TABLE 2.
Gene | Reference(s) | Variant(s) | Design | Imaging | Na | Agea,b | Ethnic Backgrounda |
Imaging findings | Behavioral findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BDNF | Jasinska et al. (2016) | rs6265** | Continuous | fMRI | 81 | 6–10 | 70 Caucasian 1 African-American 2 Hispanic 3 Asian 5 Mixed ethnicity |
Increased activation bilaterally in Met carriers relative to Val/Val homozygotes | Val allele homozygotes performed better than Met carriers on passage comprehension, phonological memory, and IQ |
C2ORF3/MRPL19/GCFC2 | Eicher et al. (2016) |
rs2298948* rs917235*⊥ rs6732511*⊥ ⊥DYX3 locus upstream of GCFC2 and MRPL19 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
332 | 3-20 | European | Minor allele on rs2298948 associated with decreased CT and GMV. rs917235 associated with CT rs6732511 minor allele associated with increased GMV |
NR |
Scerri et al. (2012) |
rs917235***** rs714939 rs1000585 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | G allele associated with reduced WMV | rs714939 and rs917235 associated with verbal IQ | |
CMIP | Skeide et al. (2016) |
rs12927866 rs6564903 rs3935802 rs4265801 rs16955705 rs7201632 Joint SNP effect***** |
Case/control | MRI | 54 | 5–12 | NR | CMIP related to bilateral portions of cerebellar WM | Associated with reading comprehension |
COL4A2 | Skeide et al. (2016) | rs9521789***** | Case/control | MRI | 54 | 5–12 | NR | Related to cerebellar GMV | No significant associations reported |
COMT | Landi et al. (2013) | rs4680**** | Case/control | fMRI | 86 | 6–10 | 83 Caucasian 3 African-American |
Greater activation in left hemisphere reading-related regions for Met carriers | Significant differences between genotype groups in phonological awareness (PA) and spelling |
NRSN1 | Skeide et al. (2016) |
rs9356928 rs4285310 rs3178 Joint SNP effect***** |
Case/control | MRI | 54 | 5–12 | NR | Joint SNP association with GMV and WMV | NRSN1 associated with reading comprehension performance. GMV in VWFA ROI related to NRSN1 predicted reading outcomes |
ROBO1 | Lamminmäki et al. (2012) | N/A | Case/control | MEG | 10 | 19–51 | Finnish | Ipsilateral auditory suppression in both hemispheres related to ROBO1 expression levels | NR |
CCDC136/FLNC | Gialluisi, Guadalupe, Francks, and Fisher 2017 | rs59197085 rs56184882** rs339054** rs339046** |
Continuous | MRI | 1275 | 18–35 | NR | Associated with cortical surface area in IFG | NR |
DCDC2 | Cope et al. (2012) | rs793862 rs807701 rs807724 BV677278 STR** BV677278 del. rs1087266 |
Continuous | fMRI | 82 | 7–12 | European American |
DCDC2 variants associated with activation during print and auditory processing Nominal associations between DCDC2 variants and activation during word reading and nonword reading tasks |
Nominally significant associations between DCDC2 variants and measures of IQ, PA, word reading, and passage comprehension |
Czamara et al. (2011) |
Chr6:24459391/rs1052724905** Chr6:24564881** Chr6:24571041** Chr6:24581378/rs1033367480** |
SRD | EEG | 200 | 8–19 | German | Four rare variants on DCDC2 or between DCDC2 and KIAA0319 were associated with late mismatch negativity (MMN) to speech | NR | |
Darki et al. (2012) |
rs793842***** rs793862 rs807701 rs2328819 rs2792682 rs7751169 rs9460974 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with WMV | Positive correlation between white matter volume and reading scores. No direct relationships between SNPs and behavior. | |
Darki et al. (2014) | rs793842***** | Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with WMV in left temporo-parietal region and with CT in left temporo-parietal and occipital cortices | Associated with reading comprehension scores; WMV and CT correlated with reading scores | |
