Skip to main content
. 2019 Jul 11;97(1):156–167. doi: 10.1111/cge.13586

Table 4.

Included studies executive functioning domain and calculated effect sizes

Authors N Age Comparison Subdomain(s) Instrument(s) + Type(s) Results Effect sizes
Lee et al, 2015

15 XXY

15 XXX

5‐18 years Control group Daily life executive functioning BRIEF (P) XXX/XXY > controls N/A
Ross et al, 2008 47 XXY 4‐18 years Normed scores Sustained attention—omissions C(K)CPT (C) XXY > controls N/A
Sustained attention—variability XXY > controls N/A
Sustained attention—reaction time XXY > controls N/A
Inhibition DKEFS‐CWIT (C) n.s.
Mental flexibility n.s.
Ross et al, 2009

93 XXY

21 XYY

4‐18 years Control group Sustained attention—omissions C(K)CPT (C) XXY > XYY = controls d xxy = .83***
Sustained attention—variability XXY = XYY > controls

d xxy = .80***

d xyy = .86***

Sustained attention—reaction time XXY = XYY > controls

d xxy = 1.02***

d xyy = 1.04***

Sustained attention—commissions n.s.
Inhibition DKEFS‐CWIT (C) XYY < XXY < controls d xyy = 1.09***
Mental flexibility XYY < XXY < controls d xyy = 1.71***
Van Rijn & Swaab, 2015 40 XXX/XXY 9‐18 years Control group Sustained attentional control ANT (C) XXX/XXY < controls d = .33*
Inhibition XXX/XXY < controls d = .38*
Mental flexibility XXX/XXY < controls d = .45*
Visual working memory XXX/XXY < controls d = .68**
Focused attention n.s.
Verbal working memory n.s.
Daily life executive functioning DEX (P) XXX/XXY < controls d = 1.37***
Samango‐Sprouse et al, 2018

44 XXY (NL)

54 XXY (United States)

8‐18 years Normed scores Sustained attention; % significant impaired ANT (C) 19%‐57% N/A
Inhibition; % significant impaired 26%‐28% N/A
Mental flexibility; % significant impaired 35%‐36% N/A

Note: *** High clinical significance; ** Moderate clinical significance; * Low clinical significance; N/A, not applicable; n.s., not significant; † higher scores denote more problems.

Abbreviations: ANT, Amsterdam Neuropsychological Tasks; BRIEF, Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function; C, Performance Task Child; C(K)CPT, Conners' (Kiddie) Continuous Performance Test; DEX, Dysexecutive Questionnaire; DKEFS‐CWIT; Delis‐Kaplin Executive Functioning Color‐Word Interference Test; P, Parent Report.