Cell culture |
Mixed, NP/IAF sample |
Cut was made through the middle of the AF with a scalpel blade. Exposed NP and IAF were scooped out with a needle |
Lumbar |
0.01% collagenase |
13
|
Cell culture |
Yes |
Identified and separated under microscope |
Tail |
0.1% pronase and 0.2% collagenase type 2 |
14
|
Cell culture |
No |
Microscopy was used to harvest IVD tissue completely from the end plates |
Coccygeal |
No |
15
|
Cell culture |
Yes |
The disc was cut and bent, forcing the NP to protrude |
Coccygeal |
No |
16
|
Gene expression |
Yes |
Dissected |
Lumbar + caudal |
No |
17
|
Gene expression |
Yes |
NP was scraped off with a scalpel. AF was isolated by a blade under the stereo microscope. The CEP was shaved off with a scalpel |
Lumbar + coccygeal |
No |
18
|
Gene expression |
Yes |
NP and AF from all lumbar IVD were resected separately |
Lumbar |
No |
19
|
Gene expression |
No |
Full tissue examined together |
Lumbar |
No |
20
|
Gene expression |
No |
Carefully dissected |
Unknown |
No |
21
|
Gene expression |
No |
Separated from all other tissues |
Tail/Lumbar |
No |
22
|
Gene expression |
No |
No method listed |
Unknown |
Unknown |
23
|
Gene expression |
No |
Isolated by microdissection |
Thoracic |
No |
24
|
Gene expression |
No |
NP isolated by microdissection |
Lumbar + thoracic |
No |
25
|
Gene expression |
Yes |
NP and AF isolated by microdissection |
Lumbar + thoracic |
No |
26
|