DCDC2 | Eicher et al. (2016) | rs707864 | Continuous | MRI DTI |
332 | 3–20 | European | NS | NR |
Marino et al. (2014) | DCDC2-intron2 deletion** | Case/control | DTI | 47 | 16–21 | NR | Reduced WM integrity in subjects with DCDC2 intron2 deletion | Positive correlation between fractional anisotropy (FA) and average reading scores | |
Meda et al. (2008) | DCDC2-intron2 deletion* | Continuous | MRI | 56 | 19–85 | NR | Increased GMV in carriers of DCDC2 intron 2 deletion compared to those homozygous for no deletion | NR | |
DYX1C1 | Darki et al. (2012) |
rs3743204**** rs3743205 rs17819126 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with WMV in bilateral temporo-parietal region | Significant correlation between WMV and reading scores |
Darki et al. (2014) | rs3743204***** | Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with bilateral temporo-parietal WMV, replicating findings of Darki et al. (2012) across an additional time point | Significant correlation between WMV and reading scores | |
FOXP2 | Belton et al. (2003) | KE Family*** | Case/control | MRI | 34 | 9–27 | European | Altered GM density in affected family members | NR |
Liegois et al. (2003) | KE Family*** | Case/control | fMRI | 20 | 19–56 | European | Affected family members showed an atypical pattern of activation in a verb generation task compared to unaffected family members and controls | NR | |
FOXP2 | Pinel et al. (2012) |
rs10249234*** rs7784315*** rs7812028* rs17137135*** rs6980093*** rs6942634 rs2894699 rs1476535 rs10255943 rs10486026 rs10261780 rs10262103 rs4727799 rs17312686 rs2106900 rs17312861 rs12113612 rs10266297 rs10279936 rs7799109 rs12532920 rs17137124 rs10269986 rs1229761 rs1229758 rs12705966 rs10230087 rs7782412 rs1456029 rs12670585 rs6966051 rs17213159 rs1378771 rs12705971 rs12705973 rs2396766 rs12671330 |
Continuous | fMRI | 94 | M = 24.7 | European | Associations with activation during a sentence reading task | NR |
FOXP2 | Skeide et al. (2016) |
rs923875
rs12533005 rs6980093 rs10230558 rs7782412 rs936146 Joint SNP effect***** |
Continuous | MRI | 54 | 5–12 | NR | Joint SNP effect related to GMV in left medial superior frontal gyrus | NS |
Vargha-Kadem et al. 1998 | KE Family*** | Case/control | PET MRI |
34 | NR | European | Atypical activation during a word repetition task in affected family members. Regional alterations in GM structure | Affected family members show deficits in word repetition, nonword repetition, and simultaneous and sequential orofacial movements | |
Watkins et al. (2002) | KE Family*** | Case/control | MRI | 34 | 9–27 | European | Atypical pattern of GMV in affected family members compared to unaffected family members and controls | Correlation between caudate nucleus volume and performance on test of oral praxis, nonword repetition, and coding subtest of Wechsler Intelligence Scale in affected family members | |
Wilcke et al. (2012) | rs12533005** | Case/control | fMRI | 33 | M = 11 | German | Decreased activation in risk allele carriers during rhyme decision task | NR | |
Darki et al. (2012) |
rs6935076***** rs4504469 rs2143340 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with left temporoparietal WMV | Positive correlations between WMV and reading comprehension and WMV and timed single-word reading; No significant correlations between SNPs and reading | |
KIAA0319 | Darki et al. (2014) | rs6935076***** | Continuous | MRI DTI |
