Sexton 1984.
Methods | Country: USA Setting: Large university hospital obstetric clinic in Baltimore, Maryland Design: Randomized controlled trial |
|
Participants | 935 pregnant women (Control 472, Intervention 463) who were smoking ≥ 10 cpd immediately prior to pregnancy, enrolled at < 18 weeks gestation. Average age 24.9 years, 40.8% Black, 59.2% White/Other, average education 12.3 years, average cpd 11.2. |
|
Interventions | Control: not clearly specified. Intervention: at least 1 in‐person visit and additional telephone contacts from a health educator. Self‐help information was mailed every 2 weeks, and a monthly newsletter was mailed in the last year of the study. Group sessions were available. Hypnosis was offered but discontinued because of low uptake. Intervention continued until end of pregnancy. A monthly lottery ran from the first newsletter until the end of the intervention period. Participants not smoking in the previous 2 weeks entered a prize draw for a prize (e.g. perfume, makeup) worth around US$30. Participants in both groups received a US$20 gift certificate at the end of the study for participation. A bonus of a US$10 gift certificate was introduced in the last year of the study to participants 2 weeks after they stopped smoking. |
|
Outcomes | Cessation measure not clearly stated, but recorded at 8 months gestation among women who were still pregnant. Verification used SCN. | |
Notes | Participants not still pregnant at 8 months were included in the study but not included in the results. Also in PIP. |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Not stated. |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Not stated. |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | High risk | Inadequate biochemical verification, outcome mainly based on self‐report with possible differential misreport given different levels of support in different study arms. |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Dropout before 8 months was primarily due to early delivery or miscarriage and little difference in rate between groups. |
Other bias | High risk | 16% of Intervention and 17% of Control quit between recruitment and randomization which might bias effect size estimate among baseline smokers. |