Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 24;15(1):e0228338. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0228338

Table 2. Genera identified in the caeca and crops with a MRA (%) > 1 in at least one treatment (i.e., day 1, high dose (HD) 14 and 35 days, low dose (LD) 14 and 35 days, control (C) 14 and 35 days).

Mean relative abundance (%) (standard error)
Day 1 HD 14d HD 35d LD 14d LD 35d C 14d C35 d
Caeca
Faecalibacterium 3.272 (0.917) 1.8 (0.088) 9.827 (1.251) 1.762 (0.066) 9.08 (1.756) 2.159 (0.136) 5.617 (0.714)
Ruminococcus 5.904 (0.86) 8.995 (0.487) 7.237 (0.2) 10.173 (0.991) 7.807 (0.336) 9.072 (0.999) 8.092 (0.537)
Eubacterium 4.541 (0.834) 7.153 (0.196) 6.629 (0.08) 7.309 (0.27) 6.67 (0.101) 7.071 (0.349) 6.489 (0.256)
Bacteroides 3.795 (0.528) 7.824 (0.792) 5.911 (0.211) 6.806 (0.877) 5.445 (0.303) 7.427 (0.865) 5.539 (0.419)
Clostridium 15.108 (2.482) 30.129 (1.687) 26.298 (0.711) 29.813 (0.829) 25.812 (0.845) 28.04 (1.594) 23.775 (0.676)
Subdoligranulum 2.461 (0.694) 1.723 (0.144) 2.963 (0.206) 1.513 (0.076) 3.947 (0.474) 5.176 (2.221) 4.588 (1.16)
Blautia 1.881 (0.366) 4.264 (0.587) 2.388 (0.181) 3.634 (0.354) 2.403 (0.078) 3.431 (0.463) 3.217 (0.338)
Lactobacillus 17.268 (4.092) 1.956 (0.49) 1.813 (0.351) 1.93 (0.71) 2.49 (0.439) 1.155 (0.165) 6.129 (1.509)
Bacillus 1.169 (0.251) 1.379 (0.088) 1.612 (0.079) 1.511 (0.165) 1.476 (0.065) 1.341 (0.055) 1.462 (0.061)
Roseburia 0.948 (0.154) 1.621 (0.097) 1.589 (0.042) 1.619 (0.061) 1.517 (0.063) 1.519 (0.112) 1.311 (0.062)
Butyrivibrio 0.859 (0.172) 1.56 (0.067) 1.53 (0.036) 1.631 (0.091) 1.563 (0.05) 1.634 (0.083) 1.37 (0.043)
Ethanoligenens 0.678 (0.116) 1.235 (0.062) 1.485 (0.021) 1.422 (0.169) 1.578 (0.049) 1.766 (0.171) 1.362 (0.14)
Holdemania 0.753 (0.116) 1.305 (0.048) 1.433 (0.058) 1.355 (0.063) 1.379 (0.052) 1.392 (0.035) 1.23 (0.029)
Streptococcus 1.019 (0.16) 2.045 (0.553) 1.41 (0.085) 1.226 (0.07) 1.357 (0.123) 1.191 (0.086) 1.224 (0.1)
Anaerotruncus 0.655 (0.06) 1.471 (0.102) 1.26 (0.093) 1.777 (0.226) 1.386 (0.159) 1.498 (0.135) 1.094 (0.089)
Desulfitobacterium 0.54 (0.135) 1.043 (0.045) 1.052 (0.029) 1.092 (0.06) 1.004 (0.03) 1.111 (0.055) 0.955 (0.031)
Dorea 0.894 (0.138) 1.37 (0.058) 1.022 (0.028) 1.384 (0.136) 1.051 (0.043) 1.251 (0.154) 1.147 (0.08)
Coprococcus 0.694 (0.097) 1.077 (0.042) 0.9 (0.012) 1.108 (0.089) 0.899 (0.033) 0.992 (0.104) 0.945 (0.056)
