Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 17;9(12):e034857. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034857

Table 5.

Responses to the survey items according to years of work experience

Item Category 0–10 11–20 >20 Total P value
2. The DS is a communication tool …
2.1 … among physicians. 1/2 303 (98.4%) 261 (96%) 454 (98.7%) 1031 (97.9%) 0.050*
3/4 5 (1.6%) 11 (4%) 6 (1.3%) 22 (2.1%)
2.2 … for the information of patients. 1/2 248 (80.5%) 214 (79.3%) 293 (64.8%) 767 (73.5%) <0.001†‡
3/4 60 (19.5%) 56 (20.7%) 159 (35.2%) 277 (26.5%)
2.3 … for all persons authorised by the patient (legal persons, relatives, caregivers). 1/2 201 (68.4%) 188 (69.4%) 264 (59.5%) 664 (65%) 0.008†‡
3/4 93 (31.6%) 83 (30.6%) 180 (40.5%) 358 (35%)
2.4 The DS that is comprehensible for patients leads to less time-consuming questions. 1/2 207 (69.2%) 193 (73.1%) 281 (63.6%) 691 (67.9%) 0.026‡
3/4 92 (30.8%) 71 (26.9%) 161 (36.4%) 327 (32.1%)
2.5 The DS is usually not read by patients. 1/2 157 (56.3%) 119 (47.6%) 178 (41.9%) 460 (47.5%) 0.001†
3/4 122 (43.7%) 131 (52.4%) 247 (58.1%) 508 (52.5%)
2.6 The patient needn’t understand the DS, as it is explained by the further treating physicians. 1/2 51 (16.7%) 62 (23.5%) 156 (34.6%) 273 (26.4%) <0.001†‡
3/4 254 (83.3%) 202 (76.5%) 295 (65.4%) 761 (73.6%)
2.7 As part of my education I have attended relevant training courses in the field of communication, such as dealing with patients and relatives. 1/2 151 (50.3%) 115 (43.7%) 222 (50.1%) 494 (48.5%) 0.196
3/4 149 (49.7%) 148 (56.3%) 221 (49.9%) 524 (51.5%)
2.8 In my education as a physician, the structure and content of the DS was an integral part. 1/2 128 (42.5%) 137 (50.7%) 241 (53.2%) 512 (49.4%) 0.014†
3/4 173 (57.5%) 133 (49.3%) 212 (46.8%) 525 (50.6%)
2.9 I regularly attend training courses on communication. 1/2 74 (24.3%) 88 (32.8%) 167 (36.9%) 333 (32.1%) 0.001†‡
3/4 230 (75.7%) 180 (67.2%) 286 (63.1%) 706 (67.9%)
3. The following are necessary contents in the DS …
3.1 … diagnosis. 1/2 304 (100%) 273 (100%) 454 (100%) 1044 (100%) 1.000
3/4 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
3.2 … therapy. 1/2 303 (99.7%) 271 (100%) 453 (99.6%) 1040 (99.7%) 0.794
3/4 1 (0.3%) 0 (0%) 2 (0.4%) 3 (0.3%)
3.3 … medical terminology. 1/2 196 (64.9%) 194 (72.4%) 321 (72.6%) 721 (70.4%) 0.055
3/4 106 (35.1%) 74 (27.6%) 121 (27.4%) 303 (29.6%)
3.4 … specific abbreviations. 1/2 58 (19.6%) 64 (24.1%) 103 (23.6%) 227 (22.5%) 0.347
3/4 238 (80.4%) 202 (75.9%) 334 (76.4%) 782 (77.5%)
3.5 … recommendations on further treatment. 1/2 303 (99.7%) 269 (99.3%) 453 (99.8%) 1037 (99.6%) 0.696
3/4 1 (0.3%) 2 (0.7%) 1 (0.2%) 4 (0.4%)
3.6 … prescription of medication. 1/2 300 (99%) 266 (98.2%) 444 (98.2%) 1023 (98.5%) 0.655
3/4 3 (1%) 5 (1.8%) 8 (1.8%) 16 (1.5%)
3.7 … control visits and follow-up appointments. 1/2 299 (99.7%) 270 (99.3%) 442 (97.6%) 1024 (98.7%) 0.041*
3/4 1 (0.3%) 2 (0.7%) 11 (2.4%) 14 (1.3%)
3.8 … behavioural recommendations for the patients. 1/2 290 (97.3%) 254 (94.1%) 411 (92.6%) 968 (94.4%) 0.016†‡
3/4 8 (2.7%) 16 (5.9%) 33 (7.4%) 57 (5.6%)
3.9 … therapy recommendations/report from graduated health and nursing staff. 1/2 133 (45.2%) 124 (48.1%) 221 (50.6%) 486 (48.6%) 0.364
3/4 161 (54.8%) 134 (51.9%) 216 (49.4%) 515 (51.4%)
3.10 … therapy recommendations/report from the clinical social workers. 1/2 166 (56.3%) 134 (51.3%) 239 (55.1%) 546 (54.5%) 0.476
3/4 129 (43.7%) 127 (48.7%) 195 (44.9%) 455 (45.5%)
3.11 … therapy recommendations/report from the medical-technical services (eg, dietology, physiotherapy). 1/2 201 (67.9%) 168 (65.1%) 302 (69.1%) 680 (67.9%) 0.552
3/4 95 (32.1%) 90 (34.9%) 135 (30.9%) 322 (32.1%)
3.12 The content of the DS in its current form is sufficient for further treatment. 1/2 234 (79.6%) 203 (78.1%) 340 (77.1%) 787 (78.2%) 0.724
3/4 60 (20.4%) 57 (21.9%) 101 (22.9%) 220 (21.8%)
3.13 The DS in its present form contributes to increase the individual health literacy of patients. 1/2 145 (52.3%) 129 (52.7%) 182 (45.3%) 461 (49.4%) 0.095
3/4 132 (47.7%) 116 (47.3%) 220 (54.7%) 473 (50.6%)
4.1 In future, the DS should contain further procedures and treatment goals in an understandable way, so that patients themselves can contribute to the improvement of their health. 1/2 245 (81.1%) 224 (84.2%) 333 (75.2%) 813 (79.3%) 0.011‡
3/4 57 (18.9%) 42 (15.8%) 110 (24.8%) 212 (20.7%)
4.2 Should the DS be changed in its current form? 1/2 114 (39.3%) 121 (49%) 209 (49.6%) 449 (46.2%) 0.016†
3/4 176 (60.7%) 126 (51%) 212 (50.4%) 522 (53.8%)

Missing data can occur because of non-response and is not explicitly stated; percentages pertain to available responses.

*No pairwise difference remained significant after Bonferroni correction.

†Significant differences (p<0.017) between 0–10 and >20 years.

‡Significant differences (p<0.017) between 11–20 and >20 years.

DS, discharge summary.