Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 10;8(12):588. doi: 10.3390/plants8120588

Table 2.

Analyses of variance of data for different physio-biochemical attributes of quinoa (Chenopodium quinoa) plants raised from seeds treated with varying (25 and 50 mM) levels of proline and chilling stress.

Source of Variation df Shoot Fresh Weight Shoot Fresh Weight Shoot Dry Weight Root Fresh Weight Root Dry Weight Shoot Length Root Length
Cultivars (Cv) 1 0.558 * 0.016 *** 0.0027 ** 0.000006 ns 19.65 *** 6.33 ns
Chilling Stress (CS) 1 3.091 *** 0.0113 ** 0.0047 *** 0.00001 * 2.89 ns 107.8 ***
Presowing (Pre) 2 1.216 *** 0.0052 * 0.0038 *** 0.00005 ns 10.11 ns 69.21 ***
Cv x CS 1 0.098 ns 0.004 ns 0.00005 ns 0.0000009 ns 0.027 ns 26.18 *
Cv x Pre 2 0.32 * 0.0008 ns 0.00006 ns 0.000000015 ns 1.66 ns 8.07 ns
CS x Pre 2 0.0261 ns 0.00005 ns 0.000008 ns 0.000001 ns 0.663 ns 2.09 ns
Cv x CS x Pre 2 0.0305 ns 0.0005 ns 0.00002 ns 0.0000007 ns 0.231 ns 15.93 ns
Error 24 0.0834 0.00113 0.000002 0.00001 1.394 4.87
Chl. a Chl. b Chl. a/b Total Chl. Carotenoids Proline
Cultivars (Cv) 1 1.23 *** 0.777 *** 34.58 *** 0.0532 ns 0.015 * 445.49 *
Chilling Stress (CS) 1 0.703 *** 0.951 *** 5.49 * 3.29 *** 0.0006 ns 611.02 **
Presowing (Pre) 2 0.273 ** 0.223 *** 1.80 ns 0.933 *** 0.011 ** 909.4 ***
Cv x CS 1 0.559 *** 0.462 *** 0.497 ns 2.04 *** 0.0054 ns 5.33 ns
Cv x Pre 2 0.159 * 0.052 * 2.83 * 0.039 ns 0.00001 ns 3.88 ns
CS x Pre 2 0.044 ns 0.060 * 0.136 ns 0.205 ** 0.000008 ns 120.9 ns
Cv x CS x Pre 2 0.069 ns 0.0809 ** 2.46 ns 0.0035 ns 0.0009 ns 262.5 *
Error 24 0.0342 0.0131 0.772 0.024 0.002 72.99
Glycine Betaine Ascorbic Acid Hydrogen Peroxide MDA Catalase Peroxidase
Cultivars (Cv) 1 633.52 ** 28.13 ** 1158762.5 *** 26.82 ns 0.142 ** 0.00002 ns
Chilling Stress (CS) 1 1386.6 *** 19.09 * 317579.2 ** 266.2 *** 0.049 ns 0.199 ***
Presowing (Pre) 2 414.3 ** 49.14 *** 67016.8 ns 34.64 ns 0.050 ns 0.0302 **
Cv x CS 1 424.9 * 1.98 ns 21085.4 ns 3.5 ns 0.019 ns 0.07 **
Cv x Pre 2 6.90 ns 1.392 ns 10304.3 ns 19.68 ns 0.0015 ns 0.00001 ns
CS x Pre 2 0.648 ns 15.92 * 75875.6 ns 8.54 ns 0.0047 ns 0.0104 ns
Cv x CS x Pre 2 27.11 ns 12.34 * 7958.5 ns 0.75 ns 0.0079 ns 0.00008 ns
Error 24 58.01 3.04 28230.2 10.89 0.0152 0.00008
SOD Total Soluble Sugars Total Phenolics Total Free Amino Acids
Cultivars (Cv) 1 22.35 *** 244.92 * 570.6 *** 0.003 ns
Chilling Stress (CS) 1 18.34 ** 121.4 ns 1348.4 *** 0.022 **
Presowing (Pre) 2 2.14 ns 72.27 ns 41.28 ns 0.005 ns
Cv x CS 1 0.292 ns 6.33 ns 0.307 ns 0.0037 ns
Cv x Pre 2 0.782 ns 29.98 ns 1.195 ns 0.00001 ns
CS x Pre 2 0.682 ns 93.94 ns 12.003 ns 0.0002 ns
Cv x CS x Pre 2 0.206 ns 22.75 ns 0.284 ns 0.00008 ns
Error 24 1.56 36.22 18.87 0.0019

ns = non-significant; *, ** and *** = significant at 0.05, 0.01 and 0.001 levels, respectively.