Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 15;9(12):e034485. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034485

Table 1.

Descriptive summary of included studies

Variable Total—n (%)
Study characteristics
Geographical location
 North America 94 (62%)
 Europe 43 (28%)
 Australia and New Zealand 10 (7%)
 Asia 5 (3%)
Setting
 Primary care 54 (36%)
 Outpatient specialised 59 (39%)
 Hospital (inpatient and emergency) 26 (17%)
 Nursing homes 5 (3%)
 Interdisciplinary 8 (5%)
Study design/method
 Qualitative (observational) 63 (42%)
  Cross-sectional (observational) 59 (39%)
  Longitudinal (observational) 4 (6%)
 Quantitative 86 (57%)
  Cross-sectional (observational) 63 (41%)
  Longitudinal (observational) 22 (15%)
  Interventional 1 (1%)
 Mixed methods (qualitative and quantitative) 3 (2%)
 Observational (total) 151 (99%)
 Interventional (total) 1 (1%)
Sample size—median (range) 83 (9–9105)
 Observational
  Qualitative 30 (9–160)
  Quantitative 196 (11–9105)
  Mixed methods 50 (32–60)
 Interventional 317
Patients characteristics
Type of condition
 Studies describing multimorbid patients* 58 (38%)
 Studies describing patients with an index disease and comorbidity 29 (19%)
  Diabetes 7 (5%)
  Hypertension 5 (3%)
  Depression/mental illness 4 (3%)
  Cardiovascular disease 4 (3%)
  Osteoarthritis 3 (2%)
  Other 6 (4%)
 Studies describing patients with chronic conditions often associated with multimorbidity 65 (43%)
  Chronic heart failure 10 (7%)
  Advanced cancer 16 (11%)
  Chronic kidney disease 15 (10%)
  COPD 4 (3%)
  Mixed (heart failure, COPD…) 20 (13%)
Age (range)† 60–85
Sex (% female)† 28 905 (51%)

*No further details of included conditions were reported in the majority of studies.

†Studies with overlapping population were excluded (n=10).36 58 59 83 84 105 109 149 161 169

COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.