Richter 1998.
Methods | Parallel design, 2 arms Single‐centre, conducted in the UK (affiliation: Royal Alexandra Children's Hospital Brighton) |
|
Participants | Inpatients Inclusion/exclusion criteria Inclusion criteria: age < 12 mo.; no history of wheezing; hospitalised with clinical features of bronchiolitis (tachypnoea, recession, wheezing, crepitations) Exclusion criteria: congenital abnormality; pre‐existing pulmonary disease; immune deficiency; need for assisted ventilation Participant characteristics All groups Sample size: randomised (N): 40, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 39 (ITT with available case analysis was performed), analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 40 (ITT with all data was performed) GROUP 1 Sample size: randomised (N): 21, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 20, analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 21 Age: 4.08 (median); 1.1 to 10.15 (range) months Males, N (%): 12 (57) RSV status: 16 (76) positive Atopic status: 18 (86) present (family) GROUP 2 Sample size: randomised (N): 19, analysed ‐ trial primary outcomes (N): 19, analysed ‐ review primary outcomes (N): 19 Age: 2.7 (median); 0.9 to 7.82 (range) months Males, N (%): 10 (52.6) RSV status: 17 (89) positive Atopic status: 12 (63) present (family) |
|
Interventions |
GROUP 1 (with glucocorticoid)
Drug name: budesonide
Dose: 1 mg in 2 mL then 0.5 mg in 2 mL
Mode of administration: nebulised with O2, flow 6 L/minute
Timing/duration: 1 mg/2mL ‐ twice daily for 5 d; 0.5 mg/2 mL ‐ 2 x daily for 6 weeks GROUP 2 Drug name: placebo Dose: 2 mL 0.9% saline Mode of administration: nebulised with O2, flow 6 L/minute Timing/duration: twice daily for 6 weeks Additional co‐interventions for all groups: no restrictions on use of other drug treatments Protocolised use of bronchodilators with glucocorticoids: no |
|
Outcomes |
Primary outcome
Clinical scale adapted from Wesley et al, based on respiratory rate, O2 concentration required to keep O2 > 92%, wheeze, degree of recession, and need for IV fluids or nasogastric tube feeding (at 48 hours; other time points*) Clinical scale*: RDAI, 17‐point score based on wheezing and retractions (at 4 hours; other time points*) Outcome used to calculate sample size Wheezing episodes in the early months after bronchiolitis (no specific time point or definition) Secondary outcomes Duration and maximum requirements of O2 therapy; LOS; hospital re‐admission (6 mo.); symptoms (diary; based on Noble et al, daytime and nighttime cough and wheeze)#¶; inhaled bronchodilators#¶; length and growth rate# *time points: twice daily until discharge, 48 hours #time points: daily until 6 weeks ¶time points: until 6 months, when symptomatic and by 6‐week periods |
|
Funding | Astra Clinical Research Unit and Rockinghorse Appeal | |
Notes | Study did not report any study‐level subgroup analyses This study contributed to the following comparisons in this review: steroid versus placebo |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Randomised; no further information provided |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Randomisation details held by hospital pharmacy |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) Health care use ((re)admissions, LOS, return visits) | Unclear risk | Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals" |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) Clinical parameters (severity scales, SpO2, respiratory and heart rate) | Unclear risk | Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals" |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) Other outcomes (adverse events, others) | Unclear risk | Double‐blind; "Throughout the study, the investigators, nursing and medical staff, and parents were unaware to which treatment group infants had been assigned"; "both budesonide and placebo were supplied in plastic repsules prepared by Astra pharmaceuticals" |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) Health care use ((re)admissions, LOS, return visits) | Low risk | 1 participant with missing outcome data |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) Clinical parameters (severity scales, SpO2, respiratory and heart rate) | Low risk | 1 participant with missing outcome data |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) Other outcomes (adverse events, others) | Low risk | 1 participant with missing outcome data |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Unclear risk | Not all outcomes reported are specified in methods |
Other bias | Low risk | No significant baseline imbalances; no other sources of bias |
Overall risk of bias | Unclear risk | > 1 domain as unclear risk of bias |