Table 3.
CMint_Green | G_Breath | H_Rooibos | P_Mind_Chamomile | Peach_Oolong | W_Ginger | F ratio | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Appearance | Attributes2 | |||||||
BrightA | 10.0a1 | 7.3b | 5.3c | 9.2a | 7.1b | 9.8a | 11.793*** | |
TranspA | 7.4ab | 6.1bc | 5.6c | 7.6a | 6.1bc | 7.9a | 4.016** | |
GreenA | 6.1a | 6.0a | 2.8c | 5.7a | 4.0b | 3.5bc | 13.820*** | |
RedA | 2.4d | 4.7c | 11.4a | 2.5d | 6.5b | 2.8d | 87.034*** | |
YellowA | 9.3a | 5.1b | 2.5c | 8.3a | 5.0b | 5.9b | 42.083*** | |
Odor/aroma | ||||||||
MintO | 6.0b | 7.8a | 4.2c | 6.1b | 4.7bc | 3.4c | 11.305*** | |
FlowerO | 5.5a | 7.1a | 6.0a | 5.7a | 6.4a | 3.9b | 4.002** | |
JellyO | 2.2c | 2.7c | 8.8a | 3.3c | 5.5b | 2.2c | 29.991*** | |
BitterO | 3.1bc | 4.8a | 2.0c | 3.4b | 2.5bc | 3.7b | 6.073*** | |
SweetO | 2.2d | 3.0 cd | 9.2a | 4.1c | 6.7b | 6.1b | 33.218*** | |
ASweetO | 1.8d | 2.6 cd | 9.1a | 3.5bc | 4.0b | 4.0b | 33.418*** | |
DMugwortO | 5.4b | 7.1a | 2.9d | 5.0bc | 4.6bc | 3.9 cd | 8.189*** | |
Flavor/taste | ||||||||
MildF | 7.9b | 7.9b | 9.6a | 8.1b | 7.7b | 8.3b | 2.875** | |
ASweetF | 1.8b | 2.4b | 5.1a | 2.6b | 2.4b | 2.5b | 10.321*** | |
BitterF | 4.2b | 3.6bc | 2.8c | 2.4c | 6.2a | 3.1bc | 8.901*** | |
SweetF | 1.9b | 2.4b | 4.3a | 2.7b | 2.5bc | 4.2a | 12.571*** | |
FruitF | 1.6c | 1.7c | 4.7a | 2.3bc | 2.9b | 2.3bc | 11.302*** | |
SourF | 1.9b | 1.9b | 1.5b | 1.9b | 3.0a | 1.7b | 2.497** | |
AstrinF | 4.3b | 2.9c | 2.6c | 2.8c | 6.3a | 2.8c | 12.879*** | |
Texture/mouthfeel | ||||||||
PowderT | 4.3b | 3.7b | 3.2b | 3.1b | 5.7a | 3.3b | 5.932*** | |
Aftertaste | ||||||||
PowerAF | 4.0b | 3.3b | 3.0b | 3.0b | 5.8a | 3.6b | 6.938*** | |
BitterAF | 4.4b | 3.7bc | 2.5c | 2.4c | 6.3a | 3.6bc | 7.319*** | |
SweetAF | 1.7d | 2.3 cd | 3.9a | 3.0bc | 2.4 cd | 3.8ab | 8.289*** | |
Acceptability3 | Overall liking | 4.8c | 5.3bc | 5.7ab | 5.9a | 5.6ab | 4.2d | 10.623*** |
Appearance liking | 5.5bc | 5.3 cd | 6.4a | 5.6bc | 5.9b | 5.0d | 9.185*** | |
Odor liking | 5.7b | 5.5b | 6.0b | 5.8b | 6.8a | 4.3c | 18.333*** | |
Flavor liking | 4.9c | 5.3bc | 5.7ab | 5.9a | 5.5abc | 4.2d | 9.458*** | |
Texture liking | 4.9c | 5.5b | 6.1a | 6.0a | 5.3bc | 4.9c | 8.639*** | |
Attitude | Familiarity | 5.2bc | 5.5b | 5.8ab | 6.2a | 5.5b | 4.9c | 5.120*** |
Try again | 4.3bc | 4.6ab | 5.1a | 5.2a | 4.9a | 3.7c | 6.539*** | |
Recommend | 4.2c | 4.6bc | 5.1ab | 5.2a | 4.9abc | 3.6d | 8.176*** |
1Means within a row not sharing a superscript letter are significantly different (***p < 0.001, **p < 0.05, Duncan’s multiple range test)
2Descriptive analysis: 15-point categorical scale ranging from 1 = “weak” to 15 = “strong.”
3Consumer acceptability test: nine-point hedonic scale ranging from 1 = “dislike extremely” to 9 = “like extremely,” with 5 (midpoint) = “neither like nor dislike.”