Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Med Image Anal. 2019 Nov 8;60:101602. doi: 10.1016/j.media.2019.101602

Table 5.

Comparison results for the proposed method and other methods with data augmentation on the testing dataset.

Dice coefficient Mean distance Jaccard Sensitivity Precision ASSD
Mean±std p-value Mean± std p-value Mean± std p-value Mean±std p-value Mean± Std p-value Mean±std p-value
FCNN 0.9179±0.0471 4.8e–17 4.2072±2.4922 4.2e–16 0.8514±0.0731 2.4e–17 0.9221±0.0730 4.8e–06 0.9207±0.0622 6.0e–10 4.1182±2.3157 1.5e–16
Deeplab 0.9236±0.0370 1.9e–18 3.7369±1.8737 4.5e–14 0.8601±0.0603 1.3e–18 0.9175±0.0584 3.0e–15 0.9344±0.0528 1.9e–03 3.7779±1.8596 1.6e–16
SegNet 0.9298±0.0409 2.3e–11 4.0753±6.4316 3.6e–10 0.8713±0.0651 1.6e–11 0.9311±0.0542 2.1e–05 0.9330±0.0600 2.0e–04 3.8450±4.9187 8.9e–10
Unet 0.9245±0.0403 2.7e–14 4.0987±2.5463 5.8e–14 0.8620±0.0650 2.6e–14 0.9132±0.0621 3.3e–13 0.9423±0.0614 4.3e–02 3.8643±2.1498 1.1e–14
PSPnet 0.9372±0.0305 1.8e–05 3.3055±2.0240 2.7e–04 0.8837±0.0580 3.4e–04 0.9491±0.0440 - 0.9292±0.0577 1.0e–09 3.1471 ± 1.6704 1.7e–03
DeeplabV3+ 0.9311±0.0354 2.8e–08 3.5080±2.2860 5.0e–05 0.8732±0.0610 1.7e–05 0.9307±0.0517 1.6e–05 0.9369±0.0612 2.1e–03 3.1837±1.9855 8.1e–05
Bnet 0.9427±0.0453 - 2.9189±1.9823 - 0.8943±0.0663 0.9439±0.0645 0.9458±0.0413 - 2.8701±1.8671