Table 1.
Positive affect, Response (13), (80), (82), (84) | Positive affect, Anticipation (13), (83), (84) | Negative affect (13), (80), (82), | Learning/habit (13), (83), (84) | Cognitive control (13), (82), (83), (84) | Interoception (83), (86) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brain circuit | Medial OFC, ventral striatum | Medial OFC, sgACC (subgenual) | Amygdala | Lateral OFC, Dorsal striatum (Caudate, putamen), Hippocampus | DLPFC, dACC (dorsal), IFG | Insula, posterior cingulate |
fMRI tasks | Monetary incentive delay (reward receipt) (87), probabilistic reward task (88), activity incentive Delay task (98) | Monetary Incentive delay (reward anticipation) (87), cue-reactivity (90), attentional bias (89) | Cue reactivity (90) during withdrawal, negative or stress cue reactivity | Instrumental reward-gain and loss-avoidance task (89) | Stop Signal (91), Go-no go (92), Stroop (93), PASAT-M (97) | heartbeat counting task (94), visceral interoceptive attention task (95) |
Cognitive | Reward receipt, response to reward, reward satiation | Motivation, saliency valuation, reward anticipation, drive expectancy, approach/attentional bias | Acute/sustained threat | Stimulus-response conditioned habits, compulsivity, learning reward/loss contingencies | Loss of cognitive control, disinhibition, performance monitoring, action/response selection, low distress tolerance | "Momentary mapping of the body’s internal landscape" (96) during craving and withdrawal |
Behavior | Experience of reward with drug use, response to substance-free reward | Increased: attention/salience of drugs and related stimuli, reward when anticipating drug use. | Experience of withdrawal, stress, anxiety, anhedonia | Drug use as: repetitive, compulsive drive, conditioned response to seek positive affect & avoid/mitigate negative affect, learnt association with people, situations, places | Drug use even when known as harmful and in response to affective distress | Heightened/lowered awareness to drug-related physical & psychological states; increase distance between cue and behavioral response. |
Intervention strategies | Decrease reward value of drug (e.g., methadone or nicotine patches), suppression of mPFC with low frequency rTMS or cTBS; increase reward value of drug-free activities (e.g., behavioral activation, physical activity) | Cognitive bias modification, reappraisal training for drug cues, exposure therapy, motivational interviewing, contingency management | Strategies to address negative affect (e.g., behavioral activation and cognitive reappraisal training), medication that counter stress response, rtfMRI neurofeedback on Insula or sgACC | Strategies that weaken conditioned drug behaviors, memory reconsolidation | Strengthen inhibitory/executive control, inhibitory control training (e.g., Go-No-Go), working memory training, goal management training, stimulating DLPFC with anodal tDCS or high frequency rTMS | Mindfulness-based therapies, physical exercise |
Columns reflect key neurocognitive constructs for addiction research. Identified constructs also map onto the three domains of the Addiction Neuroclinical Assessment (ANA) (11) framework: Positive affect (response and anticipation), Negative affect, and Cognitive control map directly onto the three domains of ANA (i.e., Incentive salience, Negative affectivity and Executive function). Learning/habit is part of Incentive salience (reward learning); Interoception is at the interface of the three ANA domains. Rows reflect functional neuroimaging methods (e.g., fMRI tasks), cognitive/behavioral assessments, and examples of neuroscience informed intervention strategies aligned with each of the identified constructs.
ACC, anterior cingulate cortex; cTBS, continuous theta burst stimulation; DLPFC, dorsolateral PFC; IFG, Inferior Frontal Gyrus; mPFC, medial PFC; OFC, orbitofrontal cortex; PFC, prefrontal cortex; rtfMRI, real-time functional MRI; rTMS, repeated transcranial magnetic stimulation; tDCS, transcranial direct current stimulation.