Table 1.
First author, year, country [reference] | Study design | Subjects | Intervention | Type of supervision | Primary outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hand exercises | |||||
Piga, 2014, Italy [44] | RCT |
|
|
Every patient received individual 1 h training on the use of the device, along with an illustrated booklet describing the exercises. Every workout was remotely monitored by physicians through the telemonitoring interface | Hand function measured by HAQ, functional index for hand OA and the hand mobility in scleroderma test |
Landim, 2017, Brazil [41] | OD | n = 22, mean age = 48.09 years, mean disease duration = 11.19 years, female n = 18, diffuse/limited subtype 6:16 | Home-based self-management programme consisting of hand exercises and concise instructions about SSc | Instructions in the program | Hand pain (visual analog scale) and hand function (Cochin hand function scale) |
Orofacial exercises | |||||
Yuen, 2011, USA [13] | RCT |
|
|
Patients were taught to perform manual mouth-stretching and oral augmentation exercises by a trained research coordinator. Handouts with pictures showing the exercises were given | Oral aperture |
Pizzo, 2003, Italy [11] | OD | n = 10, mean age = 56.8 years, female n = 10, mean maximal mouth opening = 26 mm | Mouth-stretching exercises and oral augmentation exercises, 20 minutes, twice daily for 18 weeks | Patients were instructed by one of the investigators to perform the exercise programme | Maximal mouth opening |
Aerobic and muscle-strengthening exercises | |||||
Mitropoulos, 2018, UK [42] | RCT |
|
|
Supervised sessions at sport venues of the hospital |
|
Mitropoulos, 2019, UK [43] | RCT |
|
|
Supervised sessions at sport venues of the hospital | VO2peaka |
Oliveira, 2009, Brazil [23] | OD | E: n = 7, mean age = 45.6 years, mean disease duration = 12.6 years, female n = 7, diffuse/limited subtype 2: 5, mean forced vital capacity for diffuse subtype = 77.5% of predicted and for limited subtype 103.8% of predicted | Aerobic exercise (30 min of treadmill walking at moderate intensity), 40 min, 2 days/week for 8 weeks | Supervised sessions | VO2peak, oxygen saturationa |
Pinto, 2011, Brazil [12] | OD | n = 11, mean age = 44.0 years, mean disease duration = 7.36 years, female n = 11, diffuse/limited subtype 8:3 | Aerobic training (20 min of treadmill exercise at a heart rate of ∼70% of VO2peak), resistance training (30 min, four sets of 8–12 maximal repetitions for the main muscle groups), 2 days/week for 12 weeks | Supervised training | Oxygen uptake, highest exercise load for bench and leg pressa |
Alexanderson, 2014, Sweden [27] | Single subject experimental design | n = 4, mean age = 66.5 years, mean disease duration = 3.5 years, female N = 3, lung fibrosis with 50–80% forced vital capacity/100% forced vital capacity = 2:2 | Aerobic exercise (ergometer cycling of maximum 30 min. Intensity increased from light exertion to 15 on a Borg scale) and muscular endurance training for shoulder and hip flexors, 30–50 min, 3 days/week for 8 weeks | Supervised by a trained physical therapist | 6 min walking test |
For these studies the primary outcomes were not defined in the text, but we chose the main outcomes based on our definition of physical functioning outcomes in the text.
C: control group; E: experimental group; OD: observational design; RCT: randomized controlled trial; VO2peak: peak oxygen consumption.