Table 1.
Study/Year [Country] | RCT | Blinded OIT | Comparator | Co-Treatment | Entry OFC Type | Rush Phase | Peanut OIT Dose (mg peanut protein) | Exit OFC | Subjects Receiving OIT | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Starting | Target Maintenance | |||||||||
Anagnostou 2011 [UK] | No | No | None | None | DBPCFC | No | 0.5 | 800 | Open | 22 |
Anagnostou 2014 [UK] | Yes | No | Peanut Avoidance | None | DBPCFC | No | 2 | 800 | DBPCFC | 94 |
Bird 2015 [USA] | No | No | None | None | DBPCFC | No | Variable | 2000 | DBPCFC | 11 |
Bird 2018 [USA] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | None | DBPCFC | Yes | 0.5 to 6 | 300 | DBPCFC | 29 |
Blumchen 2010 [Germany] | No | No | None | None | DBPCFC | Yes | Variable | 125 | DBPCFC* | 23 |
Blumchen 2019 [Germany] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | None | Open | No | Variable | 125 or 250 | Open | 31 |
Fauquert 2018 [France] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | None | DBPCFC | No | 2 | 400 | DBPCFC | 21 |
Hofmann 2009 [USA] | No | No | None | None | None | Yes | 0.1 to 50 | 300 | None | 28 |
Howe 2019 [USA] | Yes | No | Symptoms as side effects (n = 24) or symptoms as positive signals (n = 26) | Antihistamine | None | No | 1.3 | 240 | None | 50 |
Jones 2009 [USA] | No | No | None | None | None | Yes | 0.1 to 50 | 300 | Open | 39 |
Kukkonen 2017 [Finland] | No | No | Peanut Avoidance | Antihistamine | DBPCFC | No | 0.1 | 800 | DBPCFC | 39 |
MacGinnitie 2017 [USA] | Yes | No | Omalizumab + Oral OIT [n = 27] Vs. Oral OIT alone [n = 8] | Omalizumab | DBPCFC | Yes | 0.5 to 250 | 2000 | Open | 35 |
Nachshon 2018 [Israel] | No | No | None | None | Open | Yes | Variable | 1200 or 3000 | Open | 145 |
Nagakura 2018a [Japan] | No | No | None | Antihistamine & Montelukast | DBPCFC | Yes | Variable | 795 | OFC* | 22 |
Nagakura 2018b [Japan] | No | No | None | Antihistamine | Open | Yes | Variable | 133 | OFC* | 24 |
Narisety 2015 [USA] | Yes | No | Oral Vs. Sublingual OIT | None | Open | Yes | 0.1 to 6 | 2000 | Open | 11 |
Nozawa 2014 [Japan] | No | No | None | None | DBPCFC | Yes | Variable | 1750 or 3500 | None | 18 |
PALISADE 2018 [North America & Europe] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | None | DBPCFC | Yes | 0.5 to 6 | 300 | DBPCFC | 372 |
Reier-Nilsen 2019 [Norway] | Yes | No | Peanut Avoidance | None | DBPCFC | No | 5 or 1 | 5000 | None | 57 |
Schneider 2013 [USA] | No | No | None | Omalizumab | DBPCFC | Yes | 0.05 to 250 | 4000 | DBPCFC | 13 |
Tang 2015 [Australia] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | Probiotic† | None | Yes | 0.1 to 12 | 2000 | DBPCFC | 31 |
Tao 2017 [Australia] | No | No | None | None | Open | No | Boiled | 2500 | Open | 14 |
Varshney 2011 [USA] | Yes | Yes | Placebo | None | None | Yes | 0.1 to 6 | 4000 | DBPCFC | 19 |
Vickery 2017 [USA] | Yes | No | 300 mg [n = 20] Vs. 3000 mg [17] maintenance dose | None | Open | Yes | 0.05 to 3 | 300 vs. 3000 | DBPCFC | 37 |
Wasserman 2019 [USA] | No | No | None | None | None | Yes | 0.001 to 10 mg/0.002 to 2.05 mg | 3000 | None | 270 |
Yu 2012 [USA] | No | No | None | None | None | Yes | Variable | 4000 | None | 24 |
Zhong 2019 [Singapore] | No | No | None | Probiotic† | Open | No | 0.5 | 3000 | Open | 9 |
Abbreviations: RCT, randomised controlled trial; OIT, oral immunotherapy; OFC, oral food challenge; DBPCFC, double blind placebo controlled food challenge.
*OFC completed after 2 weeks of peanut avoidance.
†Lactobacillus rhamnosus.