Table II.
Techniques used to build a case for credibility have been described as ‘tokens of scientific legitimacy’ (modified with permission from Sipp et al).51
Token | Explanation |
---|---|
Accreditations | Asserting certification of products or practices by international standards organizations |
Boards and advisers | Convening scientific or medical advisory boards featuring prominent academics and business leaders |
Trial registration | Registering trials to attract patients willing to pay to participate |
Ethics review | Usage of the term ‘ethics review’ to convey legitimacy to products or procedures |
Location | Renting laboratory or business space within a legitimate scientific or government institution |
Membership | Joining established academic or professional societies to suggest legitimacy by association |
Outcome registries | Publication of open-ended voluntary monitoring data sets rather than controlled clinical trials |
Patenting | Suggesting that patent applications or grants indicate clinical use |
Publication | Publishing research and commentary in journals with limited anonymous peer review |
Rationales | Citing preclinical and other research findings to justify clinical application |
Self-regulation | Forming organizations to self-regulate |
Technical language | Using scientific-sounding words that suggest academic rigor |
Endorsements | Providing expert opinions or celebrity comments on unsupported clinical uses |