Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 5;13(12):e0007928. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0007928

Table 3. Summary of diagnostic test results in the 50 patients screened positive by the second blood-IgM ELISA.

Days from fever onset to the 1st blood collection (median, IQR) 8, 7–13
Days from fever onset to the 2nd blood collection (median, IQR) 14, 11–20
Days of interval between the 1st and 2nd blood collection (median, IQR) 5, 4–6
Number of patients with ST diagnosis 26
    IgM or IgG titer ≥ 4-fold increase by IIP (with positive by any PCR) 14 (4)
    Single IgM titer ≥ 320 (i.e., ≥ 1:320) by IIP (with positive by any PCR) 12 (8)
    Positive by more than one PCR assays* (with single IgM titer ≥ 320 by IIP) 10 (6)
    Dominant IIP reactions against a single antigen 15
        against Karp antigen 8
        against Kato antigen 0
        against Gilliam antigen 4
        against Hirano/Kuroki antigen 1
        against Irie/Kawasaki antigen 1
        against Shimokoshi antigen 1
    Indistinguishable IIP reactions against multiple antigens 11
IgM ELISA OD value of the 1st blood sample (median, IQR) 0.534, 0.384–1.748
IgM ELISA OD value of the 2nd blood sample (median, IQR) 1.070, 0.623–3.217
AUC of ROC curve of ST diagnosis by IgM ELISA in the 1st blood samples (95% CI) 0.73 (0.57–0.89)
    Diagnostic parameters by cut-off OD value at 0.513 in the 1st blood sample-IgM ELISA
        accuracy (95% CI) 68% (53.3%-80.5%)
        sensitivity (95% CI) 69.2% (48.2%-85.7%)
        specificity (95% CI) 66.7% (44.7%-84.4%)
        positive predictive value (95% CI) 69.2% (48.2%-85.7%)
        negative predictive value (95% CI) 66.7% (44.7%-84.4%)
    Diagnostic parameters by cut-off OD value at 1.576 in the 1st blood sample-IgM ELISA#
        accuracy (95% CI) 78% (64.0%-88.5%)
        sensitivity (95% CI) 57.7% (36.9%-76.6%)
        specificity (95% CI) 100% (85.8%-100%)
        positive predictive value (95% CI) 100% (78.2%-100%)
        negative predictive value (95% CI) 68.6% (50.7%-83.1%)
AUC of ROC curve of ST diagnosis by IgM ELISA in the 2nd blood samples (95% CI) 0.91 (0.83–0.99)
    Diagnostic parameters by cut-off OD value at 1.599 in the 2nd blood sample-IgM ELISA#
        accuracy (95% CI) 84% (70.9%-92.8%)
        sensitivity (95% CI) 73.1% (52.2%-88.4%)
        specificity (95% CI) 95.8% (78.9%-99.9%)
        positive predictive value (95% CI) 95% (75.1%-99.9%)
        negative predictive value (95% CI) 76.7% (57.7%-90.1%)

* All the PCR-positive patients also fulfilled the diagnostic criteria by IIP.

# The presented cut-off OD values at 1.576 and 1.599 produced the highest accuracy in the ROC analyses.

IQR: interquartile range, ST: scrub typhus, IIP: indirect immunoperoxidase assay, OD: optical density, AUC: area under the curve, ROC: receiver operating characteristic, CI: confidence interval