Skip to main content
. 2013 Jun 4;2013(6):CD004878. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004878.pub4

Richter 1998.

Methods Parallel design, 2 arms
Single‐centre, conducted in the UK (affiliation: Royal Alexandra Children's Hospital Brighton)
Participants Inpatients
Inclusion/exclusion criteria 
 Inclusion criteria: age < 12 mo.; no history of wheezing; hospitalised with clinical features of bronchiolitis (tachypnoea, recession, wheezing, crepitations)
 Exclusion criteria: congenital abnormality; pre‐existing pulmonary disease; immune deficiency; need for assisted ventilation
Participant characteristicsAll groups 
 Sample size: randomised (N): 40, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 39 (ITT with available case analysis was performed), analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 40 (ITT with all data was performed)
GROUP 1 
 Sample size: randomised (N): 21, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 20, analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 21
Age: 4.08 (median); 1.1 to 10.15 (range) months
 Males, N (%): 12 (57)
 RSV status: 16 (76) positive
 Atopic status: 18 (86) present (family)
GROUP 2 
 Sample size: randomised (N): 19, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 19, analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 19
Age: 2.7 (median); 0.9 to 7.82 (range) months
 Males, N (%): 10 (52.6)
 RSV status: 17 (89) positive
 Atopic status: 12 (63) present (family)
Interventions GROUP 1 (with glucocorticoid) 
 Drug name: budesonide
 Dose: 1 mg in 2 mL then 0.5 mg in 2 mL
 Mode of administration: nebulised with O2, flow 6 L/minute
 Timing/duration: 1 mg/2mL ‐ twice daily for 5 d; 0.5 mg/2 mL ‐ 2 x daily for 6 weeks
GROUP 2 
 Drug name: placebo
 Dose: 2 mL 0.9% saline
 Mode of administration: nebulised with O2, flow 6 L/minute
 Timing/duration: twice daily for 6 weeks
Additional co‐interventions for all groups: no restrictions on use of other drug treatments
 Protocolised use of bronchodilators with glucocorticoids: no
Outcomes Primary outcome 
 Clinical scale adapted from Wesley et al, based on respiratory rate, O2 concentration required to keep O2 > 92%, wheeze, degree of recession, and need for IV fluids or nasogastric tube feeding (at 48 hours; other time points*)
Clinical scale*: RDAI, 17‐point score based on wheezing and retractions (at 4 hours; other time points*)
Outcome used to calculate sample size 
 Wheezing episodes in the early months after bronchiolitis (no specific time point or definition)
Secondary outcomes 
 Duration and maximum requirements of O2 therapy; LOS; hospital re‐admission (6 mo.); symptoms (diary; based on Noble et al, daytime and nighttime cough and wheeze)#¶; inhaled bronchodilators#¶; length and growth rate#
 *time points: twice daily until discharge, 48 hours
 #time points: daily until 6 weeks
 ¶time points: until 6 months, when symptomatic and by 6‐week periods
Funding Astra Clinical Research Unit and Rockinghorse Appeal
Notes Study did not report any study‐level subgroup analyses
This study contributed to the following comparisons in this review: steroid versus placebo
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk Randomised; no further information provided
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk Randomisation details held by hospital pharmacy
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) 
 Health care use ((re)admissions, LOS, return visits) Unclear risk Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals"
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) 
 Clinical parameters (severity scales, SpO2, respiratory and heart rate) Unclear risk Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals"
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) 
 Other outcomes (adverse events, others) Unclear risk Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals"
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) 
 Health care use ((re)admissions, LOS, return visits) Low risk 1 participant with missing outcome data
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) 
 Clinical parameters (severity scales, SpO2, respiratory and heart rate) Low risk 1 participant with missing outcome data
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) 
 Other outcomes (adverse events, others) Low risk 1 participant with missing outcome data
Selective reporting (reporting bias) Unclear risk Not all outcomes reported are specified in methods
Other bias Low risk No significant baseline imbalances; no other sources of bias
Overall risk of bias Unclear risk > 1 domain as unclear risk of bias