Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 13;2013(12):CD003388. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003388.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Abbasnejad 2007 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Arntz 2007 TFCBT vs TFCBT.
Barabasz 2013 Unclear how many participants were suffering ASD as opposed to PTSD (length of time since trauma was not reported). Not a true RCT.
Boudewyns 1990 Group treatment with exposure or conventional one‐to‐one counselling.
Chemtob 1997 Treatment designed for anger vs PTSD with anger measures used as primary outcomes.
Classen 2001 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Classen 2010 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Cole 2007 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Davis 2007 Only 67.3% of participants met diagnostic criteria for PTSD before entry into study.
Difede 2007a Only 67.7% of participants met diagnostic criteria for PTSD before entry into study.
DuHamel 2010 Only 19% of participants met diagnostic criteria for PTSD before entry into study.
Dunn 2007 Treatment for depression not PTSD.
Echeburua 1996 Trauma < 3 months before entry into study.
Edmond 1999 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Falsetti 2001 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Falsetti 2005  
Foa 2006 Trauma < 3 months before entry into study.
Frommberger 2004 Psychological therapy vs pharmacotherapy.
Gidron 1996 Not psychological treatment.
Ginzberg 2009 No diagnosis of PTSD.
Glynn 1999 Not an individual or group therapy.
Hiari 2005 Participants only required to meet re‐experiencing and avoidance criteria of DSM‐IV criteria for PTSD.
Jaberghaderi 2004 Participants under 18 (study included in Gillies 2012).
Knaevelsrud 2007 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Lange 2001 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Lange 2003 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Litz 2007 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Maercker 2006 Only 48% of participants met diagnostic criteria for PTSD. Remainder had a diagnosis of "sub‐syndromal PTSD".
Mithoefer 2011 TFCBT vs TFCBT.
Najavits 2006 Mean age of participants 16 years [study included in Gillies 2012]
Paunovic 2001 TFCBT vs TFCBT.
Price 2007 No formal diagnosis of PTSD made.
Rabe 2008 Only 48.5% of participants met diagnostic criteria for PTSD before entry into study.
Rothbaum 2006 Pharmacotherapy versus pharmacotherapy plus psychological therapy.
Ryan 2005 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Schaal 2009 Age range 14 ‐ 28.
Shapiro 1989a No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Sloan 2004 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Sloan 2005 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.
Spence 2011 Information on duration was not collected. Unkown whether participants had acute/chronic PTSD.
Tarrier 1999 Compared trauma focused cognitive therapy with exposure therapy therefore both treatments = TFCBT.
Tucker 2007 Pharmacotherapy versus placebo.
Van Emmerik 2008 Only 46.6% diagnosis of PTSD.
Watson 1997 Considered 3 different types of relaxation training with no other comparison group.
Wilson 1995 < 50% PTSD at entry to study.
Yeomans 2010 No formal diagnosis of PTSD.