Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 19;14:108. doi: 10.1186/s13012-019-0952-9

Table 2.

Theory analysis elements applied to sustainability frameworks/models/theories

Categories Criteria
Origins

Who are the developers, discipline, country?

Methodological approach

Evidence to support or refute model development

Target domain (practice, education, research, policy)

Motivation(s) for development

Meaning of the framework/model/theory (F/M/T)

Examines conceptual definitions and their use

Identifies concepts (factors),

Inclusiveness of innovation, potential adopters, context factors

Relationship between and among concepts (factors)

Assumptions underlying the model (preconditions)

Schematic presentation

Empirical testability Supported by empirical data (studies)

Parsimonious

Language

Clarity and simplicity while being complete (as per rater)

Use of clear, concise language (as per rater)

Logical adequacy

Logical adequacy (logical structure of the concepts and statements)

Predictions or testable hypotheses are provided

Logical fallacies within the content or structure of the model

Usefulness

Supported by tools

Practicality to nursing and or other target groups.

Contributes to the understanding and predicting of outcomes

Generalizability Clinical context, generalizes (can be extended) to multiple settings

Based on Walker and Avant [36]