Creuzot‐Garcher 2011.
Methods |
Study design: randomized, parallel‐group, controlled trial Study site(s): multi‐center (number of sites not stated) Number randomized (total and per group): 181 participants; 90 participants in the treatment group; 91 participants in the placebo group. Unit of randomization (individual or eye): individual Exclusions after randomization: 11 participants in the treatment group and 5 participants in the placebo group were excluded or were lost to follow‐up Losses to follow‐up: 11 participants in the intervention group and 5 participants in the placebo group were excluded or were lost to follow‐up Unit of analysis (individual or eye): individual Reported power calculation? (Y/N): N Reported subgroup analysis? (Y/N): N |
|
Participants |
Baseline characteristics Country: France Age (mean ± SD, range): 61.54 ± 11.87 years total; 61.28 ± 12.15 years in the treatment group; 61.79 ± 11.64 years in the control group Gender: 8 men and 82 women in the treatment group; 7 men and 84 women in the control group Inclusion criteria: 1. 18 to 90 years of age 2. Moderate dry eye, defined as evocative symptoms of dry eye resulting in a bilateral upper dry eye sensation or equal to 2 (on a scale of severity from 0 to 3, 2 and 3 corresponding to moderate to severe), a Schirmer test less than or equal to 10 mm in 5 minutes or tear film break time (TBUT) lower 10 s, lissamine green test score > 3 according to the classification of van Bjisterveld, and corneal fluorescein staining equal to 1, 2, or 3 (Oxford scale) Exclusion criteria: not reported Equivalence of baseline characteristics? (Y/N): Y |
|
Interventions |
Intervention #1 (treatment group): oral capsule containing omega‐3 PUFAs (DHA 196 mg and EPA 14 mg), omega‐6 PUFA (GLA 41 mg or LA 63 mg), various vitamins (C, E, B6, B9, B12), and a trace element (zinc) (Nutrilarm, Laboratoires Thea), twice daily, 2 capsules per day Intervention #2 (control group): placebo capsule (composition and dose not reported), twice daily, 2 capsules per day Length of follow‐up: 6 months Notes: participants were allowed to take their usual eye treatments throughout the study period |
|
Outcomes |
Primary outcome(s): "dryness feeling" at study endpoint Secondary outcome(s): ocular symptoms (burning, stinging, sandy and/or gritty sensation, light sensitivity; reflex tearing; ocular fatigue); Schirmer test; TBUT; corneal fluorescein staining; conjunctival lissamine green staining; HLA‐DR expression, at study endpoint Adverse events reported? (Y/N): N Measurement time points (specify intervals at which outcomes were assessed): baseline, months 1, 3, and 6 Other issues with outcome assessment (eg, quality control for outcomes, if any): none |
|
Notes |
Study dates: not reported Funding source(s): Thea Laboratories funded this clinical study and drafted the article Conflicts of interest: the authors have no financial interest in Thea Laboratories and the product Nutrilarm Publication language: French Registered on clinical trials registry? (Y/N): N |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Method of random sequence generation was not reported |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Allocation concealment was not reported |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | This study was reported as a "double‐masked" study, but details of masking were not reported |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | This study was reported as a "double‐masked" study, but details of masking were not reported |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | High risk | 11 (12.2%) participants in the treatment group and 5 (5.5%) participants in the placebo group were not included in the final analysis |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Unclear risk | No access to study protocol or clinical trials registry |
Other bias | High risk | Thea Laboratories funded this clinical study and drafted the article |