76 | 6–25 | 98% European | Associated with bilateral temporoparietal WMV, replicating findings from Darki et al. (2012) across an additional time point | Significant correlation between WMV and reading scores |
Eicher et al. (2016) |
rs9461045**** rs9295626 rs10456309 rs4576240 |
Continuous | MRI DTI |
332 | 3–20 | European | Associated with cortical thickness and WM integrity | NR | |
Pinel et al., 2012 | rs2235676 rs9467247 rs3756821 |
Continuous | fMRI | 94 | M = 24.7 | Primarily Caucasian | NS | NR | |
RBFOX2 | Gialluisi et al. (2017) |
rs5995177*** rs78563107*** rs6000084*** rs6000085*** rs144006011*** |
Continuous | MRI | 1275 | 18–35 | NR | Associated with cortical thickness | NR |
SETBP1 | Perdue et al. (2019) | rs7230525*** | Continuous | fMRI | 73 | 5–12 | 116 Caucasian 2 African American 3 Hispanic 4 Asian 8 mixed 2 unreported |
Interaction between genotype, lexicality and modality in the right inferior parietal lobule | Genotype associated with phonological working memory |
SLC2A3 | Roeske et al. (2011) |
rs4234898*** rs11100040*** |
SRD | EEG | 200 18 6c*** | 8–19 | German | Altered late MMN response | NR |
Skeide et al. (2015) | rs4234898 rs11100040*** |
Continuous | rsfMRI DTI |
34 | 9–12 | NR | Weaker functional and structural connectivity in risk allele carriers | WM integrity related to PA performance | |
THEM2/ACOT13 | Eicher et al. (2016) | rs3777663** | Continuous | MRI DTI |
332 | 3–20 | European | Associated with cortical thickness | NR |
Pinel et al. (2012) |
rs17243157*** rs3756819 rs1061925 rs3181227 rs2223588 rs6928074 rs9461049 rs926529 rs1885211 |
Continuous | fMRI | 94 | M = 24.7 | Primarily Caucasian | Associated with functional asymmetry during reading and speech listening tasks | NR | |
CNTNAP2 | Dennis et al. (2011) | rs2710102*** | Continuous | DTI | 328 | M = 23.4 | Caucasian | Atypical structural connectivity indices in risk allele carriers | NR |
Koeda et al. (2015) |
rs7794745*** rs2710102 |
Continuous | fMRI | 108 | M = 26.3 | Japanese | Genotype group differences in activation during general auditory processing, human voice processing, and language processing | NS | |
Skeide et al. (2016) |
rs7794745 rs10246256 rs2710102 rs759178 rs17236239 rs4431523 rs2710117 Joint SNP effect***** |
Continuous | MRI | 54 | 5–12 | NR | Joint SNP effect related to WMV in left cerebral and cerebellar peduncles | Association with reading comprehension | |
CNTNAP2 | Tan et al. (2010) | rs7794745*** | Continuous | MRI DTI |
114 | NR | NR | Reduced GMV, WMV, and WM integrity in risk allele homozygotes | NR |
Udden et al. (2017) | rs7794745**** | Continuous | MRI | 1717 | M = 24.3 | Primarily European Caucasian | Reduced GMV in AT/TT carriers compared to AA homozygotes | NR | |
Whalley et al. (2011) |
rs7794745*** rs2710102*** |
Continuous | fMRI | 66 | M = 20.5 | Caucasian | Atypical patterns of activation in risk allele carriers during sentence completion task | NS |
Note. Shading indicates relevant phenotype: white = reading, light gray = reading and/or language, dark gray = language. Boldface indicates SNPs for which significant imaging-genetic results were reported. For studies that included corrected and uncorrected p values, asterisks indicate corrected p to be consistent with other studies presented here.
Abbreviations: CT, cortical thickness; GMV, gray matter volume; NR, not reported; NS, no significant findings; WMV, white matter volume.
p < .01, uncorrected.
p < .001, uncorrected.
p < .05, corrected.
p < .01, corrected.
p < .001, corrected.
Information listed refers to samples included in neuroimaging analyses.
Age ranges or means reported according to information available in each study.
Replication sample.