Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 2;10(1):e030873. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-030873

Table 3.

Previous studies on rubella seronegativity in women that included more than 1000 subjects and were published within the past 10 years, grouped by WHO region

WHO region Publication year N Country Seronegativity (%) Population Reference Measurement method
AFR 2009 7430 South Africa 6.2 WCBA Schoub et al 26 Bio-Rad Platelia Rubella IgG ELISA
AMR 2009 8939 Brazil 28.4 Pregnant Inagaki et al 27 Q-Preven IgG-DBS kit
AMR 2011 9610 Brazil 11.6 Pregnant Artimos de Oliveira et al 28 Beckman Coulter Access RUBELLA IgG ChLIA or bioMérieux VIDAS RUB IgG II ELFA
AMR 2016 54 717 Brazil 4.5 Pregnant Avila Moura et al 29 Q-Preven IgG-DBS kit
AMR 2009 5783 Canada 7.0 Pregnant McElroy et al 30 Hemagglutination inhibition test
AMR 2013 459 963 Canada 4.4 WCBA Lim et al 31 Abbott AxSYM Rubella IgG MEIA
AMR 2015 157 763 Canada 15.9 Pregnant Lai et al 32 Abbott ARCHITECT Rubella IgG CMIA
EMR 2014 4062 Kuwait 6.8 Pregnant Madi et al 33 Abbott ARCHITECT Rubella IgG CMIA
EMR 2013 2284 Morocco 9.8 Pregnant Belefquih et al 34 Siemens Enzygnost Anti-Rubella-Virus IgG EIA
EMR 2014 10 276 Saudi Arabia 8.7 Pregnant Alsibiani et al 35 Dade Behring ELISA BP III
EUR 2012 424 876 England 2.6 Pregnant Byrne et al 36 Microgen Mercia Rubella G EIA
EUR 2013 1090 Germany 1.6 Pregnant Enders et al 37 Hemagglutination inhibition test
EUR 2013 74 810 Ireland 6.2 Pregnant O’Dwyer et al 38 Method not described
EUR 2012 2385 Italy 8.0 Pregnant De Paschale et al 39 DiaSorin ETI-RUBEK-G PLUS EIA
EUR 2015 22 681 Spain 5.9 Pregnant Vilajeliu et al 40 Siemens ADVIA Centaur Rubella G ChLIA
EUR 2010 41 637 Sweden 4.2 Pregnant Kakoulidou et al 41 Abbott AxSYM Rubella IgG MEIA
EUR 2009 1972 Turkey 3.9 Pregnant Tamer et al 42 Abbott AxSYM Rubella IgG MEIA
EUR 2012 5959 Turkey 1.9 Pregnant Uysal et al 43 bioMérieux VIDAS RUB IgG II ELFA
EUR 2011 11 987 UK 4.4 Pregnant Matthews et al 44 DiaSorin ETI-RUBEK-G EIA
EUR 2016 19 046 UK 6.3 Pregnant Ogundele et al 45 Roche E602 MODULAR analyzer
SEAR 2011 2224 Nepal 9.2 WCBA Upreti et al 46 Enzygnost Anti-Rubella-Virus IgG EIA
SEAR 2014 1988 Vietnam 28.9 Pregnant Miyakawa et al 47 bioMérieux Mini VIDAS EIA
WPR 2008 1020 Australia 2.7 WCBA Nardone et al 48 Siemens Enzygnost Anti-Rubella-Virus IgG EIA
WPR 2008 2741 Japan 6.7 Pregnant Okuda et al 49 Hemagglutination inhibition test
WPR 2013 13 924 Japan 2.7 Pregnant Hanaoka et al 50 Hemagglutination inhibition test
WPR 2014 20 363 Japan 4.7 Pregnant Yamada et al 51 Hemagglutination inhibition test
WPR 2017 782 293 China 33.8 WCBA Liu et al 52 Method not described
WPR 2011 43 640 Taiwan 10.9 Pregnant Lin et al 53 Abbott AxSYM Rubella IgG MEIA and Beckman Coulter Access RUBELLA IgG ChLIA
WPR 2012 14 090 Taiwan 6.5 Pregnant Lin et al 54 Abbott AxSYM Rubella IgG MEIA
WPR 2019 327 637 Republic of Korea 8.7 WCBA This study Abbott ARCHITECT Rubella IgG CMIA

AFR, Africa region; AMR, American region; EMR, Eastern Mediterranean Region; EUR, European region; SEAR, South-East Asian region; WCBA, women of childbearing age; WPR, Western Pacific region.