Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Applebaum 1979 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Bettison 1996 | Not MT (AIT ‐ only music listening) |
Blackstock 1978 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Bonnel 2003 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Boso 2007 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Brown 1994 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Brown 2003 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Bruscia 1982 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Carroll 1983 | Not MT (only sung instructions) |
Chilcote‐Doner 1982 | Not MT (rhythmic strobe and drumbeat) |
Clauss 1994 | Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABACA design) |
Cooley 2012 | Not MT (speech and language training with music) |
Dawson 1998 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Diez Cuervo 1989 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Edelson 1999 | Not MT (AIT ‐ only music listening) |
Edgerton 1994 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Finnigan 2010 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Frissell 2001 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Goldstein 1964 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Gore 2002 | No usable data (unclear outcome measure) |
Griggs 1997 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) Not intervention study (assessment) |
Hadsell 1988 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) Not ASD (Rett syndrome) |
Hairston 1990 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Heaton 1999 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Heaton 2003 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Hillier 2012 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Kern 2006 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Kern 2007 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Kolko 1980 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Krauss 1982 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) Not ASD (apraxia, language delay) |
Laird 1997 | Not RCT or CCT (uncontrolled design) |
Lee 2004 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Li 2011 | Not possible to isolate MT from other interventions |
Lim 2007 | Not MT (speech training with music) |
Litchman 1976 | Not MT (listening to recorded nursery rhymes) |
Lundqvist 2009 | Not MT (presentation of preset vibroacoustic stimuli) |
Ma 2001 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Mahlberg 1973 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Miller 1979 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Mottron 2000 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Mudford 2000 | Not MT (AIT/only music listening) |
O'Connell 1974 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
O'Dell 1998 | Not MT (music listening) |
O'Loughlin 2000 | Not RCT or CCT ‐ includes three case series where all received the same treatment (no. 1, 3, 4) and one case series with an ABA design (no. 2) |
Pasiali 2004 | Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABAB design) |
Rao 2001 | Not MT (headphones with versus without music) |
Sandiford 2013 | Not MT (speech training with music) |
Saperston 1973 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Schmidt 1976 | Not RCT or CCT (case series, AB design) |
Starr 1998 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Staum 1984 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Stephens 2008 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Stevens 1969 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Thaut 1987 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Thaut 1988 | Not intervention study (assessment) |
Toolan 1994 | Not RCT or CCT (case series) |
Watson 1979 | Not RCT or CCT (case series, ABCA design) |
Wimpory 1995 | Not RCT or CCT (case study) |
Wood 1991 | Not MT (music listening) |
MT ‐ music therapy; AIT ‐ auditory integration training; RCT ‐ randomised controlled trial; CCT ‐ controlled clinical trial; ASD ‐ autism spectrum disorder; ABA, ABAB, AB ‐ type of trial where interventions A and B are given in this order; ABCA, ABACA ‐ type of trial where interventions A, B, and C are given in this order