Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 28;19:243. doi: 10.1186/s12874-019-0889-3

Table 2.

Summary of frameworks for conducting health research priority setting

Framework Year Organizationa Countrya Principles/values/
characteristics
Stakeholders Scope Outline of process Output
James Lind Alliance (JLA) [5] 2004 National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) UK Partnership Patients, caregivers, clinicians Diagnosis, intervention, care and support

Gather priorities (survey)

Process and verify

Conduct Interim priority setting (survey)

Conduct final priority setting (workshops using nominal group technique)

Top 10 research questions for funders
Council on Health Research for Development Essential National Health Research (COHRED/ENHR) [39] 2000 Council on Health Research for Development International Inclusivity, involvement of a broad range of stakeholders, multidisciplinary and cross-sectorial, partnership, participatory and transparent, systematic analysis of health needs, societal and professional expectations Researchers, decision-makers, health service providers, communities

Establish criteria

Identify research areas (brainstorming, voting, nominal group technique, roundtable etc)

Score against criteria (survey)

Child Health and Nutrition Research Initiative (CHNRI) [41, 46] 2007 Global Forum for Health Research International Systematic, fair, transparent Investors in health research, researchers, general public Fundamental, translation, implementation

Discuss criteria

Select useful and important criteria

Score against criteria (survey)

Elicit stakeholder input (reference group)

Adjust scores with stakeholder input

Dialogue Model [36] 2007 VU University The Netherlands Participatory, respect for experiential knowledge, dialogue between different stakeholders, emergent and flexible design Patients, researchers, health professionals

Explore (informal discussion)

Consult (separate stakeholder consultations, focus groups, interviews, other methods)

Prioritize (survey, focus group, Delphi technique)

Integrate (meeting)

aRefers to developers