Skip to main content
. 2014 Jun 17;2014(6):CD004381. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004381.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Applebaum 1979 Not intervention study (assessment)
Bettison 1996 Not MT (AIT ‐ only music listening)
Blackstock 1978 Not intervention study (assessment)
Bonnel 2003 Not intervention study (assessment)
Boso 2007 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Brown 1994 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Brown 2003 Not intervention study (assessment)
Bruscia 1982 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Carroll 1983 Not MT (only sung instructions)
Chilcote‐Doner 1982 Not MT (rhythmic strobe and drumbeat)
Clauss 1994 Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABACA design)
Cooley 2012 Not MT (speech and language training with music)
Dawson 1998 Not intervention study (assessment)
Diez Cuervo 1989 Not intervention study (assessment)
Edelson 1999 Not MT (AIT ‐ only music listening)
Edgerton 1994 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Finnigan 2010 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Frissell 2001 Not intervention study (assessment)
Goldstein 1964 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Gore 2002 No usable data (unclear outcome measure)
Griggs 1997 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Not intervention study (assessment)
Hadsell 1988 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Not ASD (Rett syndrome)
Hairston 1990 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Heaton 1999 Not intervention study (assessment)
Heaton 2003 Not intervention study (assessment)
Hillier 2012 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Kern 2006 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Kern 2007 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Kolko 1980 Not intervention study (assessment)
Krauss 1982 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Not ASD (apraxia, language delay)
Laird 1997 Not RCT or CCT (uncontrolled design)
Lee 2004 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Li 2011 Not possible to isolate MT from other interventions
Lim 2007 Not MT (speech training with music)
Litchman 1976 Not MT (listening to recorded nursery rhymes)
Lundqvist 2009 Not MT (presentation of preset vibroacoustic stimuli)
Ma 2001 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Mahlberg 1973 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Miller 1979 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Mottron 2000 Not intervention study (assessment)
Mudford 2000 Not MT (AIT/only music listening)
O'Connell 1974 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
O'Dell 1998 Not MT (music listening)
O'Loughlin 2000 Not RCT or CCT ‐ includes three case series where all received the same treatment (no. 1, 3, 4) and one case series with an ABA design (no. 2)
Pasiali 2004 Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABAB design)
Rao 2001 Not MT (headphones with versus without music)
Sandiford 2013 Not MT (speech training with music)
Saperston 1973 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Schmidt 1976 Not RCT or CCT (case series, AB design)
Starr 1998 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Staum 1984 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Stephens 2008 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Stevens 1969 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Thaut 1987 Not intervention study (assessment)
Thaut 1988 Not intervention study (assessment)
Toolan 1994 Not RCT or CCT (case series)
Watson 1979 Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABCA design)
Wimpory 1995 Not RCT or CCT (case study)
Wood 1991 Not MT (music listening)

MT ‐ music therapy; AIT ‐ auditory integration training; RCT ‐ randomised controlled trial; CCT ‐ controlled clinical trial; ASD ‐ autism spectrum disorder; ABA, ABAB, AB ‐ type of trial where interventions A and B are given in this order; ABCA, ABACA ‐ type of trial where interventions A, B, and C are given in this order