Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 8;2020(1):CD011935. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011935.pub2

2. Baseline characteristics.

Study Intervention(s) and comparator(s) Duration of intervention (duration of follow‐up) Description of participants Trial period Country Setting
Michielsen 2013 I1: BCG full dose Weekly for 6 weeks, each group with specific maintenance programme. Intermediate‐risk non‐muscle invasive urothelial carcinoma of the bladder Belgium Hospital
C1: MMC 40 mg
Mangiarotti 2008 I1: BCG Tice BCG weekly for 6 weeks, then 1 × month for 1 year.
MMC 1 × week for 8 weeks, then 1 × month for 1 year (follow‐up 42–45 months).
Intermediate‐risk non‐muscle invasive urothelial carcinoma of the bladder, Ta‐T1 G1‐2 Italy Hospital
C1: MMC 40 mg
Friedrich 2007 I1: BCG RIVM 2 × 108 cfu All 3 treatments for 6 weeks; long‐term MMC continued for 3 years Intermediate‐risk pTa G1 tumours or pTa G2 up to pT1 tumours (G1‐3) 1995–2002 Germany Hospital
C1: MMC 20 mg
C2: MMC 20 mg long‐term
Ojea 2007b; Ojea 2007a I1: BCG Connaught strain low‐dose 27 mg Once a week for 6 weeks, followed by another 6 instillations every 2 weeks for 12 weeks. Intermediate‐risk Ta G2 and T1 G1‐2 without Cis 1995–1998 Spain Hospital, multicentre
I2: BCG Connaught strain very low‐dose 13.5 mg
C1: MMC 30 mg
Di Stasi 2003 I1: BCG Pasteur 81 mg Weekly for 6 weeks, a further 6 weeks for non‐responders and a follow‐up 10 monthly treatments. Multifocal Cis and most had concurrent pT1 1994–2001 Italy Hospital, multicentre
C1: MMC 40 mg
C2: MMC 40 mg electromotive
Malmström 1999 I1: BCG 120 mg Danish strain Weekly for 6 weeks, then monthly for 1 year and then every 3 months for 3 years. Ta G1‐3 or T1 G1‐2 1987–1992 Sweden‐Norway Hospital, multicentre
C1: MMC 40 mg
Witjes 1998a I1: BCG RIVM MMC: weekly for 4 weeks, then monthly for 5 months.
BCG: weekly for 6 weeks.
pTa and pT1 including Cis 1985–1986 Europe Hospital, multicentre
C1: MMC 30 mg
Krege 1996 I: TUR BCG: weekly for 6 weeks, then monthly for 4 months.
MMC: every 2 weeks for 12 months, then once a months for 2 years.
pTa/1 G1‐3 1985–1992 Germany Hospital, multicentre
C1: BCG 120 mg Connaught strain
C2: MMC 20 mg
Witjes 1996a; Witjes 1996b I1: BCG RIVM 5 × 108 bacilli BCG: weekly for 6 weeks, a further 6 weeks for non‐responders.
MMC: once a week for 1 month, then once a month for 6 months, for non‐responders monthly another 3 months.
Ta or T1 including Cis 1987–1990 Hospital, multicentre
I2: BCG Tice 5 × 108 bacilli
C1: MMC 30 mg
Lamm 1995 I1: BCG Tice 50 mg (5 × 108 cfu) Weekly for 6 weeks and at 8 and 12 weeks, then monthly to 1 year. Ta or T1 at increased risk Hospital, multicentre
C1: MMC 20 mg
Rintala 1991 I1: BCG Pasteur strain 75 mg Weekly for 1 month, then once per months for 2 years. Cis G1‐3, Ta‐T1 G1‐3 1984–1987 Hospital, multicentre
C1: MMC 20–40 mg

BCG: Bacillus Calmette‐Guérin; Cis: carcinoma in situ; cfu: colony‐forming units; MMC: mitomycin C; NaCl: sodium chloride, TUR: transurethral resection.