline with reference 100
• Canadian mortality ratio of 100 is reference
• 1 was reference for both western immigrants and native patients
• Reference values were given for dichotomous age groups and two categories of follow up (1, 5 years). The authors noted that these were not statistically significant but did not provide confidence intervals for this estimate
• Chinese mortality rate in China used as a baseline with a reference of 1.0
• Statistics listed if they reached statistical and clinical significance as specified by the authors. All statistically significance ratios were greater than the reference low incidence country when considering confidence intervals of at least 95%. Region counted as high risk if at least one of the countries in the region included a high risk country.