Autogenous Bone Grafts |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Complete histocompatibility, no opportunity for infection from graft donor, and promotes strong fusion as being the only graft having all three pillars of spinal fusion |
Quality of graft is dependent on patient age and metabolic activity [13], and there is a risk of blood loss and local pain at the extraction site [14] |
Bone Marrow Aspirates |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Minimal donor site morbidity |
Must be incorporated with scaffolding or allografts [18] |
Allografts |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
Lacks donor site morbidity and can be combined with MSCs [13] |
Requires sterilization, process of sterilization alters the biomechanical properties of bones [22], and there is a possible risk of infection with HBV or HCV [21] |
Demineralized Bone Matrices |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Lower fusion rates than autogenous grafts [30,31], higher rates of spinal collapse [32], and suffers from possible contamination during its production process [33] |
Ceramics |
Yes |
No |
No |
Can be supplemented with osteogenic cells and growth factors [35], has a long shelf life, has zero risk for disease transfer, and is easily and cheaply manufactured [36,37] |
Lacks cortical stability and osteogenic properties [24] |