Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 4;10:2778. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2019.02778

TABLE 1.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex L4.4.1.1 sublineage substitution rate and time to most recent common ancestor (TMRCA) estimates.

Clock model Demographic model Substitution rate (×10–8) L4.4.1.1 TMRCA CS clade TMRCA Rangipo TMRCA Otara TMRCA
Strict Constant 6.63 (4.34–9.06) 1513 (1301–1673) 1671 (1529–1777) 1978 (1965–1987) 1827 (1744–1886)
Strict Exponential 6.63 (4.37–9.08) 1513 (1299–1672) 1672 (1530–1781) 1978 (1965–1986) 1827 (1745–1887)
Strict Skyline 6.28 (4.54–8.10) 1492 (1325–1629) 1652 (1535–1741) 1980 (1969–1988) 1813 (1746–1868)
UCLD Constant 6.49 (4.23–8.93) 1500 (1277–1667) 1665 (1518–1774) 1977 (1964–1986) 1824 (1741–1887)
UCLD Exponential 6.64 (4.37–8.98) 1511 (1294–1667) 1673 (1528–1772) 1977 (1965–1986) 1828 (1748–1888)
UCLD Skyline 6.15 (4.39–7.98) 1480 (1300–1624) 1645 (1524–1743) 1980 (1968–1988) 1809 (1739–1867)

Median values are reported and 95% HPD interval shown in brackets. Substitution rate is in substitutions per site per year. The best fitting model and estimates reported in the text are shown in bold. The GTR model of substitution was used for all analyses.