Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 17;5(1):e000647. doi: 10.1136/bmjsem-2019-000647

Table 1.

Studies and PICO

Study (A–Z) Participants
N, status, gender
Exercise type,
HIIT work interval intensity, MICT intensity
Sessions week-1 Weeks Outcomes
Ciolac et al64 22 healthy ♀ Treadmill walking or running
HIIT: 80%–90% VO2MAX, MICT: 60%–70% VO2MAX
3 16 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Connolly et al65 30 healthy ♀ Ergocycle
HIIT: 30–<100% sprint, MICT: 70%–85% HRPEAK
3 12 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C, TC/HDL-C
Cuddy et al66 27 Ov–Ob ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 100% sprint; MICT: 40%–65% HRR
HIIT: 2–4
MICT: 3–5
8 TRG, HDL-C
Fisher et al76 23 Ov–Ob ♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 85% sprint, MICT: 55%–65% VO2PEAK
HIIT: 3
MICT: 5
6 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Hwang et al67 29 Ov ♀♂ All-extremity ergometer
HIIT: 90% HRPEAK, MICT: 70% HRPEAK
4 8 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Keating et al68 22 Ov ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 120% VO2PEAK, MICT: 50%–65% VO2PEAK
3 12 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Kemmler et al24 65 Ov–MetS ♂ Running
HIIT: 95%–110% HRIAT*, MICT: 70%–82.5% HRIAT*
2–4 16 TRG, HDL-C
Kong et al69 26 Ob♀ Ergocycle
HIIT: max VO2PEAK, MICT: 60%–80% VO2PEAK
4 5 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Lee, et al a61 20 healthy ♂ Ergocyle
HIIT: 85%–90% VO2MAX, MICT: not stated
3 4 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Lee, et al b61 18 healthy ♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 85%–90% VO2MAX, MICT: not stated
3 4 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Lira et al70 20 healthy ♂ Treadmill
HIIT: 100% sVO2PEAK, MICT: 70% sVO2PEAK
3 5 TC, TRG, HDL-C
Maillard et al77 16 Ov–Ob, T2D♀ Ergocycle
HIIT: 80% MHR, MICT: 55%–60% target HR
2 16 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C, TC/HDL-C
Matsuo et al75 26 Ov–MetS ♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 85% VO2PEAK, MICT: 60%–65% VO2PEAK
3 8 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C, TC/HDL-C
Mohr et al71 42 hours, Ov ♀ Free-style swimming
HIIT: 85%–95% MHR, MICT: 72%–79% MHR
3 15 TC, HDL-C, LDL-C
Morales-Palermo et al a62 50 MetS♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT4: 90% MHR, MICT: 70% MHR
3 16 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Morales-Palermo et al b62 49 MetS♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT1:100% MHR, MICT: 70% MHR
3 16 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Moreira et al72 16 Ob ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 60%–72% VO2MAX, MICT: 55%–66% VO2MAX
3 12 TC, TRG
Nybo et al73 17 healthy ♂ Running
HIIT: 85% VO2MAX, MICT: 65% VO2MAX
3 12 TC, HDL-C, LDL-C, TC/HDL-C
Ramos et al58 32 MetS, T2D ♀♂ Walking/running, ergocycle/cycling, swimming
HIIT: 85%–95% HRPEAK, MICT: 60%–70% HRPEAK
HIIT: 3
MICT: 5
16 TRG, HDL-C
Ruffino et al78 16 Ov–Ob, T2D ♂ Ergocycle, walking
HIIT: 80%–90% MHR, MICT: 50%–55% HRR
HIIT: 3
MICT: 5
8 TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Sawyer et al79 18 Ob ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 90%–95% MHR, MICT: 70%–75% MHR
3 8 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Shepherd et al74 78 Ov ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT:>90% MHR, MICT: 70% MHR
HIIT: 3
MICT: 5
10 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C, LDL-C/HDL-C
Thomas et al a63 14 healthy ♂ Running
HIIT: 90%–100% MHR, MICT: 75%–85% MHR
3 11 TC, HDL-C
Thomas et al b63 14 healthy ♂ Running
HIIT: 90%–100% MHR, MICT: 75%–85% MHR
3 11 TC, HDL-C
Tjønna et al55 19 MetS ♀♂ Treadmill walking and running
HIIT: 90% MHR, MICT: 70% MHR
3 8 TRG, HDL-C
Vella et al25 17 Ov–Ob ♀♂ Treadmill, ergocycle, elliptical
HIIT: 75%–80% HRR, MICT: 55%–59% HRR
4 8 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Winding et al80 25 Ov, T2D ♀♂ Ergocycle
HIIT: 95% WPEAK, MICT: 50% WPEAK
3 11 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Winn et al81 16 Ob ♀♂† Treadmill walking and running
HIIT: 80% VO2PEAK, MICT: 55% VO2PEAK
4 4 TC, TRG, HDL-C, LDL-C
Zhang et al82 24 Ob ♀ Treadmill running
HIIT: 50%–95% HRPEAK, MICT: 60%–70% HRPEAK
4 12 TC, TRG

*HRIAT—HR at indvidual aerobic thershold IAt (minimum lactate 2.0 mmol/L).

†Assumed. Gender not specified.

HDL-C, High-density lipoprotein cholesterol; HIIT, High intensity interval training; HR, Heart rate; HRPEAK, Peak heart rate; HRR, Heart rate reserve; IAT, individual anaerobic threshold; LDL-C, Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; MetS, Metabolic Syndrome; MHR, maximal heart rate; MICT, Moderate intensity continuous training; Ob, Obesity; Ov, Overweight; PICO, Participants, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome; TC, Total cholesterol; T2D, Type 2 diabetes mellitus; TRG, Triglycerides; VO2PEAK,VO2MAX, Peak oxygen consumption; WPEAK, Workload or watts.