Skip to main content
. 2007 Jul 18;2007(3):CD003494. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003494.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Anderson 1992 intervention only one session
Baillargeon 1998 no RCT, CCT, or CPPT (single‐case experimental design)
Barkham 1989 intervention not performed by GP
Beusterien 2000 no psychosocial intervention (information only)
Blomhoff 2001 intervention performed by GPs, non‐specialist physicians and psychiatrists (no separate analysis)
Bowman 2000 no psychosocial intervention (telephone assessment)
Brody 1990 intervention only one session
Calfas 1996 intervention only one session
Catalan 1984 less than two standardised face‐to‐face contacts
Durand 2002 no psychosocial intervention (self‐help manual)
Fleming 1997 intervention performed by GPs and general internists (no separate analysis)
Fleming 1999 intervention performed by GPs and general internists (no separate analysis)
Gask 1992 no RCT, CCT or CPPT (narrative review)
Goldstein 1999 intervention performed by GPs and general internists (no separate analysis)
Heatley 2005 no data on outcomes in patients
Horst 1997 less than two standardised face‐to‐face contacts (second contact merely optional)
Issakidis 1999 intervention not performed by GP
Katzelnick 2000 no psychosocial intervention (pharmacotherapy)
King 1998 no psychosocial intervention (education of GPs)
King 2002 no standardised number of face‐to‐face contacts (effects of training rather than effects of applying intervention)
Kottke 1989 no psychosocial intervention (advice and information only)
Malt 1999 intervention only in combination with (placebo) pharmacotherapy
McLeod 1997 intervention not performed by GP
Morriss 1999 no RCT, CCT or CPPT (before‐ and after‐training study)
Ockene I 1999 intervention not performed by GP
Ockene J 1991 intervention not performed by GP
Patel 1988 intervention performed by GP in combination with intervention by nurse (no separate analysis)
Peveler 1999 intervention not performed by GP
Pill 1998 intervention performed by GPs and nurses (no separate analysis)
Scott 1997 intervention not performed by GP
Simkin 1997 intervention performed by GPs and general internists (no separate analysis)
Skinner 1984 intervention not performed by GP
Swinson 1992 intervention not performed by GP (not even in primary care)
Wadden 1997 intervention not performed by GP
Wallace 1988 no psychosocial intervention (advice and information only)
White 1990 intervention not performed by GP
Whitehead 2002 no standardised face‐to‐face contacts required
Wilson 1988 intervention only in combination with nicotine gum