Table 1.
Year of data | Location | Treatment sites | Patient episodes | Patients | Costs included | Measurement of staff time | Valuation of resource use | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
GROUP A | |||||||||
1 | Cromwell et al. | 2001–2003 | USA | 40 | 834 | Medicare | Direct care staff, ancillary indirect/overhead | Self-reported logs, direct observation, 7 days | CMI multiplied with average costs |
2 | Gaines et al. | 2003 | New Zealand | 8 | 2848 | No restriction | medical/health staff, ancillary, indirect/overhead | Self-reported summaries (nurses), 6 month | Top-down allocation |
3 | Hirdes et al. | 1999–2000 | Canada | 34 | 1998 | No restriction | Clinical staff excl. physicians | Self-reported logs, 1 day/7 days | Avg. wages |
4 | Buckingham et al. | 1996 | Australia | 22 | 6554 | No restriction | Direct care staff, indirect/overhead | Self-reported logs, 3 months | Top-down allocation |
5 | Yamauchi | 1993 | Japan | 17 | 2284 | No restriction | Physicians, nurses, therapists | Self-reported logs, 1 day/7 days | Avg. wages |
6 | Fries et al. | Unclear | USA | 51 | 890 | Long-staying | Nurses, physicians, psychologists, other therapists | Self-reported logs, 1 day/7 days | Avg. wages |
GROUP B | |||||||||
7 | Iglesias & Alonso Villa | 2003 | Spain | 1 | 163 | Long-staying | Nurses, aides | Self-reported logs, 7 days | None |
8 | Autio | Unclear | USA | 1 | 42 | No restriction | Nurses, counselors | Obs. patient sampling, rand. 10 min interval, ten shifts | None |
Ancillary = e.g. radiology, pharmacy, pathology; CMI = case-mix index; obs.: = observational; rand. = randomised.