Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Med Image Anal. 2019 Nov 8;60:101602. doi: 10.1016/j.media.2019.101602

Table 4.

Comparison results for the proposed method and other methods without data augmentation on the testing dataset.

Dice coefficient Mean distance Jaccard Sensitivity Precision ASSD
Mean±std p-value Mean± std p-value Mean± std p-value Mean±std p-value Mean± std p-value Mean±std p-value
FCNN 0.8020±0.1037 3.1e–27 9.6083±4.8746 4.1e–26 0.6806±0.1316 1.4e–27 0.7614±0.1404 1.1e–25 0.8690±0.1118 1.7e–15 9.9992±5.4128 1.2e–27
Deeplab 0.8724±0.0639 8.4e–26 6.2596±2.9087 2.0e–21 0.7788±0.0899 7.1e–26 0.8759±0.1002 3.2e–12 0.8829±0.0788 2.9e–19 6.3022±3.1650 8.8e–25
SegNet 0.8894±0.0619 2.9e–20 7.3921±6.1747 2.2e–23 0.8061± 0.0949 1.6e–20 0.8809±0.0917 5.4e–9 0.9080±0.0814 2.3e–10 6.1979±4.6609 4.8e–21
Unet 0.8899±0.0578 1.7e–20 7.5227±4.1757 8.8e–26 0.8062±0.0883 1.2e–20 0.8780±0.0900 4.7e–12 0.9121±0.0745 5.8e–09 6.2147±3.3764 7.9e–24
PSPnet 0.8869±0.0548 2.0e–22 7.2514±4.0461 3.2e–23 0.8008±0.0828 1.0e–22 0.8818±0.0885 6.1e–10 0.9027±0.0741 4.4e–16 6.0621±3.0109 4.7e–22
Deeplabv3+ 0.8965±0.0698 2.4e–13 6.4669±3.8065 1.9e–18 0.8187±0.1014 2.0e–13 0.8643±0.1100 9.6e–13 0.9424±0.0474 - 5.3100±2.9109 5.7e–16
Bnet 0.9303±0.0499 - 3.6130±2.3447 - 0.8729±0.0708 - 0.9220±0.0690 - 0.9442±0.0482 - 3.4792±1.9618 -