Enterococcus 1.253 (0.268) 0.843 (0.039) 0.834 (0.02) 0.827 (0.047) 0.803 (0.015) 0.712 (0.046) 0.788 (0.048)
Escherichia 7.608 (3.938) 1.296 (0.433) 0.497 (0.191) 0.942 (0.386) 0.686 (0.456) 0.619 (0.225) 1.008 (0.467)
Eggerthella 0.436 (0.107) 0.391 (0.015) 0.45 (0.013) 0.516 (0.026) 0.468 (0.019) 0.523 (0.043) 1.072 (0.161)
Shigella 1.148 (0.589) 0.203 (0.072) 0.075 (0.03) 0.153 (0.065) 0.105 (0.07) 0.098 (0.036) 0.157 (0.074)
Crops
Faecalibacterium 1.248 (0.417) 0.487 (0.191) 0.158 (0.066) 0.887 (0.153) 0.092 (0.067) 0.126 (0.015) 0.056 (0.015)
Ruminococcus 4.094 (1.287) 2.559 (1.298) 0.334 (0.155) 2.535 (0.366) 0.146 (0.1) 0.495 (0.067) 0.137 (0.048)
Eubacterium 2.407 (0.724) 1.389 (0.673) 0.231 (0.095) 1.475 (0.164) 0.126 (0.076) 0.374 (0.031) 0.127 (0.029)
Bacteroides 2.294 (0.455) 0.799 (0.427) 0.181 (0.078) 1.149 (0.187) 0.121 (0.08) 0.262 (0.028) 0.092 (0.02)
Clostridium 9.578 (2.476) 4.683 (2.122) 0.918 (0.338) 5.655 (0.506) 0.485 (0.311) 1.415 (0.098) 0.483 (0.105)
Subdoligranulum 1.597 (0.393) 0.302 (0.095) 0.125 (0.063) 0.539 (0.066) 0.085 (0.076) 0.104 (0.014) 0.051 (0.024)
Blautia 1.579 (0.533) 1.15 (0.57) 0.152 (0.082) 0.864 (0.116) 0.053 (0.043) 0.253 (0.022) 0.049 (0.024)
Lactobacillus 23.077 (5.819) 59.931 (12.434) 80.761 (6.911) 55.188 (9.781) 81.496 (14.061) 79.209 (5.72) 87.45 (4.139)
Bacillus 0.993 (0.129) 0.611 (0.158) 0.576 (0.235) 0.752 (0.212) 0.171 (0.028) 0.551 (0.13) 0.332 (0.08)
Streptococcus 0.699 (0.095) 7.536 (4.791) 1.134 (0.562) 1.987 (0.272) 0.612 (0.236) 4.404 (2.505) 1.708 (0.78)
Enterococcus 0.628 (0.045) 1.138 (0.446) 0.982 (0.425) 0.641 (0.072) 0.385 (0.103) 1.298 (0.279) 1.05 (0.323)
Escherichia 12.382 (6.287) 0.878 (0.404) 0.636 (0.287) 3.344 (1.948) 9.436 (9.311) 2.092 (1.34) 0.97 (0.801)
Staphylococcus 0.27 (0.113) 0.134 (0.023) 3.001 (1.338) 0.175 (0.038) 0.276 (0.079) 0.175 (0.035) 1.014 (0.391)
Corynebacterium 0.165 (0.117) 0.031 (0.017) 3.648 (2.112) 0.046 (0.024) 0.207 (0.058) 0.011 (0.003) 1.13 (0.79)
Shigella 1.858 (0.988) 0.11 (0.054) 0.095 (0.043) 0.491 (0.292) 1.468 (1.446) 0.312 (0.195) 0.15 (0.123)
Xanthomonas 1.859 (0.416) 0.87 (0.595) 0.039 (0.023) 2.025 (1.183) 0.043 (0.033) 0.306 (0.047) 0.012 (0.005)
Klebsiella 0.137 (0.058) 0.051 (0.024) 0.033 (0.012) 1.016 (0.627) 0.188 (0.171) 0.126 (0.051) 1.161 (1.149)