Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 10;15(1):e0227585. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0227585

Table 2. Perceptions of disclosure of patient safety incidents.

Categories Item Mean±SD
Open disclosure across harm levels In the event of a medical error causing serious harm, healthcare providers should notify the patients and families. 3.70±0.48
In the event of a medical error causing minor harm, healthcare providers should notify the patients and families. 3.42±0.60
In the event of a medical error causing no harm, healthcare providers should notify the patients and families. 3.00±0.79
Open disclosure across situations Patient safety incidents should be disclosed even when the healthcare providers determine that the patient or families would not fully understand the explanation. 3.43±0.59
Patient safety incidents should be disclosed even when the healthcare providers determine that the patients or families would not want to know about the incident. 3.20±0.70
Patient safety incidents should be disclosed even when the healthcare providers determine that the patients or families would not find out about the incident. 3.34±0.64
Patient safety incidents should be disclosed even when the healthcare providers determine that it would not be beneficial for the patient or families to find out about the incident. 3.20±0.69
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents should be determined based on the severity of the medical error.* 2.28±0.93
Patient safety incidents should be disclosed based on whether informing the patient or families about the medical error would benefit them.* 2.25±0.89
Justification
of open disclosure
I think apologizing for a patient safety incident is important in my values. 3.65±0.54
It is necessary to disclose patient safety incidents because the patient would want to know about patient safety incidents. 3.66±0.51
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents is needed even if it causes loss and disadvantage for the hospital and healthcare providers. 3.56±0.54
Healthcare providers have the responsibility to inform the patients and families about their or their team’s errors. 3.59±0.51
Negative consequences of open disclosure Patients and families will react negatively to disclosure of patient safety incidents.* 2.44±0.78
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents will increase medical litigation.* 2.16±0.72
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents will damage the reputation of the healthcare providers.* 2.71±0.78
Healthcare providers will be subject to disciplinary actions by healthcare institutions if they disclose patient safety incidents.* 2.32±0.71
Healthcare providers will be subject to criticism by their colleagues if they disclose patient safety incidents.* 2.70±0.77
Positive consequences of open disclosure Patients and families will have more trust in healthcare providers who disclose patient safety incidents. 3.18±0.74
They are more likely to recommend to others around them healthcare providers who disclose patient safety incidents. 3.16±0.73
They are more likely to return for treatment to healthcare providers who disclose patient safety incidents. 3.17±0.73
Healthcare providers who disclose patient safety incidents are more likely to provide better services. 3.42±0.63
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents will lead healthcare providers themselves to be more interested in patient safety issues. 3.58±0.52
Open disclosure of patient safety incidents will reduce the healthcare providers’ sense of guilt. 2.89±0.80
Facilitators of open disclosure Open disclosure of patient safety incidents requires higher ethical awareness by the healthcare providers. 3.63±0.51
Education and training programs are needed for open disclosure of patient safety incidents. 3.62±0.52
Healthcare institutions need personnel to support open disclosure of patient safety incidents. 3.52±0.58
Healthcare institutions need a positive culture of patient safety that supports open disclosure of patient safety incidents. 3.62±0.52
It is necessary to provide guidelines for open disclosure of patient safety incidents. 3.64±0.51
It is necessary to establish apology laws to protect healthcare providers. 3.46±0.62

* Reverse-coded items