Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 14;2019:4243853. doi: 10.1155/2019/4243853

Table 2.

The computational results of various algorithms.

Function IRCGA-1 IRCGA-2 IRCGA-3 SPXMOGA HGA MOIRCGA
t ave (s) iterave (times) t ave (s) iterave (times) t ave (s) iterave (times) t ave (s) iterave (times) t ave (s) iterave (times) t ave (s) iterave (times)
f 1 0.1142 89.6250 0.0709 68.1900 0.0679 51.3940 0.2024 624.2430 0.0168 17.1530 0.0155 6.2150
f 2 0.0285 18.2660 0.0108 11.9562 0.0064 5.6540 0.0389 15.8500 0.0041 3.7000 0.0020 2.0330
f 3 0.0842 36.2200 0.0095 13.6253 0.0120 15.7290 0.0824 20.5700 0.0068 4.8800 0.0063 3.1400
f 4 0.0648 22.7620 0.0072 10.6824 0.0088 12.6810 0.1223 275.3800 0.0135 8.4500 0.0046 3.5120
f 5 0.0664 26.5900 0.0186 36.2560 0.0190 38.2210 0.1317 428.9000 0.0179 23.6320 0.0158 20.8310
f 6 0.0260 15.7500 0.0156 20.2610 0.0141 18.6410 0.0271 82.4800 0.0601 26.0600 0.0068 4.9460
f 7 0.1305 41.1900 0.1356 242.6236 0.1287 224.1050 0.1936 263.3200 0.0862 36.6340 0.0198 22.6480
f 8 0.2868 185.0700 0.2568 263.6246 0.2107 451.7110 0.6230 1785.6240 0.1962 156.2300 0.1138 127.0690
f 9 0.1758 59.6400 0.0546 80.6528 0.0357 60.8970 0.1989 96.7800 0.0265 16.5600 0.0120 12.7330
f 10 16.5687 11835.8600 30.6528 31042.6540 27.3205 28412.8500 35.6283 32461.6280 15.7377 10983.8614 13.2385 8414.4000
f 11 0.0217 25.8100 0.0156 32.6246 0.0138 28.1210 0.1867 42.8300 0.0138 8.5320 0.0064 6.9180
f 12 0.0696 50.5600 0.0653 86.6810 0.0350 56.0080 0.2302 127.5760 0.0283 21.6230 0.0194 19.5300
f 13 0.1734 58.6100 0.0236 26.0625 0.0168 11.0350 0.1926 72.9426 0.0156 9.6230 0.0147 7.8780
f 14 0.1431 46.7300 0.0316 65.2681 0.0287 49.7220 0.2136 98.9260 0.0289 33.2310 0.0266 31.3050
f 15 0.1072 34.0400 0.1562 226.3584 0.1037 180.7190 1.8626 236.2580 0.0626 28.5300 0.0221 24.9230
f 16 1.6890 1013.5681 1.7869 1926.5863 1.6216 1711.9600 6.5681 4267.8320 1.0321 1201.6560 0.8660 813.0560