Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 1;102-B(2):148–154. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.102B2.BJJ-2019-1104.R1

Table II.

Techniques used to build a case for credibility have been described as ‘tokens of scientific legitimacy’ (modified with permission from Sipp et al).51

Token Explanation
Accreditations Asserting certification of products or practices by international standards organizations
Boards and advisers Convening scientific or medical advisory boards featuring prominent academics and business leaders
Trial registration Registering trials to attract patients willing to pay to participate
Ethics review Usage of the term ‘ethics review’ to convey legitimacy to products or procedures
Location Renting laboratory or business space within a legitimate scientific or government institution
Membership Joining established academic or professional societies to suggest legitimacy by association
Outcome registries Publication of open-ended voluntary monitoring data sets rather than controlled clinical trials
Patenting Suggesting that patent applications or grants indicate clinical use
Publication Publishing research and commentary in journals with limited anonymous peer review
Rationales Citing preclinical and other research findings to justify clinical application
Self-regulation Forming organizations to self-regulate
Technical language Using scientific-sounding words that suggest academic rigor
Endorsements Providing expert opinions or celebrity comments on unsupported clinical uses