Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 17;18:271–286. doi: 10.1016/j.csbj.2020.01.002

Table 2.

Detrimental mutations and their corresponding stability changes that influence holoenzyme assembly, rifampin and RNA interactions.

Method Wild-type residue Residue position Average stability effect Maximum stabilizing effect Mutant residue Maximum destabilizing effect Mutant residue
mCSM-Stability (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 −0.795 −0.072 L −1.701 H
H 451 −1.214 −0.104 Y −1.898 S
G 459 −0.713 −0.381 V −1.201 W
P 489 −1.135 −0.507 R −1.771 G
K 884 −1.227 −0.190 L −2.298 S
H 1035 −0.419 0.600 Y −1.421 G



mCSM-ppi (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 −0.254 0.395 H −0.820 R
H 451 −0.652 −0.050 S −1.451 M
G 459 −0.397 0.237 H −1.042 R
P 489 −0.738 −0.138 W −1.372 R
K 884 −0.105 0.160 D −0.685 R
H 1035 −0.754 0.115 W −1.726 R



mCSM-NA2 (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 −1.538 4.922 W −3.857 D
H 451 −1.300 5.147 W −3.632 D
G 459 2.289 8.556 W −0.221 D
P 489 1.926 8.195 W −0.582 D
K 884 0.221 6.647 W −2.130 D
H 1035 0.847 7.295 W −1.484 D



mCSM-lig (log-affinity change) S 437 −0.646 −0.484 L −1.062 R
H 451 −0.510 −0.076 W −0.777 E
G 459 −0.981 −0.715 A −1.236 R
P 489 −0.598 −0.254 L −0.917 R
K 884 −0.156 −0.368 D −0.925 R
H 1035 −0.121 0.097 V −0.501 E



SDM (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 0.087 2.320 V −1.900 P
H 451 −0.756 1.290 L −2.800 G
G 459 −2.842 −1.780 V −3.800 P
P 489 −0.432 1.440 Y −1.070 E
K 884 0.108 1.270 V −1.820 P
H 1035 −0.200 0.590 V −1.410 P



MAESTRO (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 −0.21 −0.14 K 0.24 F
H 451 −0.12 −0.05 G 0.22 R
G 459 −0.23 −0.17 S 0.33 W
P 489 −0.26 −0.22 H 0.31 M
K 884 −0.20 −0.14 G 0.25 M
H 1035 −0.27 −0.25 P 0.31 Y



CUPSAT (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 2.70 7.98 I −1.12 G
H 451 2.01 6.92 W −3.25 K
G 459 −2.51 5.00 K −5.53 C
P 489 −2.76 −0.84 A −5.47 M
K 884 −2.99 3.42 I −8.03 H
H 1035 −1.07 2.15 C −3.23 Y



Imutant 2.0 Structure (Sign of prediction) S 437 4.05 9.00 A 1.00 F
H 451 6.00 8.00 G 3.00 L
G 459 6.63 9.00 N 3.00 I
P 489 7.11 9.00 G 3.00 L
K 884 6.42 9.00 G 2.00 M
H 1035 4.63 8.00 G 2.00 L



PROVEAN (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 −4.79 −3.00 A −7.00 W
H 451 −8.66 −5.73 Y −10.37 C
G 459 −8.10 −6.00 A −10.00 L
P 489 −9.04 −7.99 A −10.99 F
K 884 −5.97 −2.91 R −7.75 C
H 1035 −8.98 −5.79 Y −10.61 C



Imutant 2.0 Sequence (Sign of prediction) S 437 4.47 7.00 F 0.00 H
H 451 3.21 7.00 P 0.00 F
G 459 3.53 7.00 H 0.00 A
P 489 6.89 9.00 G 5.00 L
K 884 3.53 8.00 V 0.00 G
H 1035 2.95 6.00 G 0.00 V



FOldX4 (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 2.79 −1.44 I 12.39 R
H 451 1.78 −0.74 L 4.39 W
G 459 9.14 3.96 A 20.76 H
P 489 3.04 2.11 N 4.79 R
K 884 1.06 −2.12 Y 9.77 L
H 1035 0.77 −1.47 P 5.69 Y



ENCoM (ΔΔSvib in kcal/mol/K) S 437 −0.44 0.48 G −1.50 W
H 451 0.34 0.97 G −0.46 W
G 459 −0.91 −0.29 A −1.55 W
P 489 −0.16 0.14 G −0.82 F
K 884 0.18 0.96 G −0.60 W
H 1035 0.19 0.73 G −0.26 W



DynaMut (ΔΔG in kcal/mol) S 437 2.87 6.99 L −2.08 G
H 451 −0.74 2.17 Y −3.43 T
G 459 1.93 3.29 N −0.25 S
P 489 0.94 3.26 F −0.72 S
K 884 0.14 3.69 W −1.87 E
H 1035 0.21 2.38 W −2.29 G