Table 1.
Data source | Government level | Data collection year | Context | Data source inclusion | Data source missing data and exclusions | Data adjustments or categorizations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
APHL National Laboratory Workforce Capacity Assessment11,12 | State and local (laboratory workers) | 2011 | Organizational- and individual-level survey administered to public health, environmental, and agricultural laboratories | 80 (76%) public health, environmental, and agricultural laboratories | 25 laboratories | Workforce data were collected in the occupational categories of administrative or clerical personnel, information technology workers, and laboratory workers |
ASTHO profile survey | State | 2012 | Organizational-level data on state and territorial health department’s responsibilities, structure, planning, quality-improvement activities, and full-time employee workforce | 47 states | 3 states did not respond to survey; additional 5 states did not report workers in occupational categories, and 1 state did not provide workforce data | Data from the 2010 ASTHO profile survey were used to address missing data13; ASTHO data were used for all occupational categories except epidemiologists (CSTE data used), laboratory workers (APHL), and PHNs (UM CEPHS PHN); a proportional reduction of 21.9% was used across all occupational categories to address duplicate counting of state workers in local units |
CSTE National Epidemiology Capacity Assessment14 | State and local (epidemiologists) | 2010 | Organizational-level data characterizing the state-level epidemiology workforce | All 50 states and District of Columbia workforce data for LHD epidemiologists | – | Only state health department data were used; NACCHO profile survey data were used to estimate LHD epidemiologists |
NACCHO profile survey15 | Local | 2013 | Organizational-level data on LHDs’ responsibilities, structure, planning, quality-improvement activities, and full-time employee workforce | 2000 (79%) LHDs, including District of Columbia | 532 LHDs | Community health workers, nursing aides, home health aides, licensed practical or vocational nurses, and animal control workers were included in the other/uncategorized category |
OPM16 | Federal | 2013 | Organizational-level data on USDHHS workers and USDA and EPA workers | All workers in seven occupational categories in the study case definition | The U.S Public Health Service, other noncivilian federal public health workers, and federal contractors. Also, it does not capture the roles of emergency preparedness staff, epidemiologists, or public health informatics specialists | Workers in occupational classifications that might not be specific to public health (e.g., administrative or clerical personnel) were omitted from the USDA and EPA estimates to reduce the possibility of including non–public health workers in the enumeration |
UM CEPHS Public Health Nurse Workforce Survey17 | State and local (public health nurses) | 2012 | Organizational- and individual-level data on all registered PHNs | PHNs employed or contracted by local (81%; 265/327) and state (45%; 45/50) health departments, including those in governmentoperated hospitals | 62 LHDs, and 5 state health departments | Weights were used to create a national estimate for PHNs employed or contracted by LHDs; state data were not weighted |
APHL, Association of Public Health Laboratories; ASTHO, Association of State and Territorial Health Officials; CSTE, Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists; EPA, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency; LHD, local health department; NACCHO, National Association of County and City Health Officials; OPM, U.S. Office of Personnel Management; PHN, public health nurse; UM CEPHS PHN, University of Michigan Center of Excellence in Public Health Workforce Studies Public Health Nurse Workforce Survey.