Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 6;2019:9293617. doi: 10.1155/2019/9293617

Table 13.

Comparison of results of the classical benchmark functions between DA, PSO, DE, and FA.

F Meas. DA PSO DE FA
F1 Mean 2.85E − 18 4.2E − 18 2.23e − 19 1.72e − 10
Std. 7.16E − 18 1.31E − 18 1.75e − 19 9.43e − 10
F2 Mean 1.49E − 05 0.003154 6.24e − 12 6.01e − 07
Std. 3.76E − 05 0.009811 2.2e − 12 3.29e − 06
F3 Mean 1.29E − 06 0.001891 27.882386 1.58e − 10
Std. 2.1E − 06 0.003311 12.845742 8.66e − 10
F4 Mean 0.000988 0.001748 0.002883 5.913 − 03
Std. 0.002776 0.002515 0.000577 0.029813
F5 Mean 7.600558 63.45331 9.50058 2.383765
Std. 6.786473 80.12726 3.204155 1.350716
F6 Mean 4.17E − 16 4.36E − 17 2.22e − 19 1.9e − 10
Std. 1.32E − 15 1.38E − 16 1.47e − 19 1.04e − 09
F7 Mean 0.010293 0.005973 0.005256 1.57e − 04
Std. 0.004691 0.003583 0.001649 1.01e − 04
F8 Mean 2857.58 −7.1E +11 −4181.932984 −3566.452419
Std. 383.6466 1.2E + 12 30.0487686 239.113661
F9 Mean 16.01883 10.44724 7.31e − 11 7.462188
Std. 9.479113 7.879807 1.04e − 10 4.41686
F10 Mean 0.23103 0.280137 2.1e − 10 8.47e − 07
Std. 0.487053 0.601817 9.14e − 11 4.64e − 06
F11 Mean 0.193354 0.083463 0.001259 0.053309
Std. 0.073495 0.035067 0.002957 0.053615
F12 Mean 0.031101 8.57E − 11 2.32e − 20 1.92e − 12
Std. 0.098349 2.71E − 10 3.1e − 20 1.05e − 11
F13 Mean 0.002197 0.002197 4.25e − 20 8.21e − 12
Std. 0.004633 0.004633 4.52e − 20 4.5e − 11
F14 Mean 103.742 150 0.99800 0.99800
Std. 91.24364 135.4006 0 1.700065e − 16
F15 Mean 193.0171 188.1951 0.000698 3.77e − 04
Std. 80.6332 157.2834 1.546e − 04 1.853–04
F16 Mean 458.2962 263.0948 1.031628 1.031628
Std. 165.3724 187.1352 6.77e − 16 1.06e − 15
F17 Mean 596.6629 466.5429 0.3978873 3.0
Std. 171.0631 180.9493 0 6.05e − 15
F18 Mean 229.9515 136.1759 2.9999999 3.862782
Std. 184.6095 160.0187 1.27e − 15 2.79e − 15
F19 Mean 679.588 741.6341 3.862782 −3.259273
Std. 199.4014 206.7296 2.71e − 15 0.059789
F20 Mean 3.32199 −3.27047 −3.321797 −9.316829
Std. 3.38E − 06 0.059923 0.001054 2.21393
F21 Mean −10.1532 7.3874 −9.867489 −10.147907
Std. 6.60E − 15 3.11458 0.722834 1.396876
F22 Mean −10.4029 8.5305 −10.381587 −9.398946
Std. 1.51E − 06 3.038572 0.075194 1.99413
F23 Mean −10.5364 9.1328 −10.530836 −10.2809
Std. 2.97E − 07 2.640148 0.02909 1.39948

For each test function, the result of the algorithm that has shown its superiority comparing to the other algorithms for solving a specific function is shown in